Muktol

235 Decks, 1,770 Comments, 732 Reputation

[[Stonehorn Dignitary]] would be a classic card (at least in pauper) to bounce when using white.

0
Posted 18 September 2023 at 06:38 as a comment on BD: Recast & Rebound

Permalink

[[Champion's Helm]] and things that will provide you with indestructible could be worth a look to keep your commander around longer: [[Avacyn's Memorial]], [[Darksteel Plate]], [[Hammer of Nazahn]], [[Shadowspear]]

0
Posted 15 September 2023 at 06:20 as a comment on EDH: Wilson's Bear Hug

Permalink

You can discuss decks and cards, and earlier on there where some good and constructive ones. But the members who had the knowledge and will to write such things slowly left the site and the new players rarely give or make comments or even answer ones.
Also the forum is dead as a dodo, which I partly blame on not working notifications and party on lack of interest. And talk like spoiler discussions are mostly made in the forum. Another option could be that forums are generally outdated and people now get together on discord, Instagram, and other "New" and "cool" communication platforms.

0
Posted 15 September 2023 at 06:08 in reply to #650168 on U/R Pauper: Pirates

Permalink

Yes, it could be improved on, in some areas more easily than in others. But the only thing I got to read during the last years was "Short on time", "Problems with this", "Problems with that" or the classic "We will write it into our list for the next update/ change. We really want to get this right"... heard the last one way to many times to believe in it any more. I guess I will have to start looking for alternatives, because the site I'm using to keep track of my card collection isn't really well suited for deck-building.

0
Posted 15 September 2023 at 06:00 in reply to #650144 on U/R Pauper: Pirates

Permalink

This will probably be one of the last decks I'm releasing here for a very simple reason: MTGVault is dead as a dinosaur.
Don't get me wrong, I've been on this site for a long time and it was a good time. The number of active users has dropped but it would still be a good site to build decks (and hope for comments and support from other users).
What really makes me angry is the support from Gary and Ian, which is a catastrophe. If you browse through the forum's
"MTG Vault Bugs & Suggestions" section there are a lot of bug reports and even more suggestions on how to improve things. Bugs that where site-breaking are normally dealt with sooner or later, but other linger around for decades, like the one where you can give your own decks a like... or the one currently haunting the site with no prices of decks and cards displayed. The only thing done since June 2023 was "Wilds of Eldraine added to the database!" on 09-09-2023. The other 10 posts where someone reported a bug or a missing card where ignored.
I know how hard it is to call for help on a project that is you baby that is getting over your head, be it because of technical problems or simple things like a new job, house, child or whatever. But in the end one has to make a decision between getting help and get things right or letting them die slowly and as I mentioned in my first sentence: "MTGVault is dead as a dinosaur".

0
Posted 12 September 2023 at 07:13 as a comment on U/R Pauper: Pirates

Permalink

[[Spider Spawning]] could fit to the deck, tough it might be a little expensive to play with only 19 lands.
And yes, some people actually read those.

0
Posted 31 August 2023 at 07:00 as a comment on The Hunger Tide

Permalink

[[Impaler Shrike]] could be an option tough it only enables you to draw cards after it dealt combat damage and not when it dies, which makes it a little bit unreliable against removal.

0
Posted 17 August 2023 at 08:29 as a comment on BD: Vile Vivisectionist

Permalink

[[Order of the Stars]] is a defender often overlooked by players because of it's low toughness, but in my personal opinion protection from a colour levels this. Hard to remove, it can deal with any damage it receives (only trample is a problem) and able to bypass your opponents defence.

0
Posted 13 August 2023 at 13:48 as a comment on Defenders v.2

Permalink

[[Coral Colony]]/ [[Doorkeeper]] as alternative win-con?

1
Posted 12 August 2023 at 08:37 as a comment on Day of the Walls

Permalink

[[Monastery Swiftspear]] and / or [[Dwarven Forge-Chanter]] would fit here, both are more or less "standard" cards in pauper burn.
21 lands seems to be on the high side for a deck that uses so many cmc 1 and 2 spells, personally I would try to reduce them by 1-3. Playtesting should quickly show the right number. [[Evolving Wilds]] could be replaced with [[Maestros Theater]]. Advantage is that you get 1 life, drawback is that you cannot sacrifice any time you want to.
[[Behold the Multiverse]] could be used instead of [[Lórien Revealed]]. Foretell allows you to cast it in 2 parts, reducing the mana you need at 1 time. It also allows you to scry 2 before you draw, drawback is you only draw 2 cards.

0
Posted 03 August 2023 at 07:02 as a comment on UR Delver Pauper

Permalink

[[Pestilence]], [[Pyrohemia]], [[Court of Ambition]], [[Dogged Pursuit]], [[Palace Siege]]?

1
Posted 19 July 2023 at 06:27 as a comment on Strefan Curry

Permalink

[[Illusionist's Bracers]], [[Magewright's Stone]], [[Thousand-Year Elixir]], [[Instill Energy]]

0
Posted 18 July 2023 at 20:26 as a comment on Apple's Bane

Permalink

[[Mechanized Production]]?
A deck description would be a nice addition.

0
Posted 18 July 2023 at 16:56 as a comment on Clue tokens

Permalink

[[Cauldron of Souls]] could either further enhance the synergies or serve as additional part of the toolbox you can search for.

1
Posted 11 July 2023 at 06:12 as a comment on Toolbox's Terrors

Permalink

[[Cauldron of Souls]] (Probably out of budget range) or [[Resurrection Orb]]?

1
Posted 04 July 2023 at 15:28 as a comment on BEDH: Green Governing

Permalink

What about [[Familiar's Ruse]] or [[Moon-Circuit Hacker]]?

0
Posted 22 June 2023 at 21:07 as a comment on BD: Unsummoner's Ultimatum

Permalink

"... to reuse your mana..." is a way better description for this :)

Most of my suggestions are from the pauper format (commons only) but you can extend the search on your own.
Spells with flashback, like [[Artful Dodge]] or [[Defy Gravity]] could also be worth a look as it would allow you to re-cast them when you don`t have any cards left on your hand.

Some non-pauper suggestions: [[Guttersnipe]], [[Young Pyromancer]]

Last, as you will need a stable mana-base I would also add some dual-lands: [[Swiftwater Cliffs]], [[Wind-Scarred Crag]], [[Cascade Bluffs]], [[Izzet Boilerworks]]

1
Posted 20 June 2023 at 15:03 in reply to #649911 on Crackleblitz

Permalink

[[Martyr of Frost]] or [[Judge's Familiar]] instead of [[Spiketail Hatchling]]?

1
Posted 19 June 2023 at 07:56 as a comment on BD: Lorn Longing

Permalink

[[Decanter of Endless Water]] could be an idea, to be able to have more cards in your hand.
With all the draw and discard effects you could take a look at some madness spells: [[Obsessive Search]] or [[Just the Wind]].

0
Posted 19 June 2023 at 07:50 as a comment on BD: Orderly Onslaught

Permalink

How should [[Hidden Strings]] help you with casting spells multiple times? The only thing would be [[Gigadrowse]] and untaping some lands.

0
Posted 19 June 2023 at 07:42 as a comment on Crackleblitz

Permalink

21-40 of 1,766 items