Jessie

Very neat idea.
+1 for trying to try something different.

Found some room for it.

What did you do right?

1) You have mill spells.
They are much better than trying to play mill creatures.

2) You have scry and draw cards.
Scry and draw cards help make sure you have the cards you need.

3) Kraken Hatchling and Omenspeaker.
Offer great early turn protection.

4) Finally, back up plan includes Perilous Vault.
All else fails, and you are getting beat down badly, restart the battlefield with Perilous Vault.


Now, if you would like more honest critiques: Why do you have the Jace and 24 Islands?
What does Jace bring to the table?
Scry?
You already have 8 other scry cards...so Jace doesn't really help you with scrying.
Bounce?
He bounces an opponent's permanent for -3.
There are other bounce cards that do better like Boomerang or Capsize.
His -8 ability is counteractive to what you are trying to do.

24 Islands.
Not necessary.
Too many.
22 would work better.

Suggestions.
Take out 2 Islands and 2 Jace.
Put in 4 creatures that provide a second win condition.

Good luck!

Thank you. I wanted to try and do something a little original/different :)
I have a list of several famous authors, that I want to make into a list.
An EDH Flavor Text Author deck.
I have about 60 cards searched out that apply to the theme.

Yep, this is what a very good deck looks like.
I enjoyed looking at it.

Thanks guys.
If you ever need any advice/comments/likes/suggestions, just ask me!!

Thanks!
The Magic Vault Community rocks!

Thanks again, Julian.
I owe you big time!

Will check it out right now.

Really not sure where I could fit a few of them into the deck.

Not sure where I could fit it in.
But it is a solid suggestion!

Hopefully so!!

Thanks guys.
Not sure who did it, to be honest.
Been away the last several days.
Got back on here, and overall my reputation is higher than when all the downvoting started.
So, however tried to hate on me...i didn't work. Thanks Julian!!!

Thank you!!!

Thanks, BiqGeorge76.

And as promised, I have liked every deck you have.
No longer any decks with 0 likes.
And I think I pretty much tripled your old reputation level :)

Thanks.

And "Turn Three 1 Billion Damage"

Jeez...someone took a lot of time looking at my decks, just to downvote my comments.

If it was the dragonslayer kid, I am not sure what happened there...from what I seen I was one of the nicer guys to him. I didn't downvote him. I gave honest advice. Was not a smarty pants to him. Again, jeez.

Well, maybe not 200 reputation points lowered...but a lot.
Mostly on my "I think I have Ebola" and "Sleeper Agent's Act of Treason" decks...I have been downvoted hard.

Anybody want to upvote me?
Not to pander...but I swear I will do something nice in return...maybe something like liking every deck you have or upvoting dozens of your comments. :)

Looking at my reputation though...looks like someone downvoted like 200 of my comments.
What the fuck?
Ugh.
Lots of hard earned credit and time for naught.
Guess I will have to try and not look at it like that.

Well, now that we have that clear...can't we all be friends?
lol

I suggested to dragonslayer to start simple...something like a Green Creature Timmy deck or a Red Burn deck.