MDStrawHat

mmm i'm interested...... Looks complex and clever too

Hi you commented on my Deck so im commenting on yours.

A Sound deck i think. A good ratio of creatures against other stuff. Child of Night might work that has lifelink and therefore might fit your deck

Please to anyone else who comments which would be better 2 Niv-Mizzet, the Fireminds or 2 Malfegors??

please don't decide on how good the card is individually but how good you think it works in my deck.

PLEASE READ ABOVE PLEASE READ ABOVE PLEASE READ ABOVE PLEASE READ ABOVE

Megrim is a sick card don't get me wrong my only reservation is this. Although Megrim might seem like the obvious choice in this deck it doesn't fit. A crucial part of this deck is to be able to cast everything as quickly as your picking up this would slow things down. I'm far better off casting 3 other things than one of these its as simple as that (bannerets make rogue cards cheaper so). I also feel Cover of Darkness is unneeded. Two reasons being 1 that most of my creatures are already evasive and 2 Although you might not see it just by the card list this deck has a major swarm factor so i'll still get damage through by sheer numbers. Nor does cover of darkness replace cloak and daggers function. The Blackguard and Fortune thief are worth protecting in my mind. Anyway thanks for the suggestions but those are my reasons

@EVERYONE ELSE

PLEASE NO MORE COMMENTS ABOUT MEGRIM. THANKS

Very well but i meant what happens when two players have prince of thralls out and a third player looses a permanent. Which of the two prince of thralls controllers gets the permanent of the other player?

Lol i like first of all i like the title. O my god i'd completely forgotten about Relentless Rats. I was about to comment about you having 30 but then i read it. that's insane. Well needless to say good deck. Must get a little boring to play though what? Pick up Relentless Rat. Cast Relentless Rat. Next turn. Pick up Relentless Rat. Cast Relentless Rat.....

PS please comment on my deck

Looks like a great deck. Your planes walkers look very well protected by your other cards. 19 lands seems to work in your deck as your creatures are all mostly around 3 mana. Very tenacious too.

Thanks for the suggestion. It would probably definitely make my deck more tenacious. I'll play test it and maybe replace it for cloak and dagger. Ive put it in the sideboard for now. It definitely has the advantage of protecting all my creatures not just one.

Awesome Deck. Really awesome choice of cards. One thing though why didn't you choose argothian enchantress over veduran enchantress (maybe legality issue i guess). Life gaining in these kind of epic proportions would be difficult for any deck to deal with i think.

PS please comment on my deck. Thanks

Nice Deck. Simple but not uneffective. Probably surprising how many decks would loose to this simple formula. Well balanced. Not to sure about wasting a spell just to untap Deep-Slumber Titan every time though.

PS please comment on my deck

Would love to play this deck on MTGO but not even signed up myself

I'm Loving this deck. Really good once you have Knight-Captain of Eos out cause you can swarm attacking with everything without worry of them lashing back. I just love it. Chose cards with really good artwork too. Inspires me to make a soldier deck of my own. Catapult master is awesome too. One of me favorite decks.

PS Please comment on my deck

First of all very well designed deck. I see you have the old horseshoe crab hermetic study thing going on. I feel every good deck needs some means of drawing cards which you've got in quicksilver dagger. I got a question for you. How does prince of thralls work in a three player when two people have it out and the third person loses a permanent? who gets control? anyways nice deck man

PS please comment on my deck

Nice deck. I always think that life gaining is one of the most powerful ways of influencing the game although i know some people don't think much of it. Also it can be surprising how many decks actually have trouble dealing with a deck heavy on fliers Surely there's something better than excommunicate though and 20 lands seems a bit sparse.

PS Please comment on my deck

I did consider using megrim and i might add it. However, consider that for the most part(excluding noggin whacks) i have to deal combat damage to make them discard a card, my point being that stinkdrinker bandit gives +2/+1 for every creature that deals combat damage anyway. So i deal him plus 2 damage even when he has no cards plus Stinkdrinker bandit is rogue and therefore fits better. Still could add it though and have the noggin whacks do 4 damage a piece. I'll think it over. Thanks for your comment

You could add that new Urge to Feed from worldwake

Very nice Deck indeed Prison Term and Recumbent Bliss work well especially as you can move the prison term meaning you can't really "waste" it on the wrong creature. Have you considered Mark of Eviction in place of unsummon it would work awesome with your Sigil of the Empty Throne.

PS Please come comment on my deck

By the way @anyone else (shameful typo there)

@phantomonkey I take your point. However the blackguard does gives +1/+1 counters so it shouldn't be to much of a worry
@Setherial Yeah Thanks mate. I Love rogues

By the any one @else if you comment on my deck i will comment yours if you ask

Nice deck. I think you're right this would kick the shit out of most aggro decks, probably would include mine in that list. Please comment and rate my deck