ManiacalManiac

43 Decks, 1,314 Comments, 390 Reputation

Holy Shit this deck is Hot Garbage!
I've been playing a competitive modern Ponza deck for about 6 months now. It has gone threw many tweaks and iterations. After all that I even admit that it's fairly inconsistent because it suffers from not coming back from having your T1 ramp destroyed. However that deck very much put's this deck to shame in every way.
I really don't know where to begin. Pointing out all the major flaws in this build or commenting on how obnoxious and childish your comments make you sound. Well there it is I guess I started on that and I will choose to not comment further.

The only thing I will do for you is post a link to my deck so can gain some understanding of the archetype you're trying to mimic.
http://www.mtgvault.com/maniacalmaniac/decks/rg-ponza/

BTW Don't comment on it I do not care what you have to say. I have also already unsubscribed from this piece of Shit, so don't bother wearing out another keyboard on little old me.

0
Posted Thursday at 04:16 as a comment on BEST Tyr 1 Turn 1 Kil Lan Dek?

Permalink

For starters thanks for the like and taking the time to comment.

I like where your heads at as far as limiting opponents resources. the only thing I'm concerned with, is that Shrieking Affliction tends to turn on around turn 5 with the support of a dedicated discard deck running Liliana of the Veil and Ensnaring Bridge. (Which sadly are 2 cards I do not own at the current time).
Since Smallpox only deals 1 damage, that would also create a spell that would not be enough to trigger Ascension. Playing that way I think Ascension would not end up getting turned on until turn 6 or so. Making it almost a necessity to have Ensnaring Bridge in play to survive against aggro decks. I do agree it's worth trying out tho.

The way the build is now It's possible to have it activated by turn 3 or more often by 4 while still clogging up the battlefield with creatures. (Not to mention I own everything listed above).

My thoughts on SSG were that it offers a surprise mana source when playing against Spell Pierce, Mana Leak. Also creating a situation where I could cast one of my 2cmc creatures on T2 and still have a way to threat Lightning Bolt. In addition yet again it provides a way to T2 Blood Moon in matches where I side that in. (My experience playing RG Ponza has taught me T2 Blood Moon is hand over fist better then a T3 Blood Moon).

Anyway these are a few of my thoughts on the subject thanks again for commenting.
Happy Casting :)

0
Posted 14 January 2018 at 23:59 in reply to #610555 on Bloody Crank

Permalink

Any comments or suggestion will be appreciated.
I'm debating adding 4x Simian Spirit Guides to speed up the potential combo.

0
Posted 14 January 2018 at 21:41 as a comment on Bloody Crank

Permalink

Why add Rhox Faithmender? I just feel like doubling unlimited life is a tad greedy.

0
Posted 05 January 2018 at 15:17 in reply to #610349 on Starving Sisters Combo

Permalink

"Famished" Paladin, just sayin. Hate Being that guy.
Also Necrodrex is right that the combo has the same outcome using Midnight Guard. They both give unlimited life and tokens.
I would go all in on the combo and run 4 of each. I would cut Nest Invader all together for the Midnight Guard.
Then cut Resplendent Mentor and Lone Rider to add the 4th copy of Presence of Gond to main deck the Heroic Intervention and add Blossoming Defence to protect the combo.

0
Posted 05 January 2018 at 15:16 as a comment on Starving Sisters Combo

Permalink

Nice deck. Seems like it has a ton of potential.
IMO Tidehollow Sculler is your weakest card. With the full play sets of Thoughtsieze and Inquisitions I don't think you need a need piece of hand disruption. Especially considering the amount of removal in the build. At first glance without testing the deck personally I think your lacking in the ability to close out the game fast. I'm a huge fan of Swiftspear as DedWards has suggested However I think Young Pyromancer would make the best addition since you're gonna be controlling the ground so well. I also like Bedlam Reveler as a 1 or 2 of as drakeraenes suggested.

In addition when you do decide to make a side board I highly recommend a 2 cmc answer for artifacts. Chalice on 1 will shut down this build and send you straight into scoop phase.

Anyway just my opinions.
Happy Casting :)

0
Posted 05 January 2018 at 14:07 as a comment on Modern N2O (New Decktype)

Permalink

No problem, I'm glad you like some of my suggestions.

I understand what you mean about having blockers just in case or getting early pings in when possible. I've just come to realize in every game where you're able to take advantage of having 4 mana on turn 2 general puts you so far ahead. Especially in a build like this with 16 cmc 2 spells. being able to play 2 spells on turn 2 advances your board a full turn ahead each turn the combo stays in play, IMO the benefit of that grossly over shadows the other. At the very least I urge you to play test a few games this way.

Vernal Bloom is risky because it says each forest. Not each forest you control. So it benefits your opponents forests as well. Which means more often then not you will play Vernal Bloom and your opponent is the first player to take full advantage of the benefit. Obviously this is only an issue when playing against another deck running forests but the danger is still present. Like I said if someone were to play that against me I would likely be able to capitalize on the benefit then remove it before you could the following turn. At least that's what I would try to do. Hence "Risky" .

As far as a deeper analysis on Life Goes On in place of Stream of Life which I see you've completely removed is that it's a specific side board card for a specific match up which I believe you may have trouble against. Burn! I see what you mean about Stream of Life being a great late game boost once your deck is set up doing what is meant to do. However Life Goes On is meant to be a better alternative before that on turn 3 or 4 when burn is running away with the game. Gaining 8 life at that point in the game is usually devastating against burn.

Anyway, again just my opinions shared.
Happy Casting :)

1
Posted 05 January 2018 at 13:36 in reply to #610308 on Mono Green Mana Monster

Permalink

Nice deck, I've always loved Mono Green.
A few suggestions include cutting the 8 elves you are running and replace with 4x Arbor Elf and 4x Utopia Sprawl. On there own they have exactly the same ramp with the added bonus of being combo together. 4 mana turn 2 is just an amazing place to be in. as well as Utopia Sprawl being less likely to be hit by removal. After all rule one in modern for me is. When in doubt kill the mana dork, Every Time.
In addition I think the Vernal Bloom is just to risky to play. I run a competitive LD deck in modern and if my opponent played that I would shake his hand and be over joyed. I think Overgrowth would be much more beneficial for just you. Especially if you decided to go the Arbor Elf Utopia Sprawl route.
As far as main deck I think you're running to many Time of Need. I would cut 2 for the Inclusion of Beast Within as a green answer for just about anything in the format.
For side board I would replace Stream of Life with Life Goes On. Much better against burn. I'd -1 Dismember and run 2 of these.
As well I really don't like Deconstruct, the only match up I would bring it in would be Affinity and removing 1 artifact in that match for 3 mana is just not as effective. I'd play 2x Creeping Corrosion instead. And switch Naturalize for Nature's Claim. the 4 life is irrelevant when Emrakul is involved.
Lifecrafter's Bestiary would probably be a better card to bring in against control for card draw in my opinion.
Only other thing would be the need for graveyard hate in the form of 2x Relic of Progenitus Maybe -1 Spellskite and 1 more Dismember for this.

Anyway just my opinions take for what it is.
Happy Casting :)

1
Posted 03 January 2018 at 16:42 as a comment on Mono Green Mana Monster

Permalink

Could you explain just how Crucible has synergy with anything other then the 8 fetch lands? If you include Leonin Arbiter, Ghost Quarter and Field of Ruin you would get a land destruction lock. I also wouldn't play more then 2 Crucibles.

Also I don't see a single "prison" card in the entire build other then Stoic Angel. Due Respect is a bad card for this strategy since it's only a one turn effect. Authority of the Consuls would make a much better replacement since it's a lasting effect.
Some other permanent with lasting effects that should be considered for a "prison" deck would include.
Ghostly Prison(name sack card for the archetype), Sphere of Safety, Porphyry Nodes, Rule of Law, Runed Halo, Norn's Annex and Leyline of Sanctity as a side board card against combo, burn, discard, mill etc...

Detention Sphere is a bette r option then Oblivion Ring when running blue.

A few creatures with taxing effects stapled to them worth considering,
Windborn Muse, Grand Arbiter Augustin IV, Ethersworn Canonist, Grand Abolisher, Thalia, Guardian of Thraben

Search for Azcanta would make a great addition as well o give you card advantage later in the game.

I really wouldn't focus on ramping for this strategy. Instead I would try to get as many taxing effects in play early on. The game will naturally go long allowing you to eventually do everything you want.

Anyway just my opinions and didn't intend on criticizing to much.
Happy Casting

0
Posted 03 January 2018 at 16:02 as a comment on Modern Crucible Control

Permalink

Nice, How does Arlinn tend to play out by the way?

0
Posted 01 January 2018 at 21:14 in reply to #610223 on R/G Ponza ;);)

Permalink

Have you considered Rings of Brighthearth in place of the Wanderer's Twig. I understand if it's not in the deck due to cost issues. I just think it could really put this deck over the top.

0
Posted 31 December 2017 at 17:39 as a comment on Korlash, Heir to Blackblade

Permalink

Well after a lot of deliberation and rigorous play testing against the top 5 Tier 1 decks in the format,over 20 matches each I've arrived at this current list. Which at the moment is what I will be bringing to the Toronto Grand Prix in February.

I've finally come to the conclusion that 2 Bonfires over the Mizzium Mortars is where I want be. (Sorry DedWards) Reasoning behind this decision is Mortars simply doesn't hit what I need it to hit at the time of a 6 mana investment Reality Smasher, Death Shadow, Goyf, etc...
as well as the incidental direct damage comes up relevant in games where it gets cast.

The addition of Tireless Tracker has been amazing to say the least. It gives the deck so much reach/draw in grindy match ups that it just didn't have before hand.

Another impressive and surprising addition is in the form of Hazoret the Fervent. She closes out games so quickly and the only thing currently being play that deals with her is Path which is seeing less play to the dominance of Push. Well also there are a few one of copies of Settle the Wreckage floating around. Either way she is a Power house.

The other main addition to the 75 I want to give credit to is Trinisphere. It started as a 2 of SB card and I found myself bring it into approximately 60-70% of my match up's. This has made me feel comfortable enough to include it as a 1 of in the main. It completely shuts down Storm, Burn, Aggro. As well as being a nightmare for control.

As far as the side board is concerned I've fallen back to the 3 of Ancient Grudge for the affinity match up. I believe early on I actually got lucky in a few matches which gave me a false sense of how the deck played against affinity. At this point it's probably my worst match up pre board but drastically improves post after cutting the LD cards for the 3 Anger of the Gods and 3 Grudges.
Another thing I'd like to point out is the removal of Crumble to Dust. It just kept feeling like I was improving an already good match up against Tron. I wanted to free the slots up for the harder match ups.
I think the only card I'm really not convinced of is Carnage Tyrant. When I read the card it just screams F#ck You you filthy control player. But a second Thrun may actually be ll I really need. Thrun comes down on average 2 turns earlier and lives through a Supreme Verdict thanks to the Regenerate. The main thing I like about the Tyrant is it's large Trampling body. I have found myself being blocked by a couple spirits from Lingering Souls for 2 turns when I should have had the match in hand.

Anyway just putting back out there for any input from the community.
Happy Casting :)

0
Posted 31 December 2017 at 17:27 as a comment on R/G Ponza ;);)

Permalink

I also agree that Spectral Procession should be in this build. I also feel Lily should be cut in place of it, not because she's a bad card by any means just that she really doesn't have any synergy with anything else other then Lingering Souls. I feel like there will be more times where a resolved Spectral would be closing out the game where Lily would be prolonging it in the same situation.

I also think Leyline of the Void would be much better suited for your side board since Void wont null your ability to flashback your own Lingering Souls. As well I think Leyline of Sanctity is must have SB card whenever possible. I would replace Purge, Secure and Lily for them
Only other thing I would suggest is switching the values of Fatal Push and Path around. Sure Path is far better in the late game against bigger threats. I just feel like it is so much better to have the upper hand early on in any given match up. As in being able to Push a mana dork turn 1 which is something you almost always want to do. Unlike casting Path on a mana dork on opp turn 2 which always feels bad since you're ramping your opponent which is essentially what they 're trying to do themselves.

Anyway just my opinions.
Happy Casting. :)

0
Posted 25 December 2017 at 19:22 as a comment on Orzhov Tokens

Permalink

In that case if you specifically built the deck for a playgroup with the majority of decks are mono coloured< I can see hoe Splinter could be considered a win condition.
The reasoning behind Acid-Moss being a better replacement is that it does do the same thing as Splinter but also does another key thing your deck is focusing on. Ramping which many times could be more beneficial to you in the scenario of playing against a deck with only 2 or 3 of any one land in a deck.
Your statement on not needing another land at that point in the game is quite incorrect. Since the goal is to get to 7 mana sources as quickly as possible to play World Breaker and at the time you would be playing Splinter or Acid-Moss if it were you would not be at 7 sources yet. Meaning you would need it.

1
Posted 23 December 2017 at 21:42 in reply to #610029 on Budget Land Destruction Combo

Permalink

You don't play much competitive modern, do you?

0
Posted 23 December 2017 at 20:53 in reply to #610029 on Budget Land Destruction Combo

Permalink

How do you figure it's a win condition?

0
Posted 23 December 2017 at 19:47 in reply to #610029 on Budget Land Destruction Combo

Permalink

As great an effect as Splinter is when it works I feel it should just be a 2 of. Since the majority of decks in modern run very few basics you are likely to never hit more then 3 cards with it. As well it would not be crippling your opponent as much as thinning their deck in many situations. 2x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss would be a good replacement I believe

1
Posted 23 December 2017 at 10:54 as a comment on Budget Land Destruction Combo

Permalink

Well actually no it won't. Echoing Ruin says each other "Artifact". Which is exactly what Risen Deep is trying to explain. The other forests in play won't be artifacts. Only way I know it would work is if you had Mycosynth Lattice in play. Which would be a really bad idea anyway since it would destroy your Forests too.

0
Posted 17 December 2017 at 13:37 in reply to #609825 on Land Shaper

Permalink

straight up Life gain cards are bad. They always have been and would need something amazing to make them playable. You should really cut Chaplain's Blessing for the missing Aven Mindcensor and Leonin Arbiter. Also I would highly suggest running some amount of Ghost Quarters since it works so well with them as well.

0
Posted 09 December 2017 at 23:23 as a comment on Marelen Lifegain Lockdown

Permalink

First of all you should probably cut Hymn to Tourach since it's not even legal in modern.
Wrech Mind is a decent budget substitute. Thoughtsieze and Inquisition of Kozilek should be your got to targeted discard spells tho.

0
Posted 09 December 2017 at 23:11 as a comment on Mono Black Sac

Permalink

1-20 of 1,310 items

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last