ManiacalManiac

38 Decks, 1,216 Comments, 364 Reputation

Pretty Solid build. I would add 4x more fetches since they combo with Hedron Crab so well. And 2x Ghost Quarter b/c F#ck Eldrazi and Tron. Not to mention they combo great with Archive trap.

0
Posted 19 March 2017 at 12:39 as a comment on Millstraction

Permalink

Then you you shouldn't be playing Pia's Revolution at all. The point of the card is to get your artifacts back to hand to reuse them to your advantage.

0
Posted 18 March 2017 at 23:44 in reply to #597093 on Pia's Pets (My Standard Atog)

Permalink

And you don't see this as a positive? Do you not want all your artifacts back in your hand to reuse them. If this is not how you prefer things then your opponent could chose this regardless.

0
Posted 18 March 2017 at 23:30 in reply to #597093 on Pia's Pets (My Standard Atog)

Permalink

Cookemup78 you're incorrect. Multiple copies will require your opponent to take 6 damage.

0
Posted 18 March 2017 at 14:37 in reply to #597093 on Pia's Pets (My Standard Atog)

Permalink

With such a high curve and low land count I foresee issues getting your big threats into play before the game is over. I'd consider adding 2 copies of Cabal Coffers for mana acceleration. As well perhaps 1 or 2 Reanimate to the main deck to bring back your heavy hitters after they fall victim to your opponents removal. I think I would cut Blood Tribute, Necromantic Thirst and probably both Elixers.

0
Posted 05 March 2017 at 16:43 as a comment on 30 Days of Night

Permalink

2 for 1d. Is saying that your opponent is going to destroy/remove the creature you attempt to enchant with the aura. Effectively dealing with two of your cards with one of thiers. 2 for 1.

IMO is "In My Opinion"

0
Posted 01 March 2017 at 13:02 in reply to #595768 on Life and counters

Permalink

Looks solid.
Perhaps 1 or 2 Celestial Colonnade would be useful.

0
Posted 26 February 2017 at 18:04 as a comment on Modern Jeskai Custom Control

Permalink

Hero's Downfall is better then Ruinous Path if you're worried about PWs. Go for the Throat or Dismember would probably be better yet if not.
Not to sure where to fit it in, but Corpsejack Menace is probably worth one or two slots. Maybe instead of Servant of the Scale. Not sure tho.

0
Posted 26 February 2017 at 17:57 as a comment on B/G Snek

Permalink

I think it's a bit off stating in your description that it's a 2 card combo then immediately explaining in your how to play that in fact it's not since you need another card being a sac outlet with an ability to actually make it do something. Just saying and I'm sorry for being "that guy".
BTW this deck is horrible. LOL
I love it.

0
Posted 26 February 2017 at 16:21 as a comment on Clunky Combo (Modern)

Permalink

Orzhov Basilica and the other bounce lands are really bad in a format with land destruction like Ghost Quarter. IMO they just aren't worth the risk and putting yourself back a turn by entering tapped. 4x Concealed Courtyard in it's place would be better I think other then the obvious choice of Shock and Fetch lands since they are so pricey.

I also agree with willisson7 that having 4 copies of Grave Pact as well as 3 copies of Dictate of Erebos is very redundant and you will hate drawing yet another late game if you already have one or even two in play. The same applies to Dark Prophecy. Pherexian Arena would probably be better in it's place. I think Sifter of Skulls would be a great addition in place of the enchantments.

Shirei, Shizo's Careta is a huge investment for only comboing with 2 Blood Artist and Cutthroat. As well it's just so weak an dies to everything. Mikaeus, the Unhallowed would be way better. Admittedly It is very expensive tho.

These are just my opinions and should be taken as such. Happy Casting.

0
Posted 26 February 2017 at 16:08 as a comment on Stop I'll die!.or..WILL YOU?!!

Permalink

Any questions, comments or general discussion is always welcomed.
Happy Casting all. :)

0
Posted 26 February 2017 at 15:23 as a comment on Gr!x!s Summon!ngs

Permalink

Really solid build. +1 I can only think of a few minor improvements.
+2 Stirring Wildwood, -2 Ravorverge thicket
+4 Windswept Heath, -4 basic lands.
+2 Ghost Quarters, -2 Basics.
+1 Sigarda, Host of Herons, -1 Wilt-Leaf Cavaliers
+2 Leyline of Sanctity for the S/B.
+2 Surgical Extraction for the S/B

0
Posted 25 February 2017 at 22:15 as a comment on Selesnya-Aggro

Permalink

4x Metalic Mimic in place of Lone Rider. 4x Fatal Push in place of Essence Extraction and 1 Ruinous Path.

0
Posted 25 February 2017 at 20:15 as a comment on Friends in dark places

Permalink

+1 from me for sure, overall.
A few minor suggestions if I may. (Mostly personal preferences).
I think 2 more lands is going to make your draws more consistent and you really don't want to miss your first 4 land drops. I think you could safely cut 1 Phyrexian Arena and 1 copy of Thoughtsieze for this.
As well I think having 3x Fatal Push and 1 Dismember main deck would be more versatile/Useful instead of your current Doom Blades and Victim of Nights.
I also really like the suggestion of Panharmonicon which Esqo. Doubling your Gatekeeper and Messenger triggers not to mention the Merchant is just amazing. I understand what you're trying to do with the Whip but I think it's just a bit too slow. Having to invest 8 mana into an artifact before getting any real value is a lot for modern. Yes the Lifelink will be a factor in some match ups I think Panharmonicon will be more useful.

Of course these are just my opinions and should be taken as such. Happy Casting :)

0
Posted 25 February 2017 at 19:27 as a comment on Mono-Black Devotion

Permalink

I'd consider playing Metallic Rebuke over Revolutionary Rebuff. More often then not you're gonna be able to cast it for the same cost or cheaper while it having a steeper cost for your opponent.

0
Posted 25 February 2017 at 17:55 as a comment on Mirror Angel

Permalink

Personally I think you could put the Stormbreath Dragon to 2 of and add 1 copy of Empty the Warrens and 1 copy of Tendrils of Agony. They both act as alternate win conditions in the case your Grapeshot or Dragon get targeted by Surgical Extraction or the likes of.
As well one or possibly 2 copies of Past in Flames will help win games.
Lastly Preordain, Ponder and Brainstorm are all upgrades to Serum Visions IMHO.

0
Posted 25 February 2017 at 17:04 as a comment on storm deck

Permalink

It seems wrong to me, not to auto include 4x Visions of Beyond in any mill deck. Especially one with Sphinx's Tutelage.

1
Posted 20 February 2017 at 13:22 as a comment on Dissolver mill:

Permalink

The main problem budget decks like this one have is the land base as well as good removal.
In regards to the land 4x Sunpetal Grove would be the best option if you have so many basics.
As far as removal goes Reciprocate, Immolating Glare and Smite are decent budget options.

0
Posted 19 February 2017 at 18:03 as a comment on (Modern) Budget Bogles

Permalink

The fact she's indestructible for when Worldslayer goes off along with the Ooze Rosverde would only need 1 other green symbol to turn on devotion.
However Rancor would be another great addition as well.

1
Posted 19 February 2017 at 17:37 in reply to #596324 on Predator Ooze is MVP! Modern

Permalink

Covenant of Blood needs to go. It's just not good. Fatal Push in it's place.
Phyrexian Arena instead of Underworld Connections.
Liliana Vess and Archetype of Finality are both to slow for modern in my opinion. I think you would find Geralf's Messenger to be more useful in this build.
Just my opinions happy casting.

0
Posted 19 February 2017 at 17:30 as a comment on David B devotion

Permalink

1-20 of 1,204 items

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last