richter1

I just realized that I am indeed a rookie, so spellbook might not be a great option due to the fact that you will prolly just go for the win after adding all the lands to your hand.

Check it out I have posted a new deck. I will try to get a comment about this deck up later.

also if you are planning to return all lands to your hand that were in your grave, I would say that something like spellbook would be a good option.

momentous fall is a temporary greater good. yeah I have come to dislike infinite combo decks, it seems like every game someone in my playgroup has a deck with one built into it but I have become used to it.

Well I don't have it together anymore but when I did it was a joy to play with and yes it did go off in more than one game. I had a crazy turn with this deck it involved near infinite mana with palinchron and deadeye navigator with a mystic speculation in hand. I could have set my entire deck up ftw but decided not to be that guy and passed turn. I like your idea about adding pro mimic, when I built the deck that card was not one I could choose because that set was not released at the time. Damia looks like a fun general and she would prolly work well with biovisionary. I am at the computer at my local library today, my internet is having issues so this is all you are going to get out of me today. These computers are kinda gank so when my internet decides to play nice I will possibly add more to this discussion.

Please check out decks by Jestersmind and leave a comment while you are there.

I have used shifting sky + wash out before, I know that doesn't help very much. There is Trait doctoring but since you are not using non instants then than might not work. My expertise with color changing is rather limited so I feel the need to apologize that I am rather useless when it comes to commenting on this deck.

Yeah after thinking about both of the cards you listed above (about 30 minutes time) I realized that both cards are for the most part one shots. I keep forgetting about what this deck is supposed to do, I need to start reading old comments before leaving new ones.

I am in the beginning stages of looking at cards that could go in a deck similar to this and I have run across one that I am not sure about. The one I might add is Darksteel colossus but I am wondering why you are not using it. Does it's when hits grave effect not work with volrath? Or is there another reason you decided not to run it, you might have found some thing better to fill the slot. Either way let me know what you were thinking.

Woooooottttt, I just got a copy of volrath. Now I owe my friend because he gave it to me before he went out of town and said we can settle up when he gets back. Now my playgroup and you will be looking for a deck with volrath as the general and I will have it built very soon.

There isn't much to work with for the werewolf theme, I understand why you might have been having trouble heck I built the deck and I was a little frustrated. As always I look forward to your potential troll tribal fight club deck, I have a feeling it will be better than this one just because you will have more options.

7 lands is not enough to kill a player, that damage is not considered commander damage. Commander damage is only though attacks. I have been told that my comments are not helpful enough, I hope the way I worded this comment that it is helpful. I am not being rude or an ass just stating facts.

I like contested cliffs but I do not have it in my collection so I will have to work on trading for it. Predator Ooze is another card that would work great in the deck, it would be good to give it deathtouch as well. The Myojins and That which was taken are costly as far as mana cost goes and the artifact that was mentioned costs to activate. Before now I had never seen the Captive flame, it's just as good as the war cry. I think Homura Human Ascendant is better than the stone spirit but they are similar.

I wish I had something other than what I call a "brick phone" but it's all I can afford right now.

THANK YOU JESTER FOR ALL OF THE GOOD ADVISE ! I AM GLAD YOU THINK HIGHLY OF THE THINGS I HAVE TO SAY ABOUT YOUR DECKS ! I WILL TRY TO GROW A THICKER SKIN AND NOT LET OTHER PEOPLE'S COMMENTS GET TO ME. HOPEFULLY WE WILL BE ABLE TO CONTINUE TO WORK TOGETHER TO MAKE OUR DECKS STRONGER FOR AS LONG AS WE CAN.

Jester, I am seriously considering never commenting on a deck again, except if it is in response to someone leaving a comment on one of my decks or if I am asked to leave a comment on a deck. Because some people don't think I leave helpful comments, I think if someone posts a deck on a public forum then they are asking for whatever comment I decide to leave. I understand that the only reason some people post on a place like vault is to get help but some people want to post just to show off what they have come up with. I am not trying to be unhelpful or an ass or just plain rude or any other word people can come up with to describe my comments, but I do have an opinion and sometimes I want to share what's on my mind.

Okay surewhynot what do I have to do now to redeem myself and get rid of the minus one on my comment. I can only assume you were the one to give my comment the thumbs down. If I it will help I will list lots of cards that would help the deck win. I don't understand why my comment displeases you, if is it only because it is not helpful enough I can fix it.

also crucible of worlds

Detention sphere, Meddling mage, Cranial Extraction, Memoricide, Nevermore, Phyrexian Revoker, Voidstone Gargoyle, Slaughter Games, Haunting echoes and Shimian Specter could all cause problems for this deck.

I am only guessing you were looking for Thrun and Troll ascetic but there are prolly others. I don't know of a lot of arty creatures that are indestructible but I do know Darksteel brute, manor gargoyle, the colossus brothers, senior stuffy and of those that are listed I am not sure if I want any of them in this deck. Don't get me wrong indestructible creatures would be good additions to the deck and that was something that once again I did not think about.