Muktol

235 Decks, 1,772 Comments, 721 Reputation

+1
Of you want to remove red as colour, you could use [[Syr Konrad, the Grim]]. Personally I'm no big fan of mixed strategy (mill/ burn), tough burn could be a backup-plan if someone uses cards like [[Emrakul, the Aeons Torn]]. [[Consuming Aberration]] would be an option, if you want to go for pure mill.

0
Posted 24 January 2022 at 14:15 as a comment on Heartless

Permalink

+1
[[Mage-Ring Bully]] could be replaced with [[Festival Crasher]].

0
Posted 17 January 2022 at 09:53 as a comment on Pauper Jeskai Prowess?

Permalink

+1
Some ideas, based on my own [[Riku of Two Reflections]] Deck:
[[Rite of Replication]], [[Prophetic Bolt]], [[Rapid Hybridization]]/ [[Pongify]].
Also the magecraft keyword from Strixhaven has some really interesting cards, that could synergise well:
[[Archmage Emeritus]], [[Deekah, Fractal Theorist]], [[Octavia, Living Thesis]], [[Veyran, Voice of Duality]]

1
Posted 09 January 2022 at 20:41 as a comment on BEDH: Copypasta-Conjuring

Permalink

There is also the issue that all of your non-basic lands are 4 times in the deck, where only one copy is allowed.

As for the colour identity: The color identity of a card is specified by all mana symbols that appear in its casting cost, colour indicator, AND rules text.
(https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Color_identity)

0
Posted 09 January 2022 at 20:31 in reply to #645651 on mardu aristocrats

Permalink

Sorry, I didn't see the "Arena" Tag.

0
Posted 30 December 2021 at 18:27 in reply to #645634 on Friday night brawl: Tinybones.

Permalink

+1
Some things that come to my mind when thinking of discard:
[[Waste Not]] is a controversial card when it comes to discard. I doesn't add anything to your discard-plan directly, but you gain a lot of card-quality or tokens to keep you safe. When using [[Ensnaring Bridge]] the draw can be a little bit counterproductive .
[[Scepter of Fugue]] is a simple but effective card that lets an opponent discard a card if you've run out of hand cards.
[[Megrim]]/ [[Liliana's Caress]] deal damage whenever someone discards a card, tough not much damage for commander probably.
[[Pox]]/ [[Smallpox]] deals with all resources playerds have: hand, lands, creatures and life. Only drawback is that you are also hit by this, but you can plan in advantage for this.
[[Nighthowler]] can convert your small [[Tinybones, Trinket Thief]] into a respectable commander that can easily kill an opponent, especially in multiplayer matches after a mass-removal hit the board.
[[Liliana of the Veil]] easily one of the best Planeswalkers there is... at least for non commander.

1
Posted 30 December 2021 at 09:19 as a comment on Friday night brawl: Tinybones.

Permalink

A short deck and how to play description would be a nice addition.
[[Preeminent Captain]] would let you play many of your Kithkin spells for free.

0
Posted 27 December 2021 at 10:11 as a comment on Kithkin

Permalink

Normally such questions would belong into the MTG Rulings & Questions Subforum, but as the notifications don't work for the forum, I will answer you here:
[[Kentaro, the Smiling Cat]] basically tuns the costs for samuri spells into mana of any colour. For example, you want to cast a [[Fumiko the Lowblood]], but don't have any red mana. With a [[Kentaro, the Smiling Cat]] on the battlefield, she just costs {4}.

MTG gatherer, the official database, is always a good tip for cards with rules you're not sure about. Under "Rulings" you will find any annotations written by the MTG team, to clarify the rules for this card. In the case of Kentaro:
https://gatherer.wizards.com/pages/card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=81968
"Kentaro doesn’t change when you can cast Samurai. It just makes Samurai castable for generic mana."
Generic mana meaning mana that can be paid with mana of any color, as well as colorless mana.

0
Posted 18 December 2021 at 22:00 in reply to #645557 on Samurai

Permalink

I noticed the difference, but with [[Animate Dead]] inly it doesn't make any difference. If you would want to cheat out e.g. [[Emrakul, the Aeons Torn]] you would need somthing like [[Goryo's Vengeance]]/ [[Miraculous Recovery]] or similar, because [[Unearth]] is simply to slow (Sorcery vs instant)

0
Posted 17 December 2021 at 16:02 in reply to #645496 on The "Screw You" Deck

Permalink

I'm not really convinced on [[Glacial Grasp]]. Stopping a single creature for 2 turns sound OK, but what do you do about the other creatures? I would rather use some additional removal instead because why stop it temporally when you can kill it permanently?

The main problem I'm having with this deck are attacks or damage that can bypass my defence, this can happen in some ways: Direct damage, removal, evasion, swarm or overpower. Or attacks I'm to slow to build up some defence against.
Swarm is the least problem, because sooner or later [[Pestilence]] will deal with swarms and the blockers can still hold of some damage. The problem with evasive creatures usually also can be solved by [[Pestilence]], because they are normally rather weak. Which lefts us with removal, overpower and direct damage. Direct damage obviously is a very large problem, because before using the sideboard I can't do anything against these decks. Removal and overpower deal permanently with my defence, and the itself deck has too little removal to deal with all the threats a deck specialised in larger creatures can put in the field.

When playing I found [[Koma's Faithful]] a useful creature, the mill is rather irrelevant, but the life gain proofed to be useful. Its able to deal with medium creatures and gain some life, at the costs of it's own life. I would rather be looking for something without mill, but low power/ high toughness and lifelink and/ or deathtouch... dream would be a 1/4+ with lifelink (and flying, one still can dream of).

I was also toying around with the idea of using [[Pristine Talisman]] to gain some life, but I don't have anything I can sink a lot of colourless mana into, and the lifegain is too weak. [[Kraken's Eye]] (Not pauper legal, so no option for this deck) would also be ineffective, because getting 1-2 life per turn (More if you're playing against a blue deck) will normally not be enough to balance the damage dealt by your opponents creatures.

0
Posted 17 December 2021 at 12:27 in reply to #642912 on U/B Pauper: Defensive mill

Permalink

"Battlefield", if I would have to guess.

A deck can contain a maximum of 4 cards with the same name. The only exceptions of this rule are the basic lands or if a card's text contradicts this rule. When 2 cards with the same name and supertype "legendary" are on the battlefield the "legend" rule applies:
205.4d Any permanent with the supertype “legendary” is subject to the state-based action for legendary permanents, also called the “legend rule” (see rule 704.5j).
704.5j If a player controls two or more legendary permanents with the same name, that player chooses one of them, and the rest are put into their owners’ graveyards. This is called the “legend rule.”

0
Posted 17 December 2021 at 07:21 in reply to #645494 on The "Screw You" Deck

Permalink

The latest addition to the deck where 3 [[Pestilence]], 4 [[Curse of the Bloody Tome]] and 4 [[Evolving Wilds]] to help activate the Crab. This helps to keep many but the most aggressive decks at bay, and really increases chances. Yes, the mill is slow, but nevertheless, it's able to do it's work more often now.

0
Posted 16 December 2021 at 10:26 in reply to #642912 on U/B Pauper: Defensive mill

Permalink

[[Deathknell Berserker]] doesn't make any sense, as your only way to increase it's power ([[Unlikely Aid]]) prevents it from dying, and thus gaining the token.
How do you plan to deal with more aggressive decks, or control?

0
Posted 14 December 2021 at 08:03 as a comment on Pauper

Permalink

As far as I understand the rules [[Entomb]]ing your creatures won't help you, as all of them have a replacement effect or triggered ability that force you to shuffle it back into your library. This is no "may shuffle them into your library" but you'll have to do so.

0
Posted 14 December 2021 at 07:54 as a comment on The "Screw You" Deck

Permalink

+1
Personally I would remove the 2 [[Griffin Sentinel]] and add 2 additional [[Aerial Responder]]. To make sure you have the right mana you could add some dual- or search lands: [[Evolving Wilds]], [[Scoured Barrens]].
[[Aerial Responder]] was reprinted in the GameNight expansion, where the abilitys are explained with a text.

1
Posted 13 December 2021 at 07:39 as a comment on training deck

Permalink

[[Thornbite Staff]], [[Thousand-Year Elixir]], [[Magewright's Stone]] or [[Illusionist's Bracers]] can be used to double the number of creatures you get from Krenko. [[Thornbite Staff]] also works very well with [[Goblin Sharpshooter]]

0
Posted 03 December 2021 at 07:34 as a comment on Krenko's Krankout

Permalink

I was thinking of making extra paper cards to represent such stack effects. It's much easier to grasp what is going on when you can physically put a card with "Create a Token" or "All creatures get -1/-1" on the stack.

2
Posted 03 December 2021 at 07:27 in reply to #635707 on W/B Beginner: Aristocrats

Permalink

I have added a description on how [[Massacre Girl]] works, because I got the feeling that this card might be complicated to understand. Could you guys read through my "How [[Massacre Girl]] works" description and give me some feedback, if this is understandable? Or how you would describe the function of this card.

2
Posted 02 December 2021 at 09:23 in reply to #635707 on W/B Beginner: Aristocrats

Permalink

Just don't forget that you will have an opponent on the other side of the table too, which might have something against this plan. When I sees that my opponent has to/ wants to sacrifice something each turn, I start removing the sources of his sacrifice creatures. [[Fists of Ironwood]] is the only "cheap" card you have, the other 3 options you mentioned need 4-6 mana, and a lot can happen until you get to that many lands.
Personally I would probably remove 2[[Renowned Weaver]] and 2-3 [[Flesh Carver]] to add 4 [[Nether Traitor]] or [[Reassembling Skeleton]].
[[Tragic Slip]] could be used to replace [[Bone Shards]] (tough you cannot remove planeswalkers any more, depends on your local meta), without any large loss of power.

1
Posted 29 November 2021 at 10:43 in reply to #645355 on Sacrifising creatures

Permalink

I don't want to offend you with this question: Do you know the rules for general deckbuilding, and commander in special?

2
Posted 29 November 2021 at 08:16 as a comment on green gorila

Permalink

241-260 of 1,769 items