MDStrawHat

Haha one can see you have a very nasty mind building a deck like this. Great imagination.

How did this fare in that mock tournament you went to by the way?

Great Deck. It all really fits. Gaea's Cradle works, but if you want to own this deck then yeah maybe leave it out. Love how your mana producers are also defensive and how forgotten ancients comes in and bolsters them all. Great deck :)

Hey SpawnSighT, Good Idea. Couple of things though. Why wouldn't you play your Joraga first and then level him on the second turn, this way you can use him straight away(No summoning sickness)after levelling and you get 2 mana back.
Also, well there's clearly a discrepancy with your ideal play and how lightly you'll actually get those cards in reality. Just one e.g. with 20 lands you just won't be able to put 5 lands down for every turn up to turn 5. By turn 3 having 4 of your 12 one drop mana producers (arbor joraga llanowar) is also unlikely. Think about it to get a third of them you'd expect to be a third of the way through your deck but by turn 3 you'll have only drawn 9 cards(not even a sixth of the way through)

Like I said it's a good idea but I think you need to mess around a bit with the proportionality of your deck until you really can realistically expect to get the cards needed in order that you make your ideal play a typicality of your deck. Hope that hasn't blown you out, just saying what i actually think will improve it. I'm prepared to admit I'm wrong. No need to return a comment for my deck on this one :)

That's the sort of Elf deck I like to see:)

Don't worry haha :) I would have checked....(probably)

Thanks well I wouldn't have thought of it if it hadn't been for your post :)Yeah soz i spelled it wrong just corrected that :)

I actually have a deck along the same line as yours(oran bramblewood and oona):) Oona's blackguard is an underated card IMHO, Its one of those cards that will always get better as MTG make more cards involving +1/+1 counters(thinking of steel overseer from 2011). Nice one adding the two Garruk's:)

PS I do think aiming to make your deck a tad more creature heavy would benefit it.

Thought of heritage Druid? You'd have to have elves that numbered around 20 to get the best out of it and you have 20 already. I'd even urge you to have it over and above llanowar elves if it came to choosing. Suppose it's T2 though huh?

Temp note, berkner and SpawnSighT well done for using the convention:) @everyone else just reminding you that if you want comments you need to agree an exchange with someone. Coolio

Yeah man, well a lot thought went into it I knew it could own a lot of decks but it just went down the list with no one commenting:( Cool man You 9 years me 11. I need people like you who are on my level. Many thanks can't stress it enough:)

http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=73651 $ (note the dollar peeps see convention above)
By No means a pro but am experienced enough having been familiar with MTG for 11 years.
I welcome critical comments so long as it can be debated. (Something like this guys is ideal, gives abit of info)

High dude you commented on my ADVERTISE UR DECK ltd yes i think is the answer to ur question but i'm gonna delete your comment if thats ok because i want every comment to be a decklist post from someone who wants comments on their deck. Put sum of your decks in ;)

Hang on dude i'll be back later.

No Probs. I'll do that proper comment in a bit but yeah i'm kind of getting it its like stall deck. But just of the top of my head i think, and im not entirely sure, you should focus more on the scion and counterspelling to protect the scion. i know you have 4 already but more harbingers could help guarantee getting em early game(doesn't have to be them could be something less expensive cud be demonic tutor but thats expensive in terms of $$$) anyway say what think

Do you mind just replying to this comment and explaining to me what the strategy behind this deck is or like points you think make it strong? I'll give you a proper comment in a bit. I always think a draw mechanic is good and i see you have jace beleren in the sideboard and he is one of the best draw mechanics i can think of, of the top of my head for blue, apart from the other jace. But not saying you have to add him. Don't worry about returning a comment but here's my favourite deck if you want to take a look. http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=73651

Type Advertise ur deck ltd in decksearch;)

Anyway guys if you want me to give your deck a comment I definitely will. I've been playing 11 years although I've not entered a tournament. My favourite format is legacy. If in return you could comment on this deck http://www.mtgvault.com/ViewDeck.aspx?DeckID=73651 I would much appreciate that as well. It seems like quite an original deck as i haven't come across anyone that had the same idea.

dude get it down to 60. I'll give you another comment after that

I Agree. Two many times decent decks go down the list without even a single comment. I think I speak for 99% of people when I say that the whole reason for putting your deck up is because you want others to look at it and appreciate it. Why else would you use this site. (If that's not the reason Just use pen & paper to write your decklist)

In reality everyone wants their deck fairly ranked against every other deck. Does anyone ever wish you could challenge anyone's deck with any of your own so your deck could finally win that honour and prestige it truly deserves? There must be some way of doing it without WotC getting their knickers in a twist.

Perhaps if you own the deck on MTGO there could be a way that you could say that on your deck page( leaving people to write it isn't enough) and make a search were only decks that are on MTGO appear, inviting everyone else who has a deck on MTGO to challenge it.

But dreaming aside the most sensible straight-forward solution I can think of is a common place where people advertise that they want comments on a particular deck in exchange that they give a comment to someone else's deck. Some way to enforce that a fair exchange happens may also be prudent but probably not necessary.

PS I can perfectly understand why Zamfir posted it here and not on the forums it was clever and it gets more people to comment. I might do the same myself in future it obviously works.