doctorhydrogen

81 Decks, 1,246 Comments, 346 Reputation

Sacc outlets proved the most valuable part of the deck for me. There were so many times having a Goblin Bombardment or Ashnod's Alter let me just end people 2-3 turns earlier than I would have been otherwise.

Both Ashnod's Altar and Phyrexian Altar also go infinite with a landfall token maker (Omnath, Sporemound, Zendikar's Roil, Rampaging Baloths) and Perilous forays on board.

Plus then stuff like Tempt with Vengeance and Firecat Blitz (errated to make elemental cat tokens) turn into stupid burn spells.

0
Posted 29 April 2016 at 16:24 as a comment on Omnath, Locus of Rage EDH

Permalink

Valakut the Molten Pinnacle has been solid for me in Mina and Denn.

1
Posted 27 April 2016 at 13:02 as a comment on (EDH) Mina and Denn, Wildborn

Permalink

Primal Surge reads "Win Target Game" in this deck, though I'd probably run Akroma's Memorial or Concordant Crossroads with it to make sure you get haste, too.

Lurking Predators would probably do good work here as well.

0
Posted 25 April 2016 at 11:50 as a comment on Sigarda's Friends

Permalink

Hall of Gemstone. Because why should other people be able to cast counterspells? Or multi-colored spells? Or their commander if it's not mono?

0
Posted 22 April 2016 at 18:51 as a comment on EDH - Seton, Krosan Protector

Permalink

IMO 38 creatures is way, way too many in a deck that isn't intentionally running extra creatures for a win-con via something like Primal Surge. It's asking to over-extend into a board wipe while simultaneously leaving you with too few answers.

Fell the Mighty would do good work here, as would Kin-Tree Invocation and Wave of Reckoning.

0
Posted 18 April 2016 at 15:30 as a comment on Doran EDH

Permalink

Where Land Tax gets great is when you can use the extra lands to swap with Scroll Rack into new cards, then tutor them again next turn and do it again. It's strong enough that I started running Enlightened Tutor just to get whichever one I don't have.

0
Posted 17 April 2016 at 02:44 in reply to #580205 on Darien, King of Pain

Permalink

Mitotic Manipulation is one of the few ways to ramp land in mono-blue. I run it in Talrand because three mana to make a drake and ramp a land is a fantastic value, but I'd say it's almost worth it just to ramp a land. After all Wayfarer's Bauble does the same thing at the same total cost.

I stopped running Counterbalance because it just didn't work often enough even with Scroll Rack and Divining Top to manipulate my top card. I have a hard time seeing it do great work without them, but ymmv.

I feel like Swan Song is going to work as a 1 mana counter a lot more often than Force Spike.

Long-term I'd convert your islands to snow-covered islands so nobody else gets to take advantage of your Extraplanar Lents. It also then enables you to run Scrying Sheets as a sometimes-ramp mana sink.

0
Posted 17 April 2016 at 00:42 as a comment on Grandma's Spending Spree EDH

Permalink

Crackdown can do good work in mono-white.

I personally wouldn't run Howling Mine in a deck without a way to tap it and urn it off (or in Nekusar). Getting one card for every 3-4 your enemies get is terrible math. Mind's Eye is solid, and I think Tamiyo's Journal is going to wind up being decent in mono-white (or mono-red or Boros, both of which have the same issues).

Tithe and Land Tax both are really helpful, if unflashy. Of course if you run Land Tax it's hard to resist running Scroll Rack, and those two cards will wind up being another $40 bucks or so, where as Tithe is like $4.

Micho Konda, Truth Seeker fits nicely with your theme of "attacking me is bad".

Expedition Map is good way to get one of your damage-myself-make-a-dude lands.

1
Posted 17 April 2016 at 00:32 as a comment on Darien, King of Pain

Permalink

Commander's Authority is a lot of mana for little return and is just asking to get two-for-one'ed when the creature dies.

Pulsemage Advocate seems dangerous.


0
Posted 16 April 2016 at 02:54 in reply to #580128 on Sigarda EDH

Permalink

Descendants' Path and Lurking Predators would play well here.

Mirror Entity counts as a human, and would allow a massive alpha strike, as would Tribal Unity.



0
Posted 15 April 2016 at 18:51 as a comment on Sigarda EDH

Permalink

Pariah's Shield? You've got an indestructible commander, may as well shunt all damage you take to him.

0
Posted 11 April 2016 at 17:07 as a comment on Tajic EDH

Permalink

Hero's Downfall > Murder

0
Posted 04 April 2016 at 12:41 as a comment on Bow To Sheoldred

Permalink

No Caltrops or Staff of Nin? Those are both pretty solid artifacts to animate and give deathtouch.

0
Posted 03 April 2016 at 15:27 as a comment on Sydri, Galvanic Genius

Permalink

Be cautious; I wound up taking apart my Merieke deck just because it generated such crappy game states. It wasn't unfair or anything, but since nobody wanted their stuff stolen they figured they'd wait until the next guy played a target, and it basically turned games into a boring two hour slog of people not actually playing magic.

That said:

Arena of the Ancients was a bomb. Your commander doesn't untap, so why should anyone else's?

0
Posted 30 March 2016 at 15:51 as a comment on Merieke Ri Berit Control EDH

Permalink

Glare of Subdual and/or Opposition work really well in Rafiq because you tend to have a lot of untapped dudes not doing much. Why use them as blockers when you can just tap the scariest attacker?

1
Posted 29 March 2016 at 15:53 as a comment on Bant Exalted[EDH]

Permalink

Hall of Gemstone? It basically stops counterspells and makes multi-colored spells unplayable, neither of which you have.

Deglamer/Unravel the Aether > Naturalize. I reject the notion that your Theros God or Darksteel whatever or Blightsteel Collosus should resist my removal, and I further reject the notion that once I deal with your artifact or enchantment you should be able to get it back easily from your graveyard.

0
Posted 29 March 2016 at 15:43 as a comment on Omnath - EDH

Permalink

IMO Disenchant just doesn't make the cut anymore over Revoke Existence or Fate Forgotten or Return to Dust. There's just too many Theros gods or Darksteel whatever or Blighsteel Colossos or graveyard recursion. When I remove your artifact/enchantment I want it GONE, and it's worth one more mana on a Fate Forgotten or sorcery speed on a Revoke Existence (or both on Return to Dust) to have it GONE.

Emeria the Sky Ruin would play nicely here.

0
Posted 21 March 2016 at 22:21 as a comment on Odric, Lunarch Marshal EDH

Permalink

I used to tell everyone running mono-green to get a Hall of Gemstone asap. It doesn't hurt you a bit, it keeps your stuff from getting counterspelled, and shuts down a ton of decks and commanders.

But then Wednesday happened and it spiked from fifty cents to thirty bucks.

Still, if you have one in a bot, I'd run it :)

0
Posted 18 March 2016 at 16:50 as a comment on Azusa Goddess of Mana

Permalink

Essence Harvest ends people in Karlov decks.

0
Posted 17 March 2016 at 15:14 as a comment on You can leave your hat on

Permalink

Generally speaking outside of a deck with weird, baked-in ways to play a ton of swarm guys or cheat stuff out, 35 creatures is too much in EDH. You can only play so many per turn without overextending into a wipe, and with that many you're not going to have enough to do per turn BUT overextend. I'd cut at least 7, if not 10, and fill the slots with draw, removal and/or utility.

Chaos Warp should be in here. It's your only way to deal with enchantments, but it's a great removal spell in it's own right.

1
Posted 17 March 2016 at 15:13 as a comment on Vampire's EDH

Permalink

121-140 of 1,209 items