MattCherrie

86 Decks, 93 Comments, 37 Reputation

Ramp, dorks and stompy boys. Classic Gruul deck, bravo!

0
Posted 21 February 2024 at 16:31 as a comment on EDH: Trampled By Jank

Permalink

Have tweaked it a little to add more draw, at the cost of some of the mana rocks.

0
Posted 14 February 2024 at 21:36 as a comment on Moody Judy

Permalink

Classic zombie deck with a touch of control. Good stuff, if a little on the pricy side!

0
Posted 13 February 2024 at 23:10 as a comment on Commander: Wilhelt, Zombi

Permalink

I have a similar deck, using Sisay as the commander: https://www.mtgvault.com/mattcherrie/decks/sisay-dragon-shrines-v2/ Mine is more about shrines and dragons, but the principle is the same.
There are a couple of cards to consider including:
[[Urza's Ruinous Blast]] to destroy all non legendary creatures.
[[Chromatic Orrery]], [[Coalition Relic]], [[Timeless Lotus]], [[Prismatic Geoscope]], [[Jegantha, The Wellspring]], [[Faeburrow Elder]] and [[Bloom Tender]] are all solid WUBRG mana options, although some are a little pricy.

0
Posted 23 January 2024 at 18:12 in reply to #650565 on Jodah, unifier of legends

Permalink

[[Realm Seekers]] can fetch non-basics for you, if you're set on Urzatron.
[[Colossal Majesty]] and [[Triumph of Ferocity]] would give extra draws on your upkeep. I imagine oponents will be too busy trying to destroy your stax to worry about destroying them.
[[Trailblazer's Boots]] would be good too - Non-basic landwalk is very underrated.
Continuing the voltron goodness, how about [[Raised By Giants]] and [[Eldrazi Conscription]].

As to what to drop, I'd probably lose some of the cost modifier cards, an extra 1 mana cost isn't going to slow people down much. Maybe also drop the wild growth type enchantments, outside of an enchantress deck, I find they aren't the best.

0
Posted 23 January 2024 at 01:33 in reply to #650562 on Thrun breaker of faces-8

Permalink

FYI, Mox Emerald and Rofellos are both banned in commander.
Why is Urza's Filter in here? It doesn't help you at all, and actively helps your opponent.
I'd drop the Staff of Compleation for [[Staff of Domination]], which goes infinite with most of the big mana elves.
You don't seem to make many tokens, so Doubling Season seems a bit of a waste - I think [[Hardened Scales]] would be a better fit for your +1/+1 cards (and it's only 1 mana).
You have far too many lands, elf decks usually run less than usual due to their ability to make mana. 33-35 should be plenty. You can use the space to add more utility elves: [[Wellwisher]], [[Imperious Perfect]], [[Wirewood Channeler]] and [[Immaculate Magistrate]] (gets silly with Joraga Warcaller) are all excellent options.

1
Posted 20 January 2024 at 00:36 as a comment on ELADAMRI, LORD OF LEAVES EDH

Permalink

LOL. Great minds think alike! https://www.mtgvault.com/mattcherrie/decks/x-gon-give-it-to-ya/

0
Posted 20 January 2024 at 00:30 as a comment on [EDH]X Gonna Give It To Ya

Permalink

Fair enough. Have you considered adding [[Arcane Bombardment]]? Could be pretty fun copying all those copies every time you copy a copy!

0
Posted 13 January 2024 at 00:06 in reply to #650533 on Lutri commander spell copy-10

Permalink

Lutri is banned in commander. Having a [[Fork]] in the command zone is too scary for the powers that be!

0
Posted 10 January 2024 at 19:23 as a comment on Lutri commander spell copy-10

Permalink

Looks like a pain in the arse to play against... I like it!

Sometimes you just got to be the bad guy.

0
Posted 18 December 2023 at 17:16 as a comment on No tricks, just hate

Permalink

Yeah, I've seen a few versions of Dino Blink decks out there, and they seem pretty fun. For now, I'll stick with my dino horde!

Going to play a few games with it and see what I need to change.

0
Posted 15 December 2023 at 06:23 in reply to #650490 on Open the door get on the floor

Permalink

A lot of the new flip artifacts rely on what was used to craft, which doesn't work so well with Tetzin, although he can reset them.
Further playtesting may be required, but I'm thinking about leaning more into tokens and making the commander(s) Akiri/Kraum.

1
Posted 12 December 2023 at 15:39 in reply to #650475 on Chillin' With My Gnomie

Permalink

I'd never seen big butt tribal in red before, but I can see how Mannichi makes it fun. Keep them in big butt mode if they get blocked, and switch to big titty mode if they aren't. Add first strike into the mix, and you can do both!

I assume Abbey Gargoyles is a placeholder for Riders of the Mark?

0
Posted 08 December 2023 at 14:11 as a comment on EDH Red Moon (Big Red Butts)

Permalink

Seems to be a fairly efficient ramp deck with a ton of kill spells to keep things under control. I assume the wincon is commander damage? As you'll be drawing a ton of cards, have you considered adding cards like [[Laboratory Maniac]] and the Jace that does the same thing?

1
Posted 29 November 2023 at 01:50 as a comment on Damia Ramp EDH

Permalink

Gishath is Red/Green/White. I'm confused.

0
Posted 26 November 2023 at 12:12 in reply to #650421 on dinosaur tribal rev-10

Permalink

FYI, Indoraptor is Red/Blue/Black, so can't be in this deck. Otherwise, it's a pretty sweet Dino deck!

0
Posted 25 November 2023 at 18:18 as a comment on dinosaur tribal rev-10

Permalink

You have a few cards that help increase the number of counters on creatures, but not much to put them on in the first place. Some evolve creatures would probably be good, and they're mostly pretty cheap: [[Gyre Sage]], [[Fathom Mage]] for example. Adapt creatures like [[Incubation Druid]] would be good too.
Why not use the counters as a weapon? [[Simic Ascendancy]], [[Darksteel Reactor]] and [[Lux Artillery]]/[[Lux Cannon]] are all exellent for this.
More planeswalkers would be good - [[Jiang Yanggu, Wildcrafter]] would be one you definitely want. It's not flashy, but it will help with your counters and ramp, and it's only about £0.05.
I've got a pretty similar deck, feel free to use it for ideas! https://www.mtgvault.com/mattcherrie/decks/vorel-proliferate-v3/

2
Posted 20 September 2023 at 17:47 as a comment on EDH Proliferate & Swarm : HELP

Permalink

Or he could just be using the numbers to indicate version numbers. I do the same thing with some of my decks. Maybe the previous versions are set to private.

I actually accused someone of being a bot recently. I'm talking an EDH deck with duplicate cards, off-colour cards and no mana sources for some of the colours - I was convinced it was an AI generated deck, but it turned out they were just really, really bad at deckbuilding!

0
Posted 12 September 2023 at 18:41 in reply to #650124 on Frog Control to Major Tom - 9

Permalink

Just ignore him. WDM is a conspiracy theorist who insists that everyone on here is a part of some secret cabal sending coded messages through their decks.

0
Posted 12 September 2023 at 18:07 in reply to #650124 on Frog Control to Major Tom - 9

Permalink

Kaho only works with instants, so it can't fetch beseech the queen, sorry. Might want to drop the monuments, as you probably don't have enough creatures for them to be much use - I'd add some enchantress cards for extra draw.

0
Posted 25 August 2023 at 15:43 as a comment on Shrine Time Baby

Permalink

1-20 of 92 items

1 2 3 4 5 Last