ControlGame

95 Decks, 158 Comments, 0 Reputation

Try and add some flexibility to ur deck (maybe some more creatures or add a color to give u more means of protection and different ways of winning the game); You may also want to consider Ravenous Rats, Hymn to Tourach, etc etc

I wouldn't only go for a discard theme, cause it's not easy to win with; also blue will simply counter everything

0
Posted 01 April 2010 at 09:09 as a comment on Discard

Permalink

I like ur deck; seems a bit on the slow side though; also I would replace Overgrowth with Wildgrowth and get rid of Harrow

Love the Elvish Piper in there

I like the Counterspells as they can protect u from early attackers and sorceries like Wrath of God; not much else to say; well done

0
Posted 01 April 2010 at 04:38 as a comment on Big Machine v2 (Please comment!!)

Permalink

No Felidar Sovereign??

You don't need Ranger of Eos, nor Sphinx of Jwar Isle and what's the purpose of Path to Exile and Mind Spring??? Try replacing these cards with cards that make more sense for your deck; also add some cheap defenders

0
Posted 01 April 2010 at 04:30 as a comment on W/U/g Control

Permalink

I like ur deck, seems like a fun deck to play and quite balanced. Only worry I'd have is the mana curve, since it's not the fastest deck; maybe also get rid of multiplayer cards like Syphon Soul (or add it to your sideboard instead)

0
Posted 01 April 2010 at 04:19 as a comment on Ultra Zombie Madness

Permalink

I like this deck!! and love the theme!! hehe Also like the balance in it; maybe lose Sorin Markov though as he's on the expensive side and replace Oracle of Nectars by Wellwisher (far more effective)

And no Rhys Vanquisher????

Also, maybe add some basic lands (forests and swamps); u don't want everything to come in play tapped (if u have a bad 'land-hand')

0
Posted 01 April 2010 at 04:13 as a comment on DarkElves

Permalink

like the deck, maybe a little slow, but a nice balance (different functionalities) in ur cards; did u test ur deck already??

0
Posted 31 March 2010 at 01:53 as a comment on B/R Type2 Aggro

Permalink

still seems a bit random; you're not gonna prevent an opponent from playing his cards with 8 color-changers in ur deck, not to mention all the non-land mana cards an opponent may have

0
Posted 31 March 2010 at 01:45 in reply to #59314 on UW Control COMMENT PLEASE

Permalink

turn 1 win... how does this work exactly, what is the combo here??

0
Posted 31 March 2010 at 01:30 as a comment on Millbond. (Very fast mill deck)

Permalink

seems like u have some catching up to do ;) hehehehe what I meant is that I'm not sold on the possibility of an effective (red) land destruction deck more in general (maybe if u add control)

either way, just have a look at the official site to see what's new, you can do pretty detailed searches for specific "abilities" (eg type 'destroy target land')

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 15:15 in reply to #59329 on Land Destruction is funny!

Permalink

don't really see how this would work; also counterspells are generally far better than bounce spells; your opponent just plays them again

um what were the victory conditions??? ;)

I like silence a lot, add some more white control spells; twincast is quite useless in most cases imo

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 15:07 as a comment on

Permalink

too many different cards of various and vastly different purposes; make clusters of cards (3-4) and get a theme for ur deck (how are you going to defeat your opponent??)

try not to add too many 4+ mana spells since you won't be able to stop a fast opponent if you do

hope this helps a little

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 15:02 as a comment on Green/White Deck Help

Permalink

try adding some non-creature spells for more versatility, would get rid off the 5 and 7+ mana spells

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 14:39 as a comment on Vampire

Permalink

clone is a bit expensive for what it is imo, so not sure I'd add it, maybe Rite of replication can be useful

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 13:41 in reply to #59328 on Ally Mill

Permalink

hey, I like the mana curve for ur deck, just not sure it's versatile enough; also it lacks mill power (it barely has any); also Allies are likely to get massacred by elf or vampire decks, cause imo they're just not that good (also against hard hitting damage decks (red)

Try adding some protection (it's a white deck after all) to be on the safe side and adding some blue mill cards if u want to stay with a mill theme

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 13:40 as a comment on Ally Mill

Permalink

fair enough, just saying u can build faster decks with cheap cards; or maybe trade with other players?????

Still not sold on red land destruction, however; hope ur having fun with it though

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 13:25 as a comment on Land Destruction is funny!

Permalink

No 1-2 mana spells; = gonna be hard to win any games; ur spells are too expensive; what's the purpose of Eron the Relentless in this deck??

Creature decks will probably swarm you

Control decks easily outmatch you; maybe add black for some cheaper land-destroyers and cheap creatures (vampires??); either way, I don't think it's easy to build a good land destruction deck; otherwise try White: Armageddon,..., Wash Out (blue) and build more of a proper control deck (add Wrath of God,... Winter Orb?) ;)

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 12:41 as a comment on Land Destruction is funny!

Permalink

I take it this deck is still in progress, since it doesn't have 60 cards... long story short, basilisks are too expensive making your deck way too vulnerable; maybe add some fast creatures to keep opponents busy for a couple of turns

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 12:33 as a comment on basilisk

Permalink

Too many land fetch cards (u got 22 forests, u only need a few of those, say a wild growth or 3 and a few lannowar elves maximum); most of the creatures are too expensive slowing ur deck down, fast decks are gonna hurt you

Don't like Master of the Wild Hunt; chances u get to play Howl of the Night Pact are slim (7 mana); not to mention all the milling Archive Trap could do against ur deck ;)

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 12:25 as a comment on Wolves, Wolves, Wolves (comments)

Permalink

I like the deck; agree with the other comments to just go with regular lands; would also drop Sanguine Bond (too expensive) for a lower mana cost spell (eg chainer's edict?)

I think this deck can be effective with the proper amount of creature killers against faster elf, sliver, token decks; Wonder how this deck would fare against red damage decks and blue/white/control decks full of counters, creature killers,...

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 12:18 as a comment on my vampire dream deck

Permalink

I don't like Jace Beleren, quite the useless planeswalker; Mind Sculptor is far better; too many enchantments, quick decks are gonna rip you apart
Sigil of the Empty Throne is also way too expensive

Maybe replace wall of denial by wall of tears, cheaper and more effective

Also, why are spreading seas and convincing mirage in the deck??????? How are you gonna beat ur opponent exactly, and add Day of Judgment to ur main deck

Add more control cards rather than situational enchantments

0
Posted 30 March 2010 at 10:59 as a comment on UW Control COMMENT PLEASE

Permalink

121-140 of 157 items

First 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Last