surewhynot

Necropotence. I'm honestly surprised it hasn't been banned yet, it's that good...and it's a large reason why I love black (mono or otherwise) EDH.

Thanks! I'm a big fan of mono-black EDH decks, working on another now actually, so I'd be glad to help =]

Nice, looks good. Lemme know how it plays =]

Only thing left to do now for you is to find this baby a good name =P

Am I the only one who remembers the Seismic Swan deck? That thing was hilarious...

I'd say at least one Hymn.

Haha thanks =]

The Spitfire is just dirty dude...I like it =P

Hrm, I suppose you have a point there. As for the Quest...I might lose at most 2 Goyfs for it. You could also go with some of those horrors like Nyxathid, or better yet, Nihilith, a classic Pox Filth beatstick. I think those would be more consistent than the Quest to be honest.

The term you're looking for is Pox Filth. As in, a Filth deck (not referring to the card) that is powered by Pox, among other things. I like the look of this, but my one major concern is that you don't have enough zombies for Crawler to be as effective as it can be =/

I think the biggest issue with the deck right now is that you have it set up more like a mill deck that has some nifty tricks than a true Extraction. I would try to venture away from that path and instead focus more on disruption, lockout/lockdown, and and sort of controlling "wall" that allows you to, as my buddy WnB put it, "sit on a throne".

One thing I want to point out to you though, since I noticed it in your deck description, is that Extraction is not a cheap deck type. More often than not, these things burn a substantial hole in your wallet =/ If you're already having a hard time with the huge cost of this thing, I honestly would suggest you turn to having this in a proxy form until you are positive you want to and can afford to shell out the money.

Another thing I want to mention, though you've already probably figured this out, is that Extraction has one hell of a learning curve. I think a large part of my skill with it comes from the fact that I've been playing for a very, very long time. I'm always thrilled to see someone giving it a try though, so I'll be sure to help out where ever I can =]

Everyone calm down. Although there has been a recent surge of boosters and trolls, this latest group of top decks seems to be a result of an internal site bug...most likely created accidentally from the admins going into the system and manually removing decks off the main page (the ones that WERE from boosters/trolls).

If you look, a ton of decks have suddenly hit the top with little to no comments and a crapload of likes. If that's not convincing enough evidence towards an internal gremlin, then also notice one of the decks has -1 comments!

I got a lot of work to do at the moment dude, but please, bug me and then continue to bug me to check this thing =]

Yeah, it actually has "Negative one" comments...So something goofy is happening for sure. I'm gonna let the admins know...Looks to me like a gremlin =]

0 comments, 53 likes.

I may run a 2/2 split after some testing, but I don't think I'll switch the 3/1 to favor Extirpate honestly.

I'm not actually accusing you of anything, I was just saying 3 comments and 60 likes isn't so much even suspicious...it's just weird. I don't think the most dedicated booster/troll/whatever would go through the trouble to give a deck so many likes without comments...So more than anything, it's just bizarre =/

Raven's Crime for sure man. You can do so dirty things with that card to be honest, especially with the land base you have and Crucible. Besides, you get life from Seek =]

3 comments, 60 likes.

Right.

Yeah actually it looks very good now. The Stalker works nicely for it too, contrary to what I said before. Overall, well done =]

Yeah losing Bushwacker and Guide...on top of Timely Reinforcements coming out...Current RDW designs have practically no Damage Threshold to speak of =/