Discussion Forum

oh hey look Extended is dropping out all the cards until timespiral... right after i quit(due to no one near me playing).

I do think it's a bit much of a drop, but that's only because they're dropping 3 blocks rather than a constantly rotating 1.

Of course, they don't want Mirrodin and Scars of Mirrodin in standard and extended simultaniously. Too many artifacts to drop out that are way too powerful.

I absolutely hate it but I understand it. I think they are trying to open up extended to more people. Instead of trying to get cards from 7 years of Magic, you only have to do 4. Much easier to do for people.

As much as I understand and agree with their reasons for doing this, it still makes me sad. Most of my collection is from the Kamigawa or Ravnica blocks.

horrible decision, throwing tons of cards into the "not competitive in the broken monstrosity that is vintage/legacy, the only format in which they are legal", including about 70% of my card collection.

guess i'll stick to no-format casual games from now on.

oh, and cancel my plans to start a Magic Online account

[QUOTE=Seras]oh, and cancel my plans to start a Magic Online account[/QUOTE]

that's actually a good thing, magic online sucks. I played for a while, I hated the mentality, I have 3000 cards just sitting there. You buy air. It's still better to spend a rediculous amount of money on paper cards then it is spending it on virtual cards.


And yes the new extended format sucks. Extended was fun.

The reality is that Magic The Gathering has change a lot through the years. 7 years of Magic The Gathering is too much and too powerfull. Extended will become a massive and nasty thing with Mirrodin Block and the latest editions of magic. Seeing things like Tooth and Nail + Eldrazi will be common things. How to change things like this. WoTC just took the step to stop this.

Many of us are not happy about it. Others maybe will be happier. Since they will not have to suffer from things as hateful as a 4th of 5th turn Tooth and Nail with 2 Legendary Eldrazi= game, Or Combo Decks with infinite removal, Direct Damage, discarding, mill. This things will be common. And the arsenal for the older gamers will be nasty. How to cover up the real situation. We just heard it.

At least this is my opinion.

Tooth and Nail, as well as all Mirrodin, was rotating out anyway, what they've done is also kick out kamigawa, ravnica and ice age, which have not been around for 7 years.