Discussion Forum

stack process

Ok, here is scenario, Player 1 has Oracle of muldaya with bear umbra and attacks, player 2 has sheperd of the lost with snake umbra and blocks attack, now player 1 casts naturalize on the snake umbra, what happens first?

does the attack take place first since sheperd has first strike, killing the bear umbra or does the instant naturalize negate the snake umbra and the sheperd dies since it is now a 3/3?


thanks guys
Posted 05 June 2010 at 02:14

Permalink

Alright we start off after the declare blockers step. In response to declaring blockers Player 1 casts naturalize on Snake Umbra which destroys it. Priority is then passed to Player 2 and he has the chance to counter the spell or cast an instant or activate an ability of his own.

Now the First Strike step happens and the Oracle (a 4/4 due to the umbra) takes 3 damage from the Shepherd which is now a 3/3 because its umbra was naturalized before this step occured. Following this the normal damage step happens and the Oracle deals a lethal 4 damage to the Shepherd.

Between the two damage steps there's also another chance for each player to cast instants or activate abilities, which is something to watch out for since a first striker can deal damage that can then be pushed over the lethal-limit by a quick Bolt.
0
Posted 05 June 2010 at 11:19

Permalink

thank you very much.
0
Posted 05 June 2010 at 13:38

Permalink

[QUOTE=Shadowex3]Between the two damage steps there's also another chance for each player to cast instants or activate abilities, which is something to watch out for since a first striker can deal damage that can then be pushed over the lethal-limit by a quick Bolt.[/QUOTE]

Really?!?! I didn't realise that there is a chance for instants to be cast between first strike damage dealing and the normal damage dealing steps.
0
Posted 07 June 2010 at 16:25

Permalink

Neither did I until I read the rules to doublecheck while answering this.
0
Posted 07 June 2010 at 17:02

Permalink

That's interesting and good to know. This knowledge could come in useful in the future.
0
Posted 08 June 2010 at 05:35

Permalink