Chewrida

i agree with Kazzong with adding isochron scepter

haha add leveler, a 10/10 for 5 and torpor orb saves ya from it's nasty coming into play effect

well anyhow nice, I really like Primal Surge, nice instant win combo with it, maybe try adding avacyn, make everything indestructible and ensure Labratory maniac survives, and your other creatures become even better.

haha if you could somehow add vampire hexmage in here you could win really quickly, but youd have to be able to play black spells =p

I would drop 4 bump in the night

Like the deck, looks like a fun set up to play, nice with the mana curve of 12/ 4/ 12. Nothing better than being able to play something every turn =p

You think adding more ruinscar demons in here would help? I think with quicksilver amulet and the pretty good mana ramp in here having 3 or 4 ruinscars would benefit it to pull a primal surge quicker, cause all you need to draw is a ruinscarred and you pretty much have your primal combo then

I would take out all 4 of your geosurge and add in lightning bolt, you have plenty of mana spells already and thats the only one that has a condition so you cant even use it to play more mana spells, besides you may end up drawing mana spells too much when other cards are needed. Lightning bolt is a creature control for you to keep the opponent at bay and just a great life drainer. especially for so cheap, its a first turn creature killer and a late game creature killer. Just my opinion =p

I really really like this deck, i would say tho to drop a survival cache and add a 4th chalice of life, that card just goes too well with your deck to only have 3 in it. maybe sideboard or figure out how to add some path to exile or swords to plowshares =p which ever one you like better i guess if you were gonna add them. But nice life-gain deck for sure

You should add edge walker

Hey surewhynot, i gotta say i really like the surgical extraction wither deck you made, thats a really cool twist you made to it

hmmm, maybe ill drop a fling and add another land, i do wanna make sure i can get 3 swamps or geralfs messenger is useless

Thanks man

sure i'd like that man, cause i don't know what i'd wanna do with mine yet, i could use some ideas

counterspells are too fun =] wish i owned the greatest one of them all, force of will!

though i have a deck that its basis is genesis wave, and i actually win pretty consistantly with it too, i generally get it most games (though that deck is equipped with many ways to win without it as well). It's an angel/elf deck =p The mana production in that deck is amazing, my average genesis wave is for anywhere from 9 to 12, tho i've done it for well over 20 before many times. once i genesis wave in that deck even emrakul doesnt have shit on me haha

haha i really really wish i owned one, i'd be stuck on using diabolic tutor,other than that maybe draw cards? or splash in blue for the ponders and long term plans, which combo very well together

you should let me know hows it plays out, ive always wanted to build a wither deck, and this one looks pretty fun

Yea i thought about adding blue, but i feel it slows this deck down too much to worry about 2 different colors of mana, depending on the deck im facing my burns should make quick work of any first few turn creatures, if i cant destroy them i have the flying and trample of other cards to fall back on. not to mention grapeshot really superpowers this deck along with past in flames this deck normally overwhelms the opponent very quickly with only like 1 or 2 creatures out haha

i'd just have to figure out how to supercharge my mana ramp, like mana reflection mixed with viridian joiner and some quick buffs, it's be titanic growth, giant growth, tap viridian joiner and bam 16 mana to through down for it just from the viridian, let alone anything else i have. Just thoughts tho, i'd have to think on what to do with the deck

Neat idea, I've always wanted to create a mana ramp curse deck thats based on genesis wave to just blast every curse out at once