magiccontroller

Oh I understand why you listed them now then and my discard seems pretty solid I'm just having trouble with direct damage it hits and the damage sticks before I can knock out the last player.any thoughts for burn or is it just a bad marchioness thanks

I have a deck similair to it there is a druid elf card in it that allows you to steal your opponents lands maybe it could beef it up even more.

Lol on my phone I can't loon at it :(

How about a blackmail then u pick one of 3

Honestly none of those cards help my deck in Amy way ill explain top to bottom
1. Takes red mana I'm mono black a over that its 3 mana for one discard
2. You didn't read this card correctly it doesn't work during drawstep I can't use it in any way.
3. If you are pllayg discard and by turn 6 they still have cards in hand your doing it wrong
4 useless way better cards to take its place
5. I'm not creature based the rat is useless for my deck
6. By the second or third turn I'm out of cards I don't need it
7.good suggestion
8good suggestion
9dont have tine to look that one up
10 I don't need board wipe because they don't get anything on the board if my deck works right
11lililiana is useless for this deck same reason as caress and megrim r useles
I don't know what kind of metagame your up against but I play multiplayer versus very fast decks where everyone targets my deck and some of the cards you listed I can't even use

I'm still undecided whether this will make deck better so let me know if you like it or not. Replace distress with wrench mind.trade the sangromancers for vicious hunger. And trade the rack out for nyxathid. The vicious hunger I'm iffy about but the nighthawks should keep your life relatively safe your one enemy is going to be fast cheap costing burns

All in all it looks like a much more consistent deck I would consider possibly changing the sceptres for a blackmail just for some more speed against cheap casting aggro decks

Thanks very much for the feedback. The reason I run the rituals is imagine playing multiplayer with the same people playing the same deck, this deck is brutally mean so they go for me at the start turn 1 3 mana allows me to shoot a delerium skeins or ensnaring bridge from the start a turn 1 chain of smog takes 2 cards from an opponent then hit them with blackmail chances are I took out atleast one of their bombs

taking out 2 disruptives for 2 howling mines

thanks a lot for the suggestion and feedback btw that card is so sweet I will fit it in now lol and mana leak is nice I own a few but I just cant give up the love of counterspell thought of taking the counterspells out for ixidors will though what do you think

any suggestions to the deck would be great thanks in advance

take the 4 despise out add 4 blackmails and take the 4 mind rots out and put in 4 wrench minds if you want to know my other thoughts let me know and ill give them :P

at first glance the deck is good there are just better cards that fit in your current card spots like mind rot it cost 3 mana for a 2 card discard try wrench mind/chain of smog does same thing just 1 mana less, I would take the mental agonys out and add 2 more pox you already have enough damage also I would take out the 2 caress' and add 2 nyxathids bump out 2 of your lands and add 2 more dark rituals and maybe exchange the ravens crimes for blackmail because it allows a bigger chance for you to get rid of one of their bombs and forces the opponent to think a little more and leaves more room for mistakes let me know if you liked my suggestions and if not let me know why so I can try to see things with a different spin and make my own decks better possibly good luck to ya!

Imo you only really get good use of liliana vess in a deck that will refill an oponents hand because without any ramp the earliest you can play her is turn 5 which if your discard is working like it should they will have no cards to discard, for the same reason im not to fond of lilianas caress or megrim. the scepter is a nice card but you have to pay the mana for it to work every turn I would find a card without a constant mana cost to deal discard every turn something like bottomless pit but im sure there are better cards where you wouldn't have to lose one as well. also the painful quandary is a cool card I would add another one. The deck in all looks good but I think you have to many cards that will damage an opponent with discard but not enough discard to keep that damage constant every turn for example I ran a sample of your first 3 turns 20 times you got mana screwed a couple times but you averaged 1 card discarded by turn 3 a few times you had 2 or 3 with your hymn, you just need speed with your discard and more discard it really all depends on your metagame though and how fast they're decks are. but let me know if you like my feedback and if not let me know why so I can see things with a new spin maybe and make better decks myself also check my discard deck out if you have time good luck!

I suggest taking out the 4 caress the 4 augurs and the 4sign in bloods add 4 bottomless pits that way you don't have to worry about drawing more discard. Your deck has enough of a win condition with the nihil stone and nyxathid so put in 2 more duress and 2 more wrench mind in place of caress then add 4 distress also dark ritual could put a big boost in the speed of your discard that is all without following the assumption that you don't care to keep it modern. Let me know if you like my suggestions and if not ide like to know why so I can get a new spin on things and make better decks myself.

and I second the bottomless pit because your going to want some reoccurring discard so that myxathid stays as strong as possible

just something I was thinking was take out 1 lilianas vess and 1 animate dead add 2 raise deads , maybe take 2 of the afflictions and 2 of the caress' out and add 1 blackmail and 3 graverobbers in. the reason I say take the caress and afflictions down to 2 each is because nyxathid is your powerhouse its where the damage is really coming from the others are just icing on the cake picture 2 graverobbers in your graveyard and a nyxathid use raise dead on robber play robber to get another robber play that robber to get nyxathid. or in best case animate dead the robber so the robbers affect bring you the other robber its just something I was thinking of incase your nyxathids take a fall to a murder or something.

neat deck not sure if it would work or if you would be willing to try and fit this in with the kind of mana it costs it cost 2generic and 3 of either green or white mana but its called fracturing gust anyways it destroys all artifacts and enchantments and you gain 2 life for each permanent destroyed. good deck just needs some consistency the white version of propaganda maybe of you could make the mana work

Im trying to get feedback on my multiplayer discard deck "meanest discard" let me know what you think of it but suggestions off the top of my head drop the inqusitions and add horrifying revelations its a pretty sweet card

I have a mono blue mill deck I don't play much anymore no one will play it but you have plenty of mill I suggest taking the hedron crabs out and put fog banks in their place they work wonders