Start typing a card name and use the auto-complete feature to quickly select the card you're trying to add. Enter a quantity and add that card to your sideboard!
Submit a list of cards below to bulk import them all into your sideboard. Post one card per line using a format like "4x Birds of Paradise" or "1 Blaze", you can even enter just the card name by itself like "Wrath of God" for single cards.
I've become concerned with the amount of decks going unloved in this community. It's great that everyone loves budget decks so much, but I see way too many cool and interesting, attention deserving decks go completely ignored, so here's what I propose:Comment on any deck that has no previous comments on it (Just liking a deck won't count, but by all means feel free to like, also!), and post the link to it in the comments here, and I will comment on THREE of your least commented decks in return. The comment can be just about anything, from a helpful suggestion to just a freindly "This is cool, I like how this deck does X!" will suffice!So, click over to the unloved page, start giving some love, and I will return to the community by commenting on THREE of all participater's decks! Happy supporting!
This deck has been viewed 11,790 times.
your a sweetheart <3
Permalink
Aw shucks, I'm just trying to spread the help and smiles around!
I love this idea
Love hearing that!
http://www.mtgvault.com/dreddmor/decks/tokenmill-draft/
http://www.mtgvault.com/kazzong/decks/archbound-junky/sample-hand/
Time to give some love
great idea
Tanks man !)
http://www.mtgvault.com/tether/decks/snek-snak-snake/
http://www.mtgvault.com/freakazoid37/decks/rug-experimental-sb-help/
thank yo for shining a light on this i only have one unloved deck I've only posted decks that have won me games and one of them has high comment rate between me and one person and it gets viewed and no like s or comments i also recently put back up my the do the worm deck and it is now un loved i work hard on my decks so they can win and the mtg community dose not give any advice or help ant way i thought thats what this site is for thank you for putting this up @Burtonernie I've been playing since alpha i like standard and modern and i post things and not a comment or likes or help thanks again
guys go see my new deck heliod's army #tokens
http://www.mtgvault.com/drshagnasty/decks/the-kaalia-redux/, saw kalia and though hey nice
I know exactly what you mean! I love going around and commenting on other decks (such as this one http://www.mtgvault.com/glitch42420/decks/sadistic-surgery/#469674 or this one http://www.mtgvault.com/hummahumma/decks/izzet-standard-1drops/#467108 ), but I have a hard time getting people to comment on mine. I'm going to join you in this quest, and follow all these comments, and comment on people's decks from here. :)
Love the attitude! I will gladly welcome other to partake! Hope we get some more posters to help out like you!
If anyone else has time as well, I've been working on a competitive modern deck for awhile (currently titled here as ModernControl: Glorius Azorius). It's based on Luminarch Ascension, and I want to take it to a Pro Tour (or at least a PTQ). Any advice on it would be lovely. :)
I changed my bookmark to this site to send me straight to the "New Decks" page, so I can always check out new decks every time I come back.
Sure, why not? Two neat decks I found this morning:http://www.mtgvault.com/maumau17/decks/the-biggest-feast-ever/#476447Even though I retracted most of what I said there.http://www.mtgvault.com/schulzcubed/decks/death-is-but-a-number/
Thanks for the bump! :D
Hey, what can I say? I liked the deck!
Well I appreciate it, I need advice on it so the added views help! :3
To all of those who are partaking in this, know that I work evenings, so it may take a half a day or so to get your comments, but I promise I will give them as soon and as quickly as I am able!
http://www.mtgvault.com/endarken/decks/good-junk-v2-greg-phillips/
Finally! A place for unloved decks to be advertised freely! #VaultHunting
Glad you like it! I think it's something this community sorely needed!
Thanks man cause I need some feed back
Had to dig through a couple pages to find this one. Needed something that sparked my interest and also is standard. Havent been playing long enough to have a really good grasp on modern yet.http://www.mtgvault.com/kajuata/decks/standard-auras/
Love me some constructed!
tigerknight21 has deleted this comment.
Yes, just post the links here! Thanks for spreading the help!
Love this idea! I hated it when they added the "Hot" tab to the main page, so decks that actually need help are getting the backburner!1st, http://www.mtgvault.com/cruncher/decks/heroes-journey/2nd, http://www.mtgvault.com/nantucketsleighride/decks/saprolings-beget-saprolings/
I almost feel at times, because of how crappy the decks on the hot tab usually are, that they are the ones that need all the help.The really killer decks need no help, get no support, or views.
Thanks! I joined not too long ago, but it became apparent very quickly that there was a problem. The community here is amazing, we just need to spread support around to all members!
If you do get around to commenting on one of my decks, BurtonErnie and anyone else that would like to, please check out my newest commander deck. Im not very good at building commander decks so any constructive criticism I could get with it would be very much appreciated!http://www.mtgvault.com/ahelmer/decks/intet-the-commander-2/
I definitely will! I am going to catch up on all the comments I owe tomorrow morning, first thing!
...I'm fucking sick of article decks.And budget decks.There are almost no actual good decks on the Vault anymore, just shitty budget decks and articles without any cards in them, circle jerking for a like.
You got that right. It's been getting worse and worse. I used to love this site, now i rarely come here.
I personally do like to see budget decks (cuz that's the way i play). But i want to see some new crazy combos! people keep recreating the same idea. It's feeling very unoriginal. I only come here rly to put my decks in the cloud in case if i somehow lose my deck or some cards in my deck (via stealing or water damage or whatever) that way i can find and replace the cards easier.
Agreed BlackRazz, it's cool to help out young 'uns and those who don't have extra money to create neat and effective decks, but there needs to be appreciation for talent. I've got three or four decks that win in four turns or less regularly, and then have little to no support at all. I've seen countless constructed decks that are super impressive, but no one's interested in them!
Also, Possum and Jack, there ARE good decks, you just have to go looking for them.
Jesus H. Christ. BnE, can you go post that to every deck on this site!Finally, someone voicing my same concerns! Just because a deck is super cheap, or super easy to recommend changes to, or super easy to understand doesn't mean it should get 50 likes!!!Nor does it mean a super awesome, well rounded, complex, intimidating (in that it may use older cards or difficult to understand combos) deck should be overlooked.But it happens everyday on this site.The guy that originally told me about this site. That is why he left. I am still here. But he left. Simply because he said, "a bunch of super crappy, 1 win condition decks get on the hot page. And budget decks that are budget just for the sake of being Budget are hot decks. Good, solid decks do not get any support/likes."He is right. So are you.
Can I get a hallelujah?The hot page is 80% budget decks, 10% people posting decks with one card and an article in them, and 10% random combo shit that works almost never.This isn't even a real Magic site anymore.
Yeah, i am posting on another deck. Saying basically the same thing as what you are PhyrexianPossum, and people are telling me to be positive. And that it doesn't matter if the combos do not work. lol.I don't get it.
Yea i literally use this site to brainstorm my own deck ideas, crunch numbers and take sample hands. Plus i use Tcgplayer to buy my decks. I stopped looking at other peoples decks quite some time ago for the same reasons you guys said. Its fuckin lame seeing some garb combo deck get praised as if it was some new tier one legacy tourney winner. Who wants to actually buy a deck, let alone play with a deck, that does one thing and one thing only, and if it doesn't work, it can't win? This site was popping when i first joined, now i just get shit when i make posts on crappy budgets and cheap trick decks for not "understanding" them.Sorry BurtonErnie, not trying to turn this post into a ranting page, but i got happy when i saw people felt the same as i did.
Don't apologize, I feel the same exact way. Again, not knocking budget decks, they're a good idea, but there is some major talent and creativity here going unappreciated, and it just bums me out, which is why I made this article! Getting so hyped that there are so many people on the same page and already helping out a ton! Thanks everyone!
mymobbsdeep,I feel the same. If you need ideas you might want to look up my decks, you'l probably not be disappointed. And in some cases I still need some help that nobody here so far was able to give, so you are welcome. I'll do the same with your decks if you want me to.
I agree with AlleywayJack
ive got some pretty good ideas. also jessie's wife has a mono whit noobie deck thats not bad i commented on it a few times....its called chastity belt....poor guy he aint getting any tonight lol
jessie's wife's deck sucked, there were just a bunch of horny nerds who wanted her to love them that commented
Mwahahaha. Wait, Horny nerds play Magic?!No way!!!!
This guy is a genius. I every once in a while go around doing this sorta stuff (i will right after I post this, no lie). If you guyz wouldn't mind taking a peak at my EDH deck i'm working on, i would appreciate it. http://www.mtgvault.com/blackrazz/decks/intet-commander/ TIME TO GO GIVE LOVE TO UNLOVED DECKS!Decks i've looked at:http://www.mtgvault.com/spoiler1937/decks/zendikar-vampires/http://www.mtgvault.com/foochow/decks/jou-burnt-scryfish/http://www.mtgvault.com/zerovector/decks/dimir-control-mill/
I'll definitely take a look at your decks when I get a chance to jump on my laptop! Yeah, I used to comment on unloved decks too, then I had this idea, so hopefully all the decks on this site get a lot more appreciation!
You're the best man. The community needs more people like you.http://www.mtgvault.com/coolwip4865/decks/the-funnest-deck-of-all-time/
Thanks coolwip! Same to you!
Budget decks are incredible. A lot of my decks don't even have rares in them. I started a trend called Microdeck which is a 40 card singleton deck with one rare to be the centerpiece of the deck. The trend seems to have died out a little because people have found a way to completely break the format. I need help trying to fix it. Please?
what was the break in the format? By the way I've seen your microdeck setup and i think it's awesome! Seems like the ultimate casual play format! i showed the guys i play with and we are all considering giving it a shot!
I loved the Microdeck! I built a Goblin RDW style for it. :)
the break is people using old cards that are technically commons but are a bajillion bucks and ruin shit like a steamroller. I think what i need is to make a banlist. Any advice?
I don't think a ban list is necessary. Correct me if I'm wrong since you built this format but the way I see it is those people using those old school commons are completely missing the point of this format. The whole basis of the format is to make magic less viciously competitive and make it that fun casual card game it's supposed to be. It shouldn't be on you to change your format just because ppl are finding loopholes. I guarantee no matter what you do they'll still find ways to make vicious decks that are no fun to play against.
I would say just limit what counts as common/uncommon. For instance, you could say every card must be a common or uncommon that has an average listed price of $2.00 or less (according to MtG Vault or TCGplayer) except for one "rare" card, which can be any card costing more than the $2.00. There's no need for a ban list, I think, because if someone wants to use a $15.00 common as their "rare", I don't see much problem with it. As long as the other 39 cards are under a certain price, it will remain a budget format.
thinking bout letting conspiracies be legal. Hmmmmm... I think it should count toward your rare card. What do you guys think?
Hmm. I don't quite have enough experience with conspiracies yet to judge, but I wouldn't be strictly opposed to it.
There would need to be a limit on the number of conspiracies allowed. Since you begin the game with them in the command zone, theoretically a guy could bring in twenty "Double Stroke"s, shock you, and copy it twenty times for the win. Something along the lines of only one of each or two of each, maybe even only five conspiracies total or something.
Would conspiracies count in the 40-card exact decklist? Or maybe you can say 40 card deck PLUS up to (x) conspiracies. Maybe you can rule "Conspiracies are allowed on top of the 40 card deck, but each player must have the same number of conspiracies at the start of the game." This way, people CAN have 20+ conspiracies, but they can only use 2 if the opponent only has/wants to use 2. Something like that?
That's not a bad idea, but I'm pretty sure the card ruling on conspiracies was that they start sprays from your deck, thus not being included in your deck. But a general rule of who wants to up the anty and everyone plays with 2,000 defender tokens on their first upkeep each sounds good to me, with the lesser number taking priority over a higher number.
I think I would say the best ruling would be: "Before the game begins, players may come to an agreement on a number of conspiracies to use (in addition to the normal 40-card deck). If the players do find an agreeable number, that many conspiracies may be used by each player; otherwise, conspiracies will not be legal in that game."
The conspiracies will be singleton like with the rest of the deck. It doesn't count to the 40 card limit. I'm thinking one conspiracy per deck.
That works well
tried to spread the word about microdeck on fb. Everyone compared it to commander and would not stop comparing it to commander despite it being a much faster format. Someone said it was way too similar to small soldiers. I couldnt deny that it was waaaaay too similar. Microdeck doesnt seem to be catching on outside of mtgvault. Oh well. Still gonna try but not gonna get my hopes up.
http://www.mtgvault.com/tykora/decks/draw-and-discard/http://www.mtgvault.com/mradam5/decks/group-pain/http://www.mtgvault.com/qqfish/decks/mb-8rack-no-creature/I offered advice to 3 Unloved Decks. :)
Holy whopping nine comments coming your way! Big thanks to the help out! :)
Oh, I read it wrong. I thought it was "I respond to 3 decks and you respond to 1 deck."I am totally down with you just looking over 1 of my decks.I try to comment on unloved decks anyways. I like your idea. Thank you are the boss for doing it!
Thanks for setting this up. Below are some unloved decks that might need some More comments. I'd appreciate any comments on my deck "death is but a Number"http://www.mtgvault.com/tether/decks/of-land-and-sky-budget/http://www.mtgvault.com/willbell/decks/pinnacle-of-turbo-fog/
Thanks for taking part in the cause! I'll definitely give you some well-deserved comments when I get a chance to get on my computer!
Haha, Thanks. I got excited when I saw all of the coment alerts, but they were all for this thread and the 5 decks I was able to add some comments to. :) Anyone who want to look at and contribute to my 'Death is but a number' I've been trying to make that competitive. Just post a link To a deck you want my opinion on and i'll get you back! Thanks in advance...
Its awesome that you posted this! I'm fairly new to magic and I've posted most of my decks on this site but the majority of them have been ignored regardless of how many trips to unloved they've had haha. Hopefully this makes a difference! I'd love some help on some of my decks and i know lots of other people do too! Thanks for the shout out BurtonErnie!
You and your decks are exactly what I mean! Magic is an amazing creative outlet, and no one's work should go unappreciated, I look forward to commentingg on your ideas when I get a chance to jump on my laptop!
Thanks a lot man!
Hey, it's BurtonErnie! I'm definitely off to find some unloved masterpieces now.
Thanks MagicMaster! Def looking forward to reviewing your work. :)
http://www.mtgvault.com/icenerd/decks/mystical-ninja/http://www.mtgvault.com/vaan104/decks/standard-athreos/http://www.mtgvault.com/ffriendlyffire/decks/opaline/http://www.mtgvault.com/zniwalla/decks/doran-edhcommander/http://www.mtgvault.com/hunns/decks/master-of-the-thief/http://www.mtgvault.com/wolvesinthesnow1/decks/cheap-eldrazi-earthquakes-2/http://www.mtgvault.com/callmeishmel/decks/hail-hydras/http://www.mtgvault.com/inzendium/decks/ultra-lifegain/http://www.mtgvault.com/milkbot/decks/dimir-infect-modern/There we are, that's all of them.
Absolutely, yes, people should focue less on the "hot" decks (they got enough attention already) and more on the unloved ones. In fact I think it would be better for this site if the unloved decks would be default view, not the hot ones. BTW, I offer a service for deck critique, all you have to do is drop a line here:http://www.mtgvault.com/puschkin/decks/puschkin-please-help-me/Well, that isn't entirely true: You should actually do a little bit more, add a proper deck description, add information like intended format, casual/tourney, 1-on-1/multiplayer etc. Some times, a deck is unloved and stays unloved because it is an incoherent mess or secretly genious but incomprehensible without a description.
I am trying to help with this one: http://www.mtgvault.com/diablopally/decks/jund-aggrocontrol/PLS CHECK THIS ONE OUT: http://www.mtgvault.com/mcwaffles/decks/madness-in-ur/ i think the idea is awesome
Offered advice onMadness in U/RYou get to Play LandsMana Ramp DragonsA few that I would like some input on. Budget isn't much of an issue on these until you start talking about cards that are 200-300 dollars a piece.A simple strategy of fetch, swing, fling and repeat.http://www.mtgvault.com/couch312/decks/tribal-elemental/A turn three or four mill that is fairly consistent, but I feel I could do more to make it better.http://www.mtgvault.com/couch312/decks/painterstone-mill/Modern Merfolk. I've never built merfolk till now and could use advice.http://www.mtgvault.com/couch312/decks/modern-merfolk/Legacy Goblins, in the same boat as Modern Merfolk.http://www.mtgvault.com/couch312/decks/goblins-2/
Awesome idea.
Commented on http://www.mtgvault.com/dazzleflash/decks/mana-ramp-dragons/Would like advice on scorched earth, the 2nd element and time is an illusion please.
This seems like an awesome idea. My problem is I don't feel like I'm experienced enough to be giving advice on other decks, so I rarely comment. Anyway, I saw a unicorn deck that I had to comment onhttp://www.mtgvault.com/gottie/decks/candy-mountain/and a Red/Green Dragon Deck that seemed interesting, although I couldn't give him any advice. If any more experienced players want to check it out and see if they can help, I'd appreciate it. http://www.mtgvault.com/rotawar/decks/rg-fatties/
You'd be surprised how good you really are krayterz!
I feel the same way. I believe that I make some really good decks in my opinion, but they are never really good enough against many other decks. And because of that I don't consider myself "experienced" enough to give "deck-winning" advice on other decks. However, I do give try to give constructive criticism and kudos to the decks I feel deserve it.
Here's a cool looking deck, that also needs help itself. I commented and liked it aswell.http://www.mtgvault.com/tether/decks/of-land-and-sky-budget/And here's a fun looking deck that should get more love IMO.http://www.mtgvault.com/rhody88/decks/hexproof-mill-2/
Here is a deck that looks similar to a deck I would've ran whenever I started out with magic.http://www.mtgvault.com/zerovector/decks/dimir-control-mill/
Alright guys, I am reeeeally sorry but I've been super busy! I've managed a -few- comments on my work breaks but between work, two little ones, and errands I haven't gotten around to your comment yet! This is why I PROMISE tomorrow morning I will head to my local library, jump on my lap top, and knock out ALL or the comments I owe to you wonderful people! Looking forward to seeing all of those sexy minds at work!
Here is an interesting izzet deck that I liked cause of young pyromancer and cipher, master of waves and purphoros.http://www.mtgvault.com/bishbashbosh/decks/the-2nd-element/
http://www.mtgvault.com/garuwashi/decks/budget-ooze-deck/ any suggestions ??
I typically only comment on decks that get no attention, mostly because I think the number of budget decks on this site has gotten out of hand, and the comments are worthless. That's just my opinion though, maybe it's what people want, but the introduction of the 'hot page' as the default instead of the 'new' page has been irritating since it's inception.Comments:http://www.mtgvault.com/mothafukajones/decks/elvish-hydra-counter/http://www.mtgvault.com/necrohellion/decks/darien-king-of-pain/http://www.mtgvault.com/vidrald/decks/merchant-summoning/
Hah love this idea and seems like lots of other people do too im sure it is keeping you busy. Ill have to look through eveyones stuff here and try and make comments. here is the deck i found to say something about http://www.mtgvault.com/chrismorris/decks/trondrazi/ cool play off of tron he had goin
Great idea to get some comments/ideas/suggestions for decks that need help or advice. This is my mono-black:http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/the-mad-phyrexian-obliterator/
I love the idea! I have been a user since 2010 and have not seen much action on here since then. When I first started being a vault lover I had some awesome deck ideas with no one to talk to about them because no one could afford the game. When I startd posting on here my ideas and got feedback it helped my understanding of the game and the mechanics involved to now be able to make an invincible stuffy doll. To the active users of the Vault I thank you!!
http://www.mtgvault.com/rheonotic/decks/politics-of-war-edh/Great idea man thanks!!
http://www.mtgvault.com/jeradch/decks/crystal-blue-inspiration/Love the idea the more help we give each other the better!!Working on my standard deck overwhelming wave going to play next week at FNM any help always welcome thanks y'all
I completely agree with everything you're saying, I might even help out if that's ok :)
http://www.mtgvault.com/mekkakat/decks/ur-tokens/ liked it but had some tips
Ello Ello all. Great Idea BurtonErnie! If anyone is willing to give me some more advise on my Standard deck it's appreciated and I will give my opinions on whichever deck you post on it.http://www.mtgvault.com/maniacalmaniac/decks/hexproof-enchantment-standard/
Well guys, I commented for two hours this morning until I had daddy duty. To all those still waiting for comments, I'm sorry, and I'll keep plugging away at it tomorrow, as I have the day off! I'm really sorry again guys, but I'll get comments out as quick as I can! Thank you to all of those helping to put more comments out there, as well!
I don't see any need for apologies for helping others. If someone is upset with your apparent "tardiness" they probably don't deserve your input. In my opinion that is.
Agreed with Maniac.
Well thank you, it makes me feel better that people understand, I'm feel pretty guilty about it, I'm just darn busy and don't have internet at home.
your awesome for doing this man, in fact i think ill go through and comment on a bunch of these decks also to help spread the love, i found a sweet marchesa edh deck that was particularly unloved and hit it up with a like and comment http://www.mtgvault.com/fortytwo/decks/marchesa-edh/
I think i might buy this deck. Thoughtflare for the win!
Great idea! found a deck and commented on it. Keep up the good work!http://www.mtgvault.com/pepsidime/decks/junk-lifegain-pump/
http://www.mtgvault.com/burningpeat/decks/fotress-of-madness/
http://www.mtgvault.com/ravenklath/decks/rw-planeswalker-control/
GoodOleJim has deleted this comment.
.....did you even read the opening post
Honest mistake....no need to sound like a jerk.
as i always say. i love helping people in the community to build decks. i never really like commenting on the popular decks since they already either know what they are doing or someone else already said it (and sometimes is even get a snarky response from people that feel they know better than me and their deck is perfect). so i usually stick to the decks that are new and have yet to be commented upon. the deck i decided to make some suggestions is a type that is very dear to me. an extort deck ( http://www.mtgvault.com/dsouth/decks/extortion/ ).
also if anyone wants any help from me they can find it here.i comment as fast as i can. it may take me a bit of time to respond but i am always willing to help. http://www.mtgvault.com/clawzizking/decks/here-to-help/
Pure artifacts :P http://www.mtgvault.com/tanner2/decks/artifact-creature/
http://www.mtgvault.com/coasttrax/decks/standard-grixis-control/
http://www.mtgvault.com/gr33dy/decks/wrexial-water-theme-edh/ Seems like a really cool deep waters themed deck! funny, because I was making something similar x)
Steev has deleted this comment.
Here's a mill deck, but not your typical mill deck where you play spells to force them to put their library into their graveyard. THEY force THEMSELVES to put cards into their graveyard heheheh:http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/stasis-alternative-mill-deck/
You're really a thinker aren't ya? you switched it around man... you made it so everybody is asking everybody else to like/comment on everyone's decks... good sir you think so far outside the box that you are going into other peoples boxes and forcing them to think outside their box... you've inspired me. and I am going to give to this community too every day i will go to the unloved page and give every deck that does not have one already a like and same with comments. hats off to you.here is the deck that i commented on: http://www.mtgvault.com/planbfan/decks/naya-swarm/
He is in your box thinking outside your box
cruzer has deleted this comment.
Awesome idea! It gives people who don't have constant followers to possibly make it on the hot list!http://www.mtgvault.com/theholeyfoley/decks/myracle/http://www.mtgvault.com/raginggoblin/decks/werewolf-stompy/
http://www.mtgvault.com/omnome/decks/artifact-control/
Hi all! Stuck on building tribal elves, some advice would be much appreciated.http://www.mtgvault.com/gundog-gunner/decks/rhys-the-exiled-tribal-edh/I will check other links and try and bring something to this event.
Just want to add, if anyone would like some help building an EDH, I am willing to give my input due to my love for the format.Just link below with a small description. =)
http://www.mtgvault.com/simicmartin35/decks/korimarx-king-of-traitors/
http://www.mtgvault.com/ryudhyn/decks/moderncontrol-glorius-azorius/ I love the idea of this
Thank you!
http://www.mtgvault.com/milfstink/decks/wardens-orders/Looking at other decks is cool, I should do it more often.
seriously though, this is a wondrous idea!
http://www.mtgvault.com/omnome/decks/junk-reanimator/
Thought I'd join in on these shenanigans: commented on this: http://www.mtgvault.com/jerzeydevyl/decks/devotion-to-green/
Thanks for checking out my deck and posting it here.
http://www.mtgvault.com/icooper/decks/jaliras-wurm/
oh cool, its my deck :D
Thank you for starting this pageI feel the reason for it, at least as far as i can see, is that they changed the defaults on the sitewhen i first started here, if i clicked decks it would automatically go to the "New" page, for a while now when i do it, it goes right to "Hot"I noticed an instant drop off in comments when this happenedhttp://www.mtgvault.com/osyruz916/decks/sage-of-hours/
Yep, and what is damn sad is that most of the "Hot" decks are awful.One win condition, trick pony decks. Although I shouldn't complain too much...because I have 2 or 3 decks on the Hot Page right now...lol. But yeah, lots of people begging for it to go back to the old style.
http://www.mtgvault.com/spiffmeister/decks/the-best-offense/http://www.mtgvault.com/timblebee/decks/ub-hunters/http://www.mtgvault.com/cithiri/decks/killer-infinite-mana/These decks are right up my ally, and I never would have looked for them until I saw this deck post. Love what your doing here, hope to keep spreading the love with you all some more.
http://www.mtgvault.com/dith0rder/decks/enchantments-i-guess/http://www.mtgvault.com/jerzeydevyl/decks/devotion-to-green/Both of these unloved decks I commented on.http://www.mtgvault.com/kazzong/decks/druidic-fury/This unloved deck I liked. Recommend checking it out.Deck I need advice on is:http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/mad-propetic-skills/
Neat Concept for a deck! http://www.mtgvault.com/pclemente2120/decks/sea-monsters-in-ulas-temple/
Please check out my profile on my builds! I have most of these decks built and would like some feedback or suggestions to make them run better without spending too much money on them.
I will do. Just remember, don't take me hammering your deck too hard.
No problem!
Mirthful accolades for thine unloved arsenals hence forth
I did go ahead and comment on a few decks this evening. This is really cool!
This is cool! I have commented on 6 unloved decks. And have received 2 or 3 comments back. Even a like or two with one of my decks!
This really is pretty awesome!
http://www.mtgvault.com/nosferatuzodd/decks/spider-keepers/This is my spider deck. I just did some updating to it and it should be pretty mean.http://www.mtgvault.com/nosferatuzodd/decks/nodachi-edh/This is the commander deck I ran at my last meeting on Wednesday where my friends and I play.
http://www.mtgvault.com/cithiri/decks/death-incarnate/ - Here's one I commented on / tried to help.http://www.mtgvault.com/cithiri/decks/legendary-ninjas/ - and another.http://www.mtgvault.com/milfstink/decks/planetary-might/ - and another. Thanks for the downvote.
Here's my contribution http://www.mtgvault.com/theswarmer/decks/budget-bant-midrange/
Awesome idea man, too many good decks and not enough loveHeres an awesome artifact deck i found on the unloved http://www.mtgvault.com/theholeyfoley/decks/myracle/#477857
It needs Myrs with one mana. He has nothing he can play on Turn 1. That is huge tempo disadvantage.
I haven't commented on many decks on here, as I am one of the newbies. I have only been playing Magic for about a month now, and can use all of the help I can get on my decks! Please help me, and thanks in advance. I do like the idea of this deck http://www.mtgvault.com/ajaxtheriot/decks/land-destruction/ but I think their should be a few more lower mana cards to play.
http://www.mtgvault.com/dinotrooper/ thanks!
http://www.mtgvault.com/huggs/decks/there-be-monstrs-in-them-hills/I need comments. The deck is casual, but theoretically should be quick and efficient for having big creatures. Thoughts?
I have four decks that need love! I'm willing to hear and use all great opinions
Posted a couple thorough replies on different decks. This is a real good idea. Nice job getting so much support for it!http://www.mtgvault.com/reekojacks/decks/esper-control-budget/http://www.mtgvault.com/cloudcontrol/decks/modern-infect/
ANOUNCEMENT: I believe I have a three day weekend this weekend, so everyone I owe comments to, I VOW you will get them ALL this weekend! Get ready for a marathon of constructive critisism everyone, and thank you for being so patient and understanding!
"A marathon of constructive criticism."You sound like my wife!!! lolSee what I just did? I threw down a wife joke!
Yay constructive critisism.
I know I have recorded 6 comments/likes on Unloved decks. That is just me. Counting everyone else that has participated so far, BurtonErnie's comments are going to skyrocket from 129 posts!
I've offered advice on enough decks, but everyone likes to build budget, and everything that I'd say to put in is not budget. Which makes getting advice on my legacy/modern decks difficult because nobody bothers to even look since none of them are considered "budget"
Legacy...what is budget for Legacy? 500 bucks?I have several Legacy decks for 100 bucks or cheaper. They can't win tourneys. But they can win casual games. That is the thing with Legacy/Vintage...they see a tag for it, and think, "There is a deck that is running hundred dollars cards." And lots of people do not have experience with 100 dollar cards.But you do have a point...there are great cards that are budget...but if you see a 30 dollar card...there usually is a good reason it is 30 bucks.
Yes. There is always a reason. Like Moat is over 300 dollars, because it shuts down half the decks in the format if not more.
And there is the problem. If you are 15 years old (like a lot of people on here) you don't have 300 dollars for one card.And if you are like me, married with children, you can't afford 300 dollar cards. Next best thing, build a solid budget deck that can, maybe 1 out of 10 games, beat the Moat deck. :)Regardless, checked out a few of your decks and sent some love.
For semi competitive legacy deck I think manaless dredge comes in around £150 (ot sure what that is in dollars) I swear if I ever get a big enough win off my football coupons I will get the deck!
I'm looking for suggestions on my deck!http://www.mtgvault.com/joelxdoom/decks/agent-of-fabled-fates/
added some
For all who frequent here, I would love some criticism on my decks, I'm always striving to better them.
http://www.mtgvault.com/borosblitz/decks/tyrannical-control/Any help on my decks is appreciated
http://www.mtgvault.com/necrumlsice/decks/trbialthe-apes-have-escaped/ i love weird tribal decks like this that arnt about the "main" tribes! any help on my new M15 superfriends deck would be greatly appreciated!
In the spirit of BurtonErniehttp://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/static-ability-challenge/New challenge to everyone!Have a flying deck around? Protection deck? Flash? Double Strike? Haste?Any Static ability counts.Post them to my Static Ability Challenge! I will comment on them all. And they will also get more exposure because I will post them to the "How to Play" section. Good luck!
Funny, I have been working on a flying deck tonight. Will need another day or so to whittle it down.
Add it to the deck page. I will look at it, like/comment on it. and post it to the "How to Play" section. I liked a few of the decks already posted there, and I commented on all of them. It has made other people like/comment on a few of them too. Getting your decks noticed is a great way to get advice. Good luck.
http://www.mtgvault.com/jon480/decks/budget-rw-herioc/
did you delete or rename this deck?
im pretty new to this site but i love what you are doing!! this is a great idea and i hope to see more of the awesome decks on here get some love.
Trying to get a friend into magic. He wanted to make a spider deck so this is what i made. http://www.mtgvault.com/borosblitz/decks/spider-rider/Any critiques would be great.
I was wondering if anyone would offer advice on this deck, it will be seeing competitive play and playtesting it performs well, but if there's anything to make it better I would appreciate any criticism.http://www.mtgvault.com/couch312/decks/legacy-esper-affinity/
kindly fuck off
http://www.mtgvault.com/maumau17/decks/when-did-your-hand-go-away/
Only been playing for a few months and love the game :) anyone want to help me with my angel and demon deck??:) please and thanks http://www.mtgvault.com/maggotprince/decks/rebellion-angels-vs-demons/
surelove to help
http://www.mtgvault.com/xxxeleshnornxxx/decks/fast-aggro/this deck is missing something
This is just such an awesome idea, thank you :)http://www.mtgvault.com/tjraiderfan/decks/theros-block-constellation/http://www.mtgvault.com/ketgus/decks/modern-relentless/http://www.mtgvault.com/kefrith/decks/bestyet-monoblacklifeprem15/would love some help for my modern deck idea over on the unloved page :)
http://www.mtgvault.com/borosblitz/decks/demon-deck-357812/ Anyone care to give some tips on my demon deck?
http://www.mtgvault.com/fatalfirestorm/decks/wbg-superfriends-m15-read-disc/i built a deck for m15. if you dont know what cards im referring to. http://mythicspoiler.com/its the first standard deck i actually care about and i want it to succeed :)
Hehehehehe
Hehehehehe?
Best comments ever!
http://www.mtgvault.com/onjacktaljack/decks/dominus/
http://www.mtgvault.com/huggs/decks/there-be-monstrs-in-them-hills/Please comment on all my decks! I need the love!
Okay guys. My wife's first deck!White protection deck.She has spanked my but now, in several games.Mind you, when you look at the deck:SHE HAS BEEN PLAYING MAGIC FOR LESS THAN 1 WEEK.SHE MADE THIS ENTIRE DECK WITH CARDS WE HAVE.SHE MADE THIS DECK WITH NO ADVICE FROM ME, AT ALL.Given all of those facts, she did a freaking awesome job!!!HELP SUPPORT HER!http://www.mtgvault.com/nikkiphoenixrising/decks/chastity-belt/Here is her deck! Comments, advice, and likes are welcomed!
no no no stop advertising
support her? isnt that what women have bra's for? lol
If there are any control players on here I could us a hand with med price range control cards on this deck http://www.mtgvault.com/schmidty1920/decks/control/ also feel free to help out with any other ideas on any other decks
Commented!http://www.mtgvault.com/puschkin/decks/keeping-up-the-tornado
ClockworkCopper has deleted this comment.
i would like a little help with this deckhttp://www.mtgvault.com/xxxeleshnornxxx/decks/path-to-winning/
An alternative way to win magic. No damage, no poison, no mill. Use Laboratory Maniac:http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/laboratory-maniacmaaaaniac/
I would love for some of you to give constructive criticism on my decks. I'm always looking for ways to improve.http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/smudges-army/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/black-weenies/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/the-dark-realms/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/curses/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/control-v-20/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/russian-black-squirrels/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/i-banish-you/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/knights/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/the-original-angel-deck/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/zombies/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/soul-sisters/http://www.mtgvault.com/joeyburnette/decks/elves/
Eat shit and die.
I'm always looking for help with my decks or sideboards. I'm trying to make both tourny level and fun level decks and i never get any love with any of the :(. im on a tricolor kick
Check these out! =)http://www.mtgvault.com/zsombi10/decks/blood-magic/ http://www.mtgvault.com/zsombi10/decks/elixir-of-life-death/
http://www.mtgvault.com/martianshark/decks/unhinged-t3-win/I thought of a great idea, but this deck beat me to it. Using Wordmail (enchanted creature gets +1/+1 for each word in its name) and Our Market Research Shows that Players Like Really Long Card Names So We made this Card to have the Absolute Longest Card Name Ever Elemental. Basically, "Our Market" is a creature with 25 words in it's title. He is 3 mana.So, you cast him and then next turn cast Wordmail (for 1 mana) on "Our Market" 27/27!!!You can do that, with mana ramp, to where you can get off a Turn 3 win.Turn 1: Forest. Play Llanowar elves (or bop)Turn 2: Plains. Play "Our Market"Turn 3. Plains. Play Wordmail on "Our Market" and now you have a 27/27 on the third turn. If you want, play something like Stave Off or Faith's Shield, giving him protection, and attack unblocked!!!Again, this guys version is better than what i had in mind. Wish I would of come up with it!!!
I have become Death, the Destroyer of Worlds. Check out this combo-busting, creature-breaking, graveyard-returning, butt-kicking deck:http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/i-am-deathdestroyer-of-worlds/
kindly fuck your mother
still working on getting the cards, but would love any help! thanks, and its junk hexproof, got the idea from seeing a junk deck and i just love bant hexhttp://www.mtgvault.com/elodin/decks/strange-looking-junk/
Would like some Sideboard helphttp://www.mtgvault.com/joelxdoom/decks/thaumaturge/
http://www.mtgvault.com/glitch42420/decks/double-time/Time to go find some cool unloved decks.
Why are people posting their own decks here? That's not the point of this, the point was for you to go to the unloved deck section, find a deck or 2 that you like, like them and/or leave a comment, then post that deck here so that others can view it, THEN the Author of this "Deck" will comment on your decks when he has time to get to it. You're not supposed to be posting your own decks, that defeats the purpose of him doing this. Someone with 10 rep should go through and downvote every single person that posted their own decks. Just sayin.
I can't speak for others, but I for one offer/offered advice on many decks before and after this came to be. I simply posted the links of decks I would like prefer the critique to go towards.
Was no way refering to you Couch312, I've seen you commenting on others deck to help them, it's the ones that just came here, posted their deck, and didn't do what BertonErnie was intending for this article/"deck".
Sorry, I misread. http://www.mtgvault.com/magicpro44/decks/rw-humans/
http://www.mtgvault.com/spoiler1937/decks/artifact-hater-deck/
http://www.mtgvault.com/jerzeydevyl/decks/devotion-to-green/
Thanks for checking out my deck, and posting it here.
http://www.mtgvault.com/rellarella/decks/buyingselling-life-modern-2/http://www.mtgvault.com/writteninred/decks/shrine-like-the-sun/
http://www.mtgvault.com/rhodanperry8/decks/grisel-cannon/
http://www.mtgvault.com/vaan104/decks/life-gain-for-the-win/ this ones my brothers deckand a couple of mine i really would love to see feedback on.http://www.mtgvault.com/variable/decks/courtesy-of-the-r-w-and-b/http://www.mtgvault.com/variable/decks/spell-me/http://www.mtgvault.com/variable/decks/goblin-burn-revamped/
Can I get a little love?http://www.mtgvault.com/dschlie573/Thank ya, thank ya!
look, a well!jump, dschliethere's a cookie down there
http://www.mtgvault.com/borosblitz/decks/dominion-victory/I really like this, but would like some opinions on what i can do better, if you all would be so kind.
Commented on it. i love Draco!
sourcer has deleted this comment.
You should read what this article is about instead of just posting, because this isn't what it was made for. Just letting you know before someone decides to downvote you.
ll i want is if for for people to look at all the decks i have posted and just give me better ideas ones i may not see that is what the site is for right ? I'm a veteran player been playing since alpha but i can always learn something new from someone else's experience and the way they brew i don't have many decks posted so please go to my page and please check them out it would be much appreciated
http://www.mtgvault.com/dazzleflash/decks/giggle-at-the-ghosty/ This looks like a really fun deck to play!
http://www.mtgvault.com/theholeyfoley/decks/nope/ Another deck that caught my eye. A great deck to annoy your opponents with.
http://www.mtgvault.com/systemscsnake/decks/braid-of-destruction/ This deck uses Braid of Fire, which no other player in my magic group uses except me, so seeing how it was used so well in this deck I had to give it some love!
http://www.mtgvault.com/drklucavi/decks/massacre-under-the-big-top-m/This deck is GIGANTIC with tons of GREAT cards in there, a bit of tweaks are still needed, but it's awesome anyhow
"if you love your country...then stand up and show them big ol'.......to me ahhhhoooooooo" a cookie for who knows who's line that is lolhttp://www.mtgvault.com/variable/decks/courtesy-of-the-r-w-and-b/
Rodney Carrington
nice glad to see someone get it so fast
deviljulio has deleted this comment.
this is actually kinda importanthttp://www.mtgvault.com/xxxeleshnornxxx/decks/should-i-keep-playing/
http://www.mtgvault.com/dabuzz/decks/youve-been-burned/ A fun Burn Deck. Worth a look-see.
http://www.mtgvault.com/thomasst/decks/demonic-divine-vs-demonic/An interesting demon deck. Gave me some card ideas for mine.
http://www.mtgvault.com/extile/decks/white-weenie-life/
http://www.mtgvault.com/gentlejackjones/decks/stormworld/
baby farts? seriously, that is your name? lolGeez
Love what you are doing here! http://www.mtgvault.com/vinscadut/decks/mono-black-vampire/
Just noticed you said we need to comment a deck with 0 previous comments :http://www.mtgvault.com/kaiansbt/decks/monowhite-auras-pauper-2/
I found a deck that, while unloved, has had no comments/likes since it was made more than a week ago. I love the concept, and feel it should get more attention:http://www.mtgvault.com/bishbashbosh/decks/izzet-elementary-tho-sherlock/
My very first deck. Blue controlWith Palinchron/High Tide Infinite Mana Combohttp://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/oldschool-blue-my-first-deck/Unloved deck I commented on is:http://www.mtgvault.com/ontraio718/decks/deck-ideas-wantedput-in-chat/Commented on this one...even though I HATE THE DAMN DECK TITLE:http://www.mtgvault.com/jcmbassist/decks/northy-was-stupid-anyway/
http://www.mtgvault.com/rickell/decks/standard-ub-control-31/
nice to see this but its sad you have to bribe people to comment on decks and that people comment on budget stuff all day long. The problem is so many budget decks flood this site that people looking for help never have a chance. I know i've inquired on some commander decks i've made for help but then 2 hrs later my deck is 4 pages deep and no one would ever bother to dig that deep. Glad to see this and maybe sometime we can see more than budget imo junk on the hot list.
Northy being back, it will get worse, lol. :)
And i do not play commander/edh? so, I can't offer advice.
http://www.mtgvault.com/da1flyboy/decks/turn-3-win-red-mono-updated/#481934
http://www.mtgvault.com/lykaj/decks/comp-control/
http://www.mtgvault.com/ankokuraven/decks/darkflame-heroes-budgetdeck/Since pretty much all of my decks have no comments, I figured I'd give you some direction. Most of my decks are budget, and I'm focusing on Goblins, Sliver Combo, and Pyromancing the Stone, though Ultimate Sacrifice could probably use some work. In the end, though, it's up to you.
http://www.mtgvault.com/casey130/decks/grixis-splinter-twin/
http://www.mtgvault.com/hashawashka/decks/ur-artifact-new-standard/What u think about this? thx if u comment, if u dont.... 2 premade trolls in your next ranked game.
Need looks on these two decks. I think they have potential:http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/3-brutal-blackgreen-combos/http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/m15-ob-nixilis-unshackled/Decks I responded to:http://www.mtgvault.com/pete69/decks/thats-alot-of-goblins/http://www.mtgvault.com/dfank/decks/venomlure/
http://www.mtgvault.com/azuresouldragon/decks/radha-heir-to-gruul/Sideboarded hasnt been built yet right now it's weakness is prolly black spot destruction so hexproof and pro black equips is what I'm thinking so far
Commeted on http://www.mtgvault.com/dabuzz/decks/youve-been-burned/ and http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/3-brutal-blackgreen-combos/q
Just a notice guys...people, are getting downvoted (not by me) for wanting people to look at their decks IF YOU DO NOT PROVE THAT YOU ARE ALSO HELPING OTHER PEOPLE.So, with that in thought, I might suggest you only post your deck link if you also post a deck link TO A DECK YOU HAVE HELPED/COMMENTED ON/LIKED.Good luck! "So, click over to the unloved page, start giving some love, and I will return to the community by commenting on THREE of all participater's decks! Happy supporting!"That was BurtonErnie's rules.
Aa didn't notice will commit on some when I get home, was at school and now on the way home
Magic Cards while at school?!Slacker!!!! :)
It passes time and the game is ever changing due to the millions of card combos or variants
My deck http://www.mtgvault.com/carmen93/decks/rally-to-me/ fun soldier deck!And this guys deck which is also super cool! brutal combo with Battlefield Thaumaturgehttp://www.mtgvault.com/ankokuraven/decks/heroic-age-strategic-force/
http://www.mtgvault.com/huggs/decks/we-are-sanguine-bond-ed-2/pretty cool concept.
Question, are you still responding to decks?Just curious, because so many people have clogged the deck...so weren't sure if you were able to keep up. I know, personally, i must of responded to over 6 or 7 decks, with no responses back. So..was just curious.
He hasn't said anything for 2 weeks... I'm due 27 comments, so I don't know what's happening either.
It will keep getting likes and comments, regardless. Neat. Hope all is well with him. If he does get back...he will be on Magic Vault for weeks trying to respond. If he keeps this as his only hot deck, it will probably stay on here for months. :)
Commented on this little M15 brew: http://www.mtgvault.com/imfromnasa/decks/izzet-dead-yet/ Hoping it can get some more feedback.Also hoping that I could get some feedback on my post-rotation deck: http://www.mtgvault.com/babyziggles/decks/pseudopod-coming-to-standard/
http://www.mtgvault.com/berndttoast/decks/teysa-orzhov-scion-edh/That was fun!
this deck seemed interesting to me.http://www.mtgvault.com/alleywayjack/decks/modern-bloom-titan/Im working on two decks but much more interested in the standard deck.http://www.mtgvault.com/atmaweapon/decks/dega-standard/http://www.mtgvault.com/atmaweapon/decks/darksteel-blastzone/
A simple B/W Contellation + Life Steal deck that has won/been close to winning all of its games: http://www.mtgvault.com/s0rinmark0v/decks/taxes-of-nyx/
http://www.mtgvault.com/joelxdoom/decks/tokens-go-boom/TOKENS GO BOOM! Control type deck, Suggestions welcome!
http://www.mtgvault.com/xambt/decks/izzet-burncounter-2/
http://www.mtgvault.com/fatalfirestorm/decks/attempt-at-theros-block-mill/i built this for my friend who wants to get into standard and he wants mill. so hard to please
gon184 has deleted this comment.
http://www.mtgvault.com/lloyd156/decks/keranos-god-of-storms-edh/That's my first commander deck, anyone give me any decent feedback.
Pooooooopppppp
Yep. I think that about sums it up.
Is that in response to my deck?
Nope, it is response to BurtonErnie not responding to any decks in over 3 weeks.
Oh ok, well if you get a chance to have a look, any feedback would be appreciated
I am currently making my very first EDH, suggested by surewhynot...so, i am not the person to ask about EDH. Sorry. I have very little experience.
Hi I would be pleased if you posted some deck ideas in my deck called: deck ideas wanted(put in chat). <------ deck name
So i really cant decide what to do with this deck, just made this one. Any advice would help! thanks! and my land situation is a mess, the whole thing is hahahhttp://www.mtgvault.com/elodin/decks/shardless-gone-nuts/
My Commander needs some work, and any help could be very much appreciated http://www.mtgvault.com/shadowsmark/decks/krenkos-tactics-commander/
If you want deck comments, don't reply here!
As i said, the way Magic Vault works with Hot Decks right now, this deck will be on the Hot Page forever, and keep getting comments. Meanwhile, people like me, will get their hot decks removed over and over, and get removed before they should be. I have had decks removed, from the Hot Page, less than 2 weeks old. Meanwhile, this deck keeps getting likes/comments. Go figure.
Fundamentally, I think this has just become too big of a beast for one user to handle. Respect to BurtonErnie for trying this, but the way this thread has exploded has put the mockers on it actually achieving its intended purpose. Speaking as someone who has never had a hot deck, and who is a avowed casual Magic player, it was a great thing to see someone trying to send some love to the casual decks, the budget decks, the stupid combo decks that'll only work 1 in 10 times, because there's a hell of a lot of fun in this system of ours to be found there.In short, a lofty goal, but unrealistically executable.
No, It can be done. I did it.http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/static-ability-challenge/I am still doing it. I kept up with everybody. Over 75 decks commented on. BUT my deck got kicked off the Hot Page. And this deck has not been kicked off the Hot Page. And my Static Ability deck has almost double the comments this deck has. Magic Vault is just flawed. He stopped commenting on all of your decks, but his deck is still getting likes.I kept commenting on all of your decks, and my deck got kicked off the Hot Page. So..yeah, it is a big beast to handle. But it is possible.
Sad part is... he stopped commenting on people's posts RIGHT whenever i posted... not upset, just a little disappointed that someone decides to do this idea and not keep up with it after 3 or 4 days.
No, the sad part is that this deck is still getting likes while i had several of my decks be kicked off from the Hot Page because I posted more Hot Decks. You can only have 2 hot decks. But this guys deck keeps getting vote after vote. Not cool. And he will still get likes/comments forever. That is the way Magic Vault is designed right now. Punish good deck builders. And reward decks like this for months!
Yep, just a second ago I got one of my Hot Decks kicked off Magic Vault...but this deck is still on here. I don't get it.
Hey, I have a boros deck that really could use some advice, it's titled "Boros Legion,Attack!!!!!!! Thanks!
And i need 100 bucks. Don't see that happening.
The one that I'm posting, isn't necessarily an unloved deck, but it looks more like a new player that's looking for advice. He hasn't posted a deck description, but I tried to give him/her some basics. Hopefully you guys will help too! http://www.mtgvault.com/killsburydouboy/decks/first-deck/
is anyone interested in aiding me in building a junk walkers/ soldier deck for standard?
I like what you do
Ugh. Ugh. Ugh.
can you please look at these deckshttp://www.mtgvault.com/sn1p3r1170/decks/azorius-speed-win/http://www.mtgvault.com/sn1p3r1170/decks/mono-green/
Want deck comments? Look here:http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/static-ability-challenge/And my new one:http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/color-hate-challenge/Read the rules first, boys and girls. I will respond to them.
pepsidime has deleted this comment.
I am new to this community so I like this idea. Www.mtgvault.com/bmg
Www.mtgvault.com/bmg548
http://www.mtgvault.com/borosblitz/decks/increasing-spikes/
Nuclear launch detected...http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/nuclear-launch-detected/
http://www.mtgvault.com/udsuna/decks/bant-walkers-infi-turnscombo/
http://www.mtgvault.com/mozex/decks/modern-goblin-horde/
I wish I were experienced enough to have offered this user some valuable advice, but I did leave him what I hope was an encouraging comment: http://www.mtgvault.com/koakuma/decks/walls-to-nothingness/As for my own decks, I've built only one in this site. I'm still new at MTG and looking for feedback to know how I can improve!! Thank you very much in advance!
You my friend are salt of the earthhttp://www.mtgvault.com/freakinrobe/decks/as-the-gods-command-2/#489240
Bounce everything back to their hand so they are helpless:http://www.mtgvault.com/tleung84633/decks/lockdown-and-bounce/
This is a great Idea for encouraging this community in talking to each other thank you for the Idea I might start a threat to do the same thing so ppl start talking to each other on this silly sitehttp://www.mtgvault.com/ayban/decks/welcome-to-the-maze-hunter/
Yeah, if he actually responded. He quit responding over a month ago.
So I have this deck and its not legal in any formats! can you please help make it legal? fast bond and contract from below are killing me cause they are so good but if you have any ideas as for cards to substitute them with please shoot away! and demonic tutor can stay it can be a 'vintage' deckhttp://www.mtgvault.com/elodin/decks/speedy-old-griselbrand/
due to work and school, I don't have much time to build my own decks (relying on pre-made) or play enough (usually once or twice a month) to get enough experience to make quality comments. but I wouldnt mind any comments to improve any decks i have made, am working on, or improve on the pre-made ones until such time as i can fully contribute more to providing imput on other's decks
Can everyone just go to my name and click on it and look at all 5 decks I have made? They are all budget friendly and would love some feedback on them!
Mind looking at mine, and doing the same?
jessie....you need more help then we are qualified to give lol
Looked at some and commented but it's so hard to give advice on your decks that combo so well already lol
http://www.mtgvault.com/variable/decks/jace-anyone-2/ just thoiught id give Jace a try and see what happens with it. ive made several other decks that dont get any love including a really sweet goblin deck.
http://www.mtgvault.com/chrismorris/decks/turn-burn-and-return/I look forward to your ideas and thoughts.
You're the man! This site needs our love!Here's a deck I have been working on.http://www.mtgvault.com/opet69/decks/m15ur-shrapnel-in-yo-ss/
http://www.mtgvault.com/slimslamer/decks/the-best-35-deck-in-modern/You're awesome, I really appreciate any advice you could give.
You don't understand this thread, do you? Have you read the description? You are supposed to to comment and help someone else first, then post the link here, and if you have done that, BurtonErnie will reard you with comments on your deck!
hey everyone this deck is unloved if you could give me som hel id really appreciate it it runs smooth but I'm sure everyone can help thank youhttp://www.mtgvault.com/metamorph24/decks/wg-aggromidrange/
Regardless...he hasn't been on here in over a month. He owes people hundreds or responses.
Sheesh ... don't tell them yet! Let them inspect and comment other decks first :)
Mwahahaha! You evil prick, you!
I commented here:http://www.mtgvault.com/pepbswag/decks/fire-and-flames/#492512
Granflux has deleted this comment.
http://www.mtgvault.com/lemonadepaintbrush/decks/please-help-a-poor-angel/
http://www.mtgvault.com/cagerat07/decks/affinity-artifact-ub/http://www.mtgvault.com/spawnk/decks/blue-skies/http://www.mtgvault.com/taylo/decks/an-eye-for-a-body/nicely done sir
http://www.mtgvault.com/5gtpepper/decks/funny-grave-titan-lol/http://www.mtgvault.com/5gtpepper/decks/i-hate-flying-and-liflink/I'm gonna get a comment I'm gonna get a comment I'm gonna get a commentWooHooThank's bro good idea
No. You will not. He hasn't responded to anything in like 2 months!!!
PLEASE STOP POSTING ON THIS DECK, HE IS NOT RESPONDING TO ANYONE! HE HASN'T BEEN ON IN OVER 2 MONTHS.
ok thnk's for the advise
http://www.mtgvault.com/jaap75/decks/aura-hexproof/
Tarrasque has deleted this comment.
please tell me what you think about my modern and standard decks.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hello thanks for this topic !!Im relatively new to magic and trying to construct a deck.Can you maybe give me some advise off what i could improve in my deck?http://www.mtgvault.com/johancore/decks/whiteblue-deck-final/I also look at the other decks but i dont have a clue sometimes whats going onThanks !!
Arthemio has deleted this comment.
Maybe you guys should have read the deck descriptions....
He isn't responding to anyone's decks. Even if you do it by the rules he suggests. I am owed like 20 or 30 views. So are a lot of other people. I wish this deck would be taken down. It keeps getting likes/views based on an empty promise. Weak.
Just a red black I threw together and am running now. Let me know what you think.http://www.mtgvault.com/novax13/decks/hellfire/
I commented on the deck below, I love Simic and thought it was a good find.http://www.mtgvault.com/mymobbsdeep/decks/fun-deck-evolve/I will be commenting on more later (have to go now) and I will take a look at your decks. Thanks for setting comment exchange up!
He stopped Magic Vault over 2 months ago, sir.He will not comment on your decks.
Ok thanks for the heads up. Are you taking up the cause?
No, I had my Challenge.It got taken down from the Hot Page because I made another Hot Deck (If you have 2 Hot Decks, and make another Hot Deck...the oldest of the 1st two Hot Decks get taken down). So...while my deck got taken down....this deck stays up!!! I don't get it. One of the flaws of Magic Vault, I guess. Not sure why the hell Magic Vault does not take this deck down! It doesn't deserve to keep getting likes/views/comments.This entire deck IS BASED ON AN EMPTY PROMISE. This was my Challenge Deck in which I KEPT MY PROMISE TO RESPOND EVEN THOUGH MAGIC VAULT took it down. Again, go figure:http://www.mtgvault.com/jessie/decks/static-ability-challenge/I responded to over 75 decks!Way more then this guy ever did...and again, my deck was taken off the Hot Page and this Want deck comments? deck is still at the top.
Ah, I see your frustration. I don't really see a need for this "deck" to be taken down though. I neglected to read the comments and see he wasn't responding anymore. If I had done so, I wouldn't have posted. So it's my fault and my waste of time which, while somewhat regrettable, isn't that big a deal. Hey, at least one guy got a comment from me, and I am going to go and comment more. Sounds like Magic Vault didn't take your deck down, I can see it if I click on your name. Looks like it is merely not featured as Hot anymore. Since you still follow through with your challenge, I can see why it would be frustrating for this deck to be featured and not yours.In the end, this deck is supposed to encourage people to go out and comment. While he may not be living up to his promise, I think the attitude he is encouraging is a good one.
I meant, it got taken down from the Hot Pages and his did not. It is a sham. I ended up with 20 likes for helping 75 people....and this deck has almost 100 likes and he might of looked at 10 decks, at best. Again, a rip off.
jessie is jelly
What does that even mean, lol?
jealousof burtonernie
Oh..."jelly" is "jealous" lol.No need to be jealous, silly.
PLEASE STOP POSTING ON THIS DECK, HE IS NOT RESPONDING TO ANYONE!HE HASN'T BEEN ON IN OVER 2 MONTHS.
bant legacy, any ideas? shoot awayhttp://www.mtgvault.com/elodin/decks/bant-legacy-creatures/
http://www.mtgvault.com/skullion123/decks/golgari-death/
http://www.mtgvault.com/skullion123/decks/thriving-on-death-commander/
would love someone to look at my bant hypergenesis deck, any help is greatly appreciated! http://www.mtgvault.com/elodin/decks/shardless-genesis/
Hi i know that this is not the point of this page but could some one help me with my Dragon Deck it needs mana Ramp and idk what to put in. http://www.mtgvault.com/schmidty1920/decks/dragons/ please help
hi i could use some helpthanks ; )
What do you want help with?
http://www.mtgvault.com/simicmartin35/decks/knights-of-martin-budget/
i commented on a cool deck.. http://www.mtgvault.com/wolffguy/decks/stop-thief/
I'm only a little upset that he didn't come through on his part of the bargain by commenting and liking any of my decks. but on the other hand he did successfully get a lot of people to check out and spread ideas on the unloved page. something that i think we all can agree is a good thing and should be done more often. the more frequently we all comment on and like decks, the more frequently we will get comments and likes in return. share the ideas and love of mtg
Exactly! Ever since seeing this "deck" I have tried to at least comment on one deck a day. For me, I have taken this situation of hoping to receive "promised" deck comments and turned it into something positive by commenting when I can.
I need help with my fling deckhttp://www.mtgvault.com/tornorock/decks/fling-burst/