The Most Important Meal

Well I run silence against control and the deck is really consistent. Also I can combo off on turn 3 so taking some aggro damage is okay :)

"Can" combo off at turn 3. Have you run the stats on that working out? You say "the deck is really consistent," but the numbers don't agree with that.

Also x4 Silence doesn't stop a control deck.

I run 2x silence and with all the draw I get I easily stumble upon them. And do you know this deck won pro tour return to ravnica modern or no? Also I ment to say turn 2 lol

I don't undertand how your combo is complete on turn two, please explain.

Also, even with draw, just silence isn't enough vs a control deck... So you begin round two and on turn one, your opponent drops Pithing Needle (Pyrite Spellbomb) on turn one. It's a very common control card, after all.

This is a long established deck called Eggs. The algorithm for sample hands on this site is actually kinda bad (no offense vault, love your site), but the deck can, and does, win pretty consistently on turn 3. That's why a key card, second sunrise, is banned in modern.
Look up some old videos of this deck a few months ago spudshaver. There was a GP i believe where the finals was Eggs versus USA control, and the control deck played maybe 3 spells the entire match. Easy win for Eggs.

all you need is reshape to search for lotus bloom and you can start from there. Also that's why grapeshot is sideboarded, to help deal with pithing needle's and other assortments.

So this is another deck someone else created without credit given?

I want to understand the turn two win; this is how I see it (please correct me if I am wrong):

Turn 1) Land, (any Bauble) - I would say you'd drop Pyrite Spellbomb, but your plan can't be to expect it in your opening hand, right?
Turn 2) Land, Reshape (for lotus) - with three mana available and no more than five cards in hand, how are you getting the combo off?

You are not dumb; you are correct.

It's a bit old but here was my take on those old cantriping artifact cards. http://www.mtgvault.com/lobstermobster/decks/bubble-bauble/ I think that red would be a better focus of this deck for the direct burn. Though I am biased since that is essentially all I did with mine.

Thats how you win yes :) its really consistent at keeping draw power going and normally combos off around 3-5 turns

I will play test it some more. Trust me, I want this to be awesome. I love the low mana cost artifacts.

Okay and this deck is awesome. It won pro tour return to ravnica modern :)

Very nice. I actually finally get it by the way. The lotus bloom is what makes it all work, right? Though by my count the spellbomb can only do 18 damage with all the recursion. Does there need to be an extra one?

Actually not only that, the deck looks like it depends on getting all 8 of the recursion spells. Which is fine, do not get me wrong what with all the draw power, but that would certainly slow it down a little bit. At least by what I am seeing with play testing.

You can Conjurer's Bauble + Reshape

I understand that. It's easy enough to get out the spellbomb but it still has limited uses. The problem I see is getting all the recursion spells to use the spellbomb.

To me it goes like this:

Get spell bomb and lotus out some time turn two or turn 3 or so.
Have recursion spell in hand and sacrifice spellbomb and lotus to get mana floating and do 2 damage.
Use recursion spell in hand to bring both back to field.

This is all well and good but it slows down until you get the next recursion spell. Even with all the draw it still takes potentially a couple of turns to run into one of them again.

Even that is alright though, since that is what this deck does as its idea. It just seems to me like you can only sacrifice the spellbomb a limited number of times before you run out of the instants used to bring the spellbomb back. If each instant essentially means a single extra sacrifice of the spellbomb then the total is 8 times 2 plus the initial 2 which adds up to 18 and thus not being enough to kill anyone unless they were damaging themselves.

Am I wrong?

In theory, withevery card played ideally and smoothly, you can deal 26 points in total.
Initial use (2 damage)
Conjurer's Bauble + Reshape (8 damage)
Faith's Rewened (8 damage)
Second Sunrise (8 damage)

It is, as you said, rather slow for this style of deck. Even with draw, without mana boost, going through an entire deck takes time.

oh that's right, I completely forgot the bauble's use of putting back in a card from the graveyard. I did not take that into account. Alright then, it makes sense damage-wise. Thank you for clearing that up for me

No problem sir.

Doesnt it go like this:
-When there is no cards in your library, Pyrite Spellbomb goes of 4 times with help from Conjurers Bauble. (When there is no cards in your library, Conjures Bauble puts any card in your graveyard back in your hand).
-Then use the fourth Conjurers Bauble to get Second Sunrise.
-Play Second Sunrise to get Pyrite Spellbomb and 4 x Conjures Bauble back into the battlefield. (Infite damage).
Correct me if I am wrong, put isnt this the grand final?

I am sure that mana never will be a problem with Lotus Bloom coming into play repeatedly. Btw remember when you are getting near then bottom of the library, dont put any instant draw cards like Elsewhere Flask into the graveyard or you will mulligan yourself.

The plan is to rotate Pyrite Spellbomb an infinite number of time with Conjurers bauble and Second Sunrise.

I think Second Sunrise is one of the most strange infinite combos out there, but it is a bit too weak in legacy.

When you got the artifact on the battlefield, you can actually use the Bauble on Second Sunrise every time, wich will make all actions instant. Makes its hard to counter. :) Or am I wrong?

It's the Pyrite Spellbomb. It can be brought back enough to kill someone with all the recursion spells the deck has (the Faith's Reward, Second Sunrise, along with the bauble and reshape to bring it back)

hmmm, it makes sense conceptually, but does it play out that way? seriously you kinda need a bunch of second ssunrises/faiths rewards all at once.

That does seem to be the case. As seen in the comments above there has been a semi-lengthy discussion about the speed. Certainly an interesting concept though. The creator of it said that it won him/her a tournament though so there is that as well (I will assume male).

It used to be a fairly good Modern Deck, but it has not seen much serious play in legacy

Pyrite Spellbomb can win the game, but I prefer to utilize Cunnning Wish with Brainfreeze and Grapeshot in the sideboard to provide more options.

http://www.mtgvault.com/roar/decks/sunny-side-up/

I am male lol and I didn't win a pro tour with it but Stanislav Cifka did. He made the whole deck up and he got 1st place with an amazing ratio. :) You guys could always check out the deck play so you can see it's full potentional!

The same reason I wouldn't expect a seven year old Standard deck to consistently win against other Legacy/Vintage versions. It may have fit into Modern at the time, but that doesn't mean a deck should be considered perfect in a wider format. I think consistency is worth reviewing when a deck falls into Vintage/Legacy and costs $290, and is an important element of a deck.

Hold up, I'm not seeing why this isn't Modern Legal. Which card is wrong?

Oh, hold up, Second Sunrise is now banned. Looked it up; banned since April. Bummer.

Sunny Side decks were very strong in competitive Modern plays, but is unfortunately too weak in Legacy play.

Well since this is a combo deck that usually can go off around 2-5 turns silence is definitely a time walk in this deck. It stops the graveyard hate and you can just combo and win :)

spudshaver has deleted this comment.

I could definitely do that but I was mainly making this for fun because I still like the combo a lot :)

I agree it is a fun combo :)

Have you had any success with it in any metagame match-ups with other legacy decks? Personally I found legacy to be too tough for this deck, due to cards like Force of Will.

But if you simply want to play the deck for fun, I would rearrange the mana-setup. It is too expensive with fetch-lands and they don't add much tempo to the deck. Archaeological Dig will provide you with much the same benefit and only cost $2.