Discussion Forum

EDH = vintage + short restriction list that is pretty easy to memorize. If you play the format you should know the banned cards.

Another issue is that Commander is a format where the restriction list is a guide more then a rule and a format where houseruling/banning is common. On top of that there are actually 2 types of Commander, your usual multiplayer Commander as it was intended when it was still called EDH and 1vs1 (duel) competitive EDH which follows the french banned cards list and can be found here http://duelcommander.com/banlist/

Since this posts only says Commander / EDH Legality i would suggest turning this post into a discussion on why and what cards would you like to be removed from EDH banlist.

i have been searching for a post of the sort in MTGVAULT but couldn't find one.

I could start what i want you to say is a thing of the sort,

: i Do not agree with worldfire ban i know it is a bit(lol) overwpowered in the format, i fell they did not gave time for it to be played enough...

...

Yea I agree, we should be able to do it easy enough, considering the ban list is pretty short.

Would be awesome to select the EDH/Commander format when building a new deck, and for the deck editor to cap out the number of cards at 100. Additional cards added would either be reddened text or automatically go into the sideboard.

Additionally, I'd like to be able to designate which card is my Commander/General and it would be listed in a separate category a la "Artifacts," "Creatures," etc., or featured in some other way.

Thanks!

There actually is a banned list for edh. you can find it at the following site
http://mtgcommander.net/rules.php
click on deck construction and it will show the banned list for cards in the deck as well as banned legends for the commander

Dear Seth,

The idea behind using the deck legality list is having a quick go-to reference for legality. I don't know the vintage legality list by heart, nor the small list of 30 cards that make up commander legality.

I am a relatively experienced player, but I could imagine quite a few new players would love the commander legality indicator.

Another small addition: it would be great if hovering over one of the legality indicators would highlight the illegal cards in your decklist!

Having Commander and French Commander Deck Legality would be a great feature to add and an easy enough one to implement too. This could be done in an hour and would add utility to the site.