slinky62

55 Decks, 30 Comments, 22 Reputation

Looking good!.. My only other preference would be to add some card draw. Opt doesn't count as card draw remember as it just replaces itself with another card and you don't increase the card count in your hand. I personally would...

-1 Spell Pierce (gets worse late game so more than one in hand is often not what you want)
-1 Nicol Bolas, Dragon God (hard to cast so it's likely a dead card early game especially in multiples)
-1 Scions (3 is a good number I feel and they can draw into the others)
-1 Blood Crypt +1 Watery Grave (You need Blue more than you need Red early game if you want to cast Narset on T3)
+3 Treasure Cruise (You are discarding a fair amount so may as well use that graveyard)

I know you are reducing your fun card counts but you are actually increasing your chance of drawing them by adding Treasure Cruise to dig deeper.

Like I said these are only my suggestions and what I'd do. It's up to you to play it and see how it performs and go from there.
Thanks for sharing and good luck. ;)

0
Posted 30 October 2019 at 20:30 in reply to #628281 on Grixis control, pioneer

Permalink

It think you're on to a good start here but Liquimetal Coating isn't legal in Pioneer unfortunately. To be honest, I don't see the benefit to Karn at all here. His +1 does nothing as we don't run mainboard artifacts and what he fetches without Coating is all a bit meh.

Fiery Temper with the discard package of The Royal Scions and JVP is quite good so I'd run Scions instead of Karn and consider Tempers.

Also, with Oko, T3feri, JVP, Saheeli, etc.. all being quite prevalent, Dreadbore seems to be a must somewhere in the 75.

Just my thoughts :)

0
Posted 30 October 2019 at 17:37 as a comment on Grixis control, pioneer

Permalink

Lol.. I've never forgotten about this Cruel Master of doom!

I did start with Stitcher but I found that I wanted more targets for Alesha that impacted the board rather than fueled the plan. It was great on turn 1 but terrible in later turns when I wanted to reanimate a threat. I can see adding two back in place of the Rat which just eats removal every time. Also doing this will also balance my Mill vs discard effects but just never a fan of adding only 2.

The burn match was not great hence the main Pulse but supplier might add some early blockers that fuel the plan as well, so I like that thinking actually. My last 3 burn matches I've won 2, lost one by boarding into slightly more removal but I am considering and extra Pulse in the board.

Thanks for your suggestions.

0
Posted 27 October 2019 at 12:24 in reply to #628144 on Pioneer Cruel Alesha Combo

Permalink

Thanks. It's the same list I ran in Modern just without fetches. Oh and my brewers brain has gone into overload with Pioneer! So excited!

0
Posted 23 October 2019 at 17:14 in reply to #627977 on Pioneer Soulflayer Surprise

Permalink

They are not legal (thank the lord).. best 1 cmc we have is Opt to my knowledge.

1
Posted 22 October 2019 at 19:18 in reply to #627960 on A new Frontier

Permalink

Great start here! If we are going 3 colours, I feel like we need Fabled Passage's though... Also I feel like Tireless tracker and maybe even Courser of Kruphix needs to be in this sort of deck but maybe not the Courser if you're focusing on counters.
Keep up the great brewing!

2
Posted 22 October 2019 at 19:12 as a comment on Siege Rhino Pioneer

Permalink

Nothing beats a bit of mono Red! Love the ideas.. My immediate thoughts are that Legion Loyalist, Runaway Steamkin seam to be great and lets not forget Reckless Bushwhacker. The downside with red is we lose the one mana burn spells that modern has to offer so we need to be more creature based. Steamkin seems great as its more mana to use to cast more creatures later on. The card I feel you've overlooked here which works well with many creatures... Stoke the Flames! If you want to add green don't forget Atarka's Command.

The alternate direction is to go Boros or even Jeskai for Boros Charm and Jeskai Charm and Mantis rider funs! OH lordy the ideas are making me tingle! (and my head hurt)

Either way I think we need to find out the game plan first... Do we want to be super aggressive and deal as much damage as possible as quick as possible? - Then I suggest mono red with small hastey creatures early game moving to a stoke the flames burn strategy late game. Adding another colour could slow this plan down but at the same time give you a better mid to late game. At the end of the day I suppose the meta (once established) will dictate which strategy is more viable.

Just my rambling thoughts so good luck with the build and I hope your head doesn't hurt as much as mine does. :)

1
Posted 22 October 2019 at 19:00 as a comment on Pioneer RedX Aggro

Permalink

Hahaha! Thanks! Exciting times for us brewers!

0
Posted 22 October 2019 at 17:46 in reply to #627939 on Pioneer Soulflayer Surprise

Permalink

Great idea! Only allow decks that have a description to be made public. If I can't be bothered to comment on my own deck, then I can't complain that others can't be bothered either!

3
Posted 22 October 2019 at 01:15 in reply to #626762 on Be More Supportive

Permalink

Hey Gary, long time no see since the Uni FNM days! I agree there needs to be more format separation on the site. I'm only interested in Modern (and now Pioneer which I'm looking forward to you adding btw! ;) ) so I feel my input and comments are more relevant to other modern decks. So I'm naturally going to look for decks of that format so it would be nice if this was made easier.

5
Posted 22 October 2019 at 01:13 in reply to #626831 on Be More Supportive

Permalink

No! I think this is a very valid observation! Seeing that my deck has 15+ views and no likes or comments adds to that feeling that no one really cares what you have said or even acknowledged the time and effort you've put into creating a deck WITH a description. Knowing that your own views are up-ticking the view count is very relevant in ones own perception of this community. I agree this needs fixing as not everyone is going to read this decks comments! TL;DR as I'm told on other sites!

7
Posted 22 October 2019 at 01:05 in reply to #627925 on Be More Supportive

Permalink

I agree with LordCinder here. With another 2 and the Leylines in the board it seems excessive to run two in the main as well! I'd rather play Desert Cerodon or even main the Fulminators in their place. I like the 6/4 body of a Cerodon personally.

0
Posted 28 August 2018 at 18:08 in reply to #617459 on Grixish Living End

Permalink

No problem ;-)
That looks pretty solid to me now.

I play Grixis Improvise and play against this deck a lot when my friend and I test and Vraska is a nightmare! So hard to get rid of because she can protect herself in two ways 1) creating a blocker 2) killing a threat!

He plays 2 Lifecrafter's Bestiary main and the 2 Journey's in the sideboard because people often side in more removal on game two so it's more relevant. Game one the card advantage of the Lifecrafter's Bestiary is usually more useful. This is just his choice and a little metagame dependant, but worth baring in mind.

Glad I could help and good luck in your games.

0
Posted 01 February 2018 at 23:39 in reply to #611230 on G/B Constrictor

Permalink

Nice deck and my friend plays this. I would personally add 4 Glint-Sleeve Siphoner for card draw, Aether Hub to help it, 1 Hashep Oasis for extra damage, and 2 Ifnir Deadlands for extra removal.

Not sure How Lilliana helps the deck so i would drop it and main the Vraska for game 1 artifact and enchantment removal. Also a 2/2 menace pirate is better than a 2/2 zombie that mills your very important cards!

I'd remove:
2 Overcome (too expensive for a sorcery and mana better spent expanding your board with creatures)
1 Journey to Eternity (2 main is fine in my opinion especially with the added card draw from Siphoner)
1 land (Deck runs well with 24 land)
This will make space for the 4 Glint-Sleeve Siphoner which will add card draw and another menacing threat.

Just my suggestions. :)

0
Posted 01 February 2018 at 20:09 as a comment on G/B Constrictor

Permalink

Thanks for the comment.. I've added it to the sideboard as an option to speed the deck up game 2. :)

0
Posted 03 July 2017 at 19:02 in reply to #602163 on Modern Mardu Vampires

Permalink

Hi, thanks. The deck has been doing really well and went 5-0 on my first FNM. I've made some minor tweeks to the deck. I did consider wrangle but being sorcery I would almost never get to use it. If they curve into the combo (turn 3 saheeli, turn 4 Guardian) they win. Having an instand speed way to interact with the combo is key especially on the draw. Additionally, with shock I have more option to develop my board on turn 3 by having access to play my 1 & 2 drops and still leave protection for their turn 4 combo. Even more, shock is better against aggro. Thanks for the suggestion though. :-)

0
Posted 07 February 2017 at 00:58 in reply to #594841 on 4c Saheeli Aetherworks

Permalink

Excellent choice, didn't think of that. That's an old favorite of mine when I played Rakdos Control in standard. Maybe a Rogue's Passage to help get the damage through?

0
Posted 04 October 2015 at 19:36 in reply to #563726 on Kaalia

Permalink

Nice deck. You have Angelic Arbiter twice though. Stormbreath Dragon or Restoration Angel maybe?

0
Posted 04 October 2015 at 12:57 as a comment on Kaalia

Permalink

LOL... That's excellent... There is a lot of Tron in my local meta and it's the way I deal with Wurmcoil. My mate swung with 2 wurmcoils all cocky thinking he'd stabilize and I Palmed both!

0
Posted 26 August 2015 at 22:14 in reply to #560182 on Modern Burn

Permalink

Thanks... It's served me well so far and I love the Palms in the SB.

0
Posted 26 August 2015 at 22:03 in reply to #560182 on Modern Burn

Permalink

1-20 of 25 items

1 2 Last