Shinza

100 Decks, 264 Comments, 61 Reputation

Well, the first thing I noticed was that there are seriously powerful creatures in there.
The problem is expense. All very mana expensive.
Maybe some focus on a particular idea and then choosing the best of those heavies to go with and then support from little cheap guys.

0
Posted 16 September 2014 at 02:14 as a comment on Legends Deck

Permalink

So you can get infinite tokens! Impressive!
Looks like once intruder alarm is out opponent is just about done!
Conceptually interesting!
I like it! Though for casual, it might be less than a fun game.
Like +1

0
Posted 16 September 2014 at 01:34 as a comment on Elves of Plenty !

Permalink

I especially like that the casting cost of the permanents really jacks the devotion up for the merchant!
Its a good deck, Northy!
Like+1

Would Sangromancer fit?
To benefit from Hippy discard

0
Posted 16 September 2014 at 01:15 as a comment on Friday Budget: Black Beater

Permalink

No worries!

You asked for me to take a look,
and take a look I did :)
Hope it helps.

Good deck tho.

0
Posted 12 September 2014 at 16:30 in reply to #502424 on Path to Revelation

Permalink

I agree with Z. Runechanter's first strike won't do much if he's unblockable. Also snapcaster will be plucking fuel for the runecaster away. Of the two swords, I would pick Fire and Ice. The card draw might serve better than the creature return, unless you draw into a terminus. Its a risk I would take.

Or you could go a different way and put a Loxodon Warhammer in to increase the beats and gain life. Trample wouldn't do much, but who cares. Your aetherling could pound for 11 and it would be a 22 point swing with your life gain.

Or you could go with Moonsilver Spear after a board wipe and start manufacturing some angry angels.

Ha! Ok. So Fire and Ice it is?

Actually, I would vote for Umezawa's Jitte. The protections of the swords aren't as necessary as long as you can exile your guy at will. The charges on the Jitte remain, so when he gets back he can use them. Some pretty good options there too.

On a side note... have you considered Hindering Light instead of Remand? It also lets you draw a card, but doesn't put the card back into the opponent's hand. Other than tempo, I don't really see the advantage of handing the spell back to the evil bad guy.

Anyway, its a hugely powered deck! More brooms than the witches' warehouse!

As a side note... I'm impressed by Sphinxes Revelation, but I wonder if it will work in play. 3 to get it started and then whatever you pump in for X, it might net less than ideal benefit. Maybe if there was a storage land?

2
Posted 12 September 2014 at 08:31 in reply to #502424 on Path to Revelation

Permalink

sure! I see a bunch of usa control popping up. Thought I might try for burn. Though the card cost is ridiculous to actually put together.

Control would be more natural since blue and white roll that way.

The damage output of electrolyze kind of stinks. need the card draw though

1
Posted 12 September 2014 at 07:43 in reply to #502441 on American Fireworks

Permalink

Please comment if you get the chance!
American burn...is it feasible?

0
Posted 11 September 2014 at 21:21 as a comment on American Fireworks

Permalink

Thanks for the comment!
I had not seen a deck like this before either.
I thought it might be good.
I am glad you like it.
I clicked the up arrow on the right to increase your reputation.

1
Posted 09 September 2014 at 02:56 in reply to #501620 on Hybrevotion Thievery

Permalink

Exactly that. I considered Oona, but there are 3 colorless mana in her cost and her token creation is awesome, but somewhat covered with Master of Waves.

You think I should sideboard Vanishment?
I have it in there to combo with Nightveil Spectre (put the card on top of library so Nightveil Spectre can pluck it off.)
I am considering Hinder for the same reason.


Thanks for the feedback. Bumped Rep +1

0
Posted 09 September 2014 at 00:06 in reply to #501584 on Hybrevotion Thievery

Permalink

oops and a black one

0
Posted 07 September 2014 at 05:33 in reply to #500020 on Budget $6: Blue Tide

Permalink

Great Deck! For standard I like it just the way it is. I do echo the idea of sideboarding a couple absurdly big spells in for games 2 and 3.
Like +1

0
Posted 06 September 2014 at 20:01 as a comment on Izzet Four or Greater? Nope

Permalink

Cool! How about Gelectrode? It would seem to fit with your theme.
Other possible options to consider:
Distortion Strike for its rebound effect
Forked Bolt for damage as you want it
Pyromancer Ascension for more power
Kiln Fiend for cheap beater
Charmbreaker Devils for expensive beater who gives instants/sorceries back

Good deck! Like +1

0
Posted 06 September 2014 at 19:20 as a comment on Counterburn full

Permalink

I like it! Like +1
These duels are fun! The motivation stories are cool too.

Btw, I finished a Budget $6 red deck.
http://www.mtgvault.com/shinza/decks/budget-6-red-punctures/
Enjoy!

0
Posted 05 September 2014 at 19:30 as a comment on Budget Duel: Naya - Esper

Permalink

Wow! Good work!
I like the variety! And LegendaryHero7 is right. This has the feel of a wizard duel!
Like +1 on both

0
Posted 05 September 2014 at 19:26 as a comment on Budget Duel: Naya - Esper

Permalink

Cool deck! The humans have a tough night ahead. The synergy of Slivers is unmatched!
I think the power levels are relatively equal though.
I wonder how the balance of power would shift if Sliver Queen and Odric, Master Tactician were included.

Great job, Northy!

Like +1

0
Posted 04 September 2014 at 05:59 as a comment on Budget Duel: Slivers - Humans

Permalink

By the way, I finished my budget $6 green deck.
If you feel so inclined, tell me what you think
http://www.mtgvault.com/shinza/decks/budget-6-savage-magic/
Enjoy!

0
Posted 04 September 2014 at 05:48 as a comment on Budget Duel: Slivers - Humans

Permalink

I especially like the storyline! I tried the link for the other to no avail.
Just when I thought it was safe, the Slivers are Back! Its great! I like the synergy of the slivers! You did a good job!

In terms of managing 4 colors, I noticed that green seem to be the baseline color (more forests, manaweft slivers, etc), but the only 1 drop is red and is Striking Sliver. Is it worth it to have 4 Striking Slivers with redundant ability. Maybe drop it to 2 Striking Slivers and increase Manaweft Slivers to 4? For better mana fixing.

At any rate, it looks menacing! The humans better bring it! For some reason Slivers always remind me of Pitch Black (movie with Vin Diesel). Hope the humans fare better here.

Like +1

0
Posted 04 September 2014 at 05:44 as a comment on Budget Duel: Slivers - Humans

Permalink

Ha! cool. Thanks for giving it a look. I hadn't seen too many Blue budget $6 floating around. Gonna make a green deck and a red one also to round out the challenge.

0
Posted 03 September 2014 at 06:09 in reply to #500020 on Budget $6: Blue Tide

Permalink

True that. This $6 budget idea is intriguing. Very restrictive, but rewarding. Its like the MTG equivalent of "small ball" in baseball. No home runs. Just basics.
With the volume of cards and the power creep, this brings it back to what the commons can do. Reminds me of when I opened my first pack back in the Revised days and marvelled at the Prodigal Sorcerer and the Craw Wurm

0
Posted 03 September 2014 at 06:05 in reply to #499632 on Budget $6: Mach White

Permalink

Hahahaha! True! I can just imagine the resulting forehead slap of dismay. I still think your black deck wins, though it may come down to whether my spectral riders can get Holy Mantled up and drop some Blessing before the Black Knights work me over.

0
Posted 03 September 2014 at 05:57 in reply to #499848 on Budget $6: Lilly White

Permalink

221-240 of 260 items