Anon88

139 Decks, 198 Comments, 44 Reputation

True, but WotC have in the past noted how broken certain cards were and down right banned them from all formats or certain formats. If people complain hard enough then the message might get across, if not there's always Rule Zero and local group banned lists.

0
Posted 10 May 2025 at 19:12 in reply to #651584 on Voice of Victory: Discussion

Permalink

I get what you're saying and agree that there are cards that make you question what Wizards of the Coast was thinking when they made them but all of them can be countered/tackled (I don't think there are cards that are impossible to counter/tackle save for the Split Second cards). Some will need a great deal of creative thinking that's true, but I feel that's what makes the game a little interesting.

It's either that or Rule Zero the cards you feel are overpowered or don't make sense. That's the beauty of this game, the versatility of how you and your group can play the game in my opinion.

0
Posted 10 May 2025 at 09:15 as a comment on Voice of Victory: Discussion

Permalink

Many thanks for the card ideas, I know that not everyone likes to play EDH so I don't expect much of a response.

I did actually consider using the Marauders as other sac triggers but I wasn't sure if I could get a consistent reanimation setup to keep cycling through them. I might tinker around another version of this deck which includes them. I instead opted for the low cost creatures which can reanimate themselves so that I can get away with using the Braids and the Smokestack as much as possible.

Tainted Aether looks awesome but I feel it is works heavily against the player as much as the opponent with the current deck setup, unless you have the right board already in play which would give an instant win through ping damage.

I went ahead and added Smallpox and Painful Quandary by removing Blasphemous Edict and Braids's Frightful Return as I total missed them.

0
Posted 04 May 2025 at 19:14 in reply to #651573 on Guess who's back

Permalink

So quick update, deck worked like a charm in the first round and took everyone by surprise. But the next couple of games they had me figured out and put me on the ropes multiple of times. Luckily the deck has some flexibility but others is slow to recuperate after a board wipe.

To help improve the deck a little I removed four of the Hawks in favour of more card draw in the form of Rogue's Gloves and Bygone Bishop. I also added Ornithopter of Paradise and Darksteel Mutation for added mana ramp and board interaction.

0
Posted 26 April 2025 at 08:08 as a comment on Tempest Hawk EDH

Permalink

I'd suggest Amulet of Vigor as a good combo piece with Root Maze to negate it's negative effects on your side of the board.
Also instead of Prismatic Ending I'd go for Stroke of Midnight as it allows you to target anything without restriction at instant speed.

0
Posted 17 April 2025 at 02:24 as a comment on Legacy Labyrinth (Competitive)

Permalink

Thanks for the suggestions, I added Cut a Deal and removed a card I felt didn't quite fit the theme.

1
Posted 08 March 2025 at 15:02 in reply to #651496 on The Chaos of Giving

Permalink

Looks great from my end, hope the play testing goes well for you.
I might just try and make an EDH version of this unique idea.

Will keep you posted if I manage to start thinking of one.

1
Posted 01 March 2025 at 17:32 in reply to #651480 on Gifted Tokens - 60

Permalink

To add to dknight27's suggestions, I have done some research on the matter and there are quite a few other cards that allow you to give tokens to your opponent. Here's a list of them for you to consider:
Grismold, the Dreadsower, Sylvan Offering, Tempt with Vengeance, Eiganjo Uprising and Curse of the Swine

As a compliment to the pillow cards Angel's Trumpet is a good card to make them suffer post-combat.
I like the deck concept, hope you can manage to make it work.

1
Posted 01 March 2025 at 06:00 as a comment on Gifted Tokens - 60

Permalink

Many thanks for the like and suggestions, I tweaked the deck slightly.

I try to avoid looking at expensive cards like Cabal Coffers and Cabal Stronghold to keep my decks affordable to anyone who wishes to try them out. That is unless they are crucial for the deck to function and I have no choice in the matter.

1
Posted 26 February 2025 at 08:58 in reply to #651472 on Shaders Required

Permalink

I've been going through some of my deck ideas for an affinity build and thought you'd like to know about these cards:

Machinate - a good way to tutor for that critical card based on the number of artefacts you have in play
Monumental Corruption - a good damage dealer should you not be able to connect with your creatures (rather high in mana though)
Welding Jar - Another zero cost artefact which gives regenerate (even to non-creature artefacts)
Override - That classic counter spell
Irradiate - For those big boys/girls you might face
Desynchronization - A good board clear for the finishing blow (four mana but a good card)

I have other card ideas but they are more for slow meta affinity decks rather than the fast build you are going with.

1
Posted 01 February 2025 at 18:25 as a comment on Bauble Broodstar Affinity - 60

Permalink

Thanks for bringing back memories of when I started playing the game seriously.
One suggestion, Cranial Plating and you'd have a quick win deck easy.

0
Posted 28 January 2025 at 15:43 as a comment on Bauble Broodstar Affinity - 60

Permalink

What is your goal with this deck? To generate a lot of Energy?
If so might I suggest cards like Satya, Aetherflux Genius, Izzet Generatorium and Aether Refinery.
I would also suggest some finishers like Electrostatic Pummeler, Razorfield Ripper and Whirler Virtuoso

Otherwise, great deck :)

0
Posted 26 January 2025 at 05:54 as a comment on Artifact Energy

Permalink

If you want to make the deck a little broken maybe consider Conspiracy, Orah, Skyclave Hierophant and Profane Prayers.
The first will ensure all creatures on your side of the board are clerics which will also pair well with Profane Prayers.
Also Orah can also fix your graveyard issue and keep your board stocked.

0
Posted 18 January 2025 at 16:59 as a comment on Cleric Tribal Scion - 65

Permalink

If you're going for a red/green build like you said then maybe consider Replicating Ring as a compliment Svella's ability to create more snow permanents.

0
Posted 18 January 2025 at 05:29 as a comment on Snow-Covered Skred - 65

Permalink

This looks really good mate, well done. :)

0
Posted 18 January 2025 at 05:06 in reply to #651344 on Varchild's Rampage Lure - 60

Permalink

Many thanks for the idea, will remove a card to include it.
I also replaced a mountain to include Forbidden Orchard as an extra mana fix and blocker generator.

1
Posted 18 January 2025 at 05:03 in reply to #651345 on Marhault's Rampage

Permalink

Have you considered cards like Master's Call, Myr Kinsmith, Myr Matrix and Myrsmith?

0
Posted 17 January 2025 at 16:26 as a comment on ITS MYR Time!

Permalink

Thanks for reminding me about this old mechanic, completely slipped my mind.
Going to try and build an EDH deck around it.

In the meantime, here are some card ideas for you to consider (giving you cheap options):
General Marhault Elsdragon, Noble Quarry, Shinen of Life's Roar, Roar of Challenge, Predatory Rampage, Retaliation, Invasion Plans and No Quarter

1
Posted 15 January 2025 at 20:01 as a comment on Varchild's Rampage Lure - 60

Permalink

Pity they're unlisted as I am sure you had interesting ideas like this one

1
Posted 05 December 2024 at 06:00 in reply to #650857 on infinite combo

Permalink

It is not a case of impacting the board state but rather a way around the Bitterblossom life loss making you being able to last longer in a game of attrition. There are of course other ways this can be tackled like Bastion of Remembrance but at the cost of losing board state by blocking with your tokens.

In all honesty I wouldn't remove Bitterblossom from the deck as you'd need blockers to protect against difficult to remove creatures and deal the finishing blow.

0
Posted 03 December 2024 at 04:52 in reply to #651239 on Modern Microwave (Competitive)

Permalink

1-20 of 198 items

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Last