dknight27

1,840 Decks, 2,576 Comments, 300 Reputation

On an unrelated note, I love kessig prowler in general. It does pretty much exactly what agro decks want. Turn 1 threat that starts the clock, but isn't a dead topdeck

0
Posted 05 October 2018 at 21:24 in reply to #618388 on Howling at the Moon

Permalink

Maybe some of the 1-drop greed tactics cards? Commune with nature or adventurous impulse?

0
Posted 05 October 2018 at 21:21 in reply to #618388 on Howling at the Moon

Permalink

Even with 23 lands, this deck looks pretty 3-drop heavy. You're going to see a lot of games where you get choked in the opening and don't develop a boardstate quickly enough to get the job done, at least from my point of view

0
Posted 05 October 2018 at 21:03 as a comment on Howling at the Moon

Permalink

The complete lack of 1-drops seems like it will be a problem in here, as you will get many hands that are 2-drop and 3-drop choked where you get behind and can't respond fast enough

0
Posted 05 October 2018 at 20:50 as a comment on Sultai Control

Permalink

woodland cemetery is coming in a little strong,

0
Posted 04 October 2018 at 16:16 as a comment on Elvish Torment

Permalink

Right now electromancer isn't really helping you that much. He lowers 3 ionizes, 4 risk factors, and 2 unexplained disappearances (the other ones are either already reduced or are color specific), so he only helps with 9/60 cards, and really doesn't do anything else but be a wizard. I would definitely consider the stormtamer over him for a fast wizard with utility. I would also drop 1 niv-mizzet for an opt, as you DEFINATELY don't want niv in the opening hand, and you ideally want to drop an opt turn 1 if possible.

1
Posted 04 October 2018 at 02:51 in reply to #618316 on Wizard Counter Burn (Standard)

Permalink

Right now this deck is a little 3-drop heavy. Control decks like this need a good saturation of 1 and 2-drops so that you can basically always respond to whatever opponent is doing. Even with 23 lands, you are going to have a lot of games where opponent fields something before you can deal with it and smacks you to death.

Evolving wilds, abrade, blink of an eye, censor, chandra's pyrohelix, lightning strike, negate are all cards to look at.

But, fair warning, standard is about to be in a new rotation

0
Posted 03 October 2018 at 16:05 as a comment on Wizard Counter Burn (Standard)

Permalink

This build is a little 3-drop heavy. Even with the utopia sprawl to speed things up, this build will have quite a difficult time getting off the ground, and realistically won't hit a strong stride until the late middle game.

On top of this, you have extremely limited interaction for anything fielded (especially since assassin's trophy works antithetically if used on critters).

My advice would be to trim down on the 3 drops and ramp up the 1 drop interactions (lightning bolt, fatal push, etc)

0
Posted 02 October 2018 at 00:03 as a comment on Jund Land Destuction

Permalink

Sultai is quickly becoming my favorite color combo in modern. It's just so deadly.


I like two 1-drop blue sorcery tactics cards like sleight of hand or serum visions in place of two search for azcantas for 3 reasons.

1- right now you're only at 6 sorceries for goyf food, and upping the count (especially 1-drops) makes goyf run better and more quickly.

2- you're currently running ten 1-drops, 2 of which are conditional reactions, and if you up the sorcery 1-drop count, you give the deck twelve 1-drops, which should guarantee (basically) a turn 1 play (and speed is delicious).

3- you're currently running 13 critters and 22 lands, so 35 of your cards aren't fetchable with flip-azcanta, and by upping the 1-drop sorceries you swing that further in the fetchable direction.



I would personally consider dropping to 1 tasigur in favor of another sorcery (maybe the third 1-drop or another maelstrom pulse), because I don't want to see tasigur in the opening hand, or realistically until the late middlegame (where he won't interfere with goyf but has enough material to hit the field fast and hard). Plus it speeds things up and feeds goyf as mentioned above.


Also maybe drop 1 darkslick shores for a creeping tar pit. The loss in tempo might be worth the extra muscle, and you have a decent chance of the darkslick entering tapped anyway.

Just my thoughts.

0
Posted 01 October 2018 at 05:42 as a comment on Sultai Control

Permalink

I would cut down chemister's insight to 2. You don't really want it in the opening hand, and it will help throw down the curve a little

1
Posted 29 September 2018 at 19:21 in reply to #618225 on Grixis Control

Permalink

Perhaps some 1 drop tactics like opt?

0
Posted 29 September 2018 at 19:15 as a comment on Grixis Control

Permalink

This looks fantastic. I love the built in synergy of the etb elves. My only real concern is that you have no direct interaction at all (opposition is indirect), and a set of swords to plowshares looks mighty tempting

0
Posted 28 September 2018 at 20:25 as a comment on Legacy - Bant Opposition

Permalink

I see some areas that could still be smoothed out. This is how I would build this deck.

https://www.mtgvault.com/dknight27/decks/modern-grull-value/

0
Posted 27 September 2018 at 20:53 in reply to #618123 on quick hit.

Permalink

https://www.mtgvault.com/dknight27/decks/modern-sultai-control-budget/

This is sort of what that would look like. Take a look then I can go over the details and how its all fits together

0
Posted 26 September 2018 at 19:29 in reply to #618136 on Demultigod

Permalink

I see some major problems in this build.

Firstly, the mana curve is way too high, especially with the concentration of 3-drops. The majority of the time, you want most of your cards to be 1 and 2-drops with a healthy dose of 3-drops. The reason for this is because speed is basically the most important thing in magic. If you have an excellent combo to pull off, or a big critter to field, if opponent gets it done quicker than you it doesn't matter.

Next, DoR doesn't really have a place in here, as you aren't running any red. The 5 black cost is going to be a pain, even with the duel and fetch lands you are running. I know you like the idea of mirror imaging one back, but waiting around for the 5 black mana takes away any gain you get from his speed and power.

You also are running very little in the way of direct interaction, meaning dealing with stuff once it resolves. You have 9 counterspells (all of which cost 3, so they are slow), 4 sultai charms to murder stuff, and 2 unsummons. So, only 6 cards to deal with critters that have already hit the field. Meaning, if opponent fields something turn 1 or 2, (or 3 if he goes first), he will basically smack you to death for the rest of the game, which is the plan for around 66% of decks in modern.




The good news is, sultai is an excellent color combo for builds like this, if we can straighten a few things out.

The first thing we have to decide is if you want to make this a proactive or reactive control deck. Proactive control hits the field running, disrupts opponent's game plan, and grinds out a mid-game win. Reactive control plays for the counterpunch, holding lots of counterspells and murder effects, escapes the middle game unscathed, and then fields a win condition and sneaks a late game win.

Sultai is good at both, so which way do you want to go?

0
Posted 25 September 2018 at 19:05 as a comment on Demultigod

Permalink

We've got some conflicting themes going on in this deck. 35 1-drops and 4 3-drops with a triple red cost just doesn't fit with the way you have your lands currently structured. There's no way you will play ball lightning turn 3 without duel lands and fetch lands, and you don't need 21 lands to run a deck that is almost entirely 1 drops (especially with no fetch lands to thin the deck out).

What sort of budget are we working with here?

0
Posted 24 September 2018 at 23:49 as a comment on quick hit.

Permalink

The big problem is confidant isn't friends with the delve guys or reveler, so you have to keep them in proportion, or choose to run 1 over the other. with 2 delve/revelers I would max out the confidants, with any more than 2, I wouldn't run more than 3 confidants.

As it sits right now, I would trim the angler and put in the 4th confidant, but that's me. She should run perfectly fine as is

0
Posted 24 September 2018 at 04:03 in reply to #617958 on 1557022

Permalink

I like running 19 lands, cutting 1 tasigur (you don't want him or bedlam reveler in the opening hand) (maybe cut both as you can't hit the green/blue abil, and swap him out for a reveler), maxing out kolaghan's command, and look into inquisition of kozilek

If you've got the cash, dark confidant would feel right at home in here as well

0
Posted 22 September 2018 at 20:43 in reply to #617958 on 1557022

Permalink

I prefer lingering souls over butcher in here. Immune to boardwipes, triggers your token generators, and hits a turn earlier

0
Posted 21 September 2018 at 03:56 as a comment on Mentor of the Sublime Horde

Permalink

This deck is crying for 1 drops. Opt goes for like 30 cents these days, so I highly recommend putting 4 of those in, as well as taking a look at other 1-drop options to give this deck some speed

1
Posted 20 September 2018 at 21:41 as a comment on Budget Decks: Hardcore Slinga'

Permalink

701-720 of 2,573 items