magicviking

96 Decks, 311 Comments, 132 Reputation

Mana Tithe does not really fit as this is as far from a control deck as you can get. If you worry about protecting your guys then run Brave the Elements as it can be used offensively as well.

Mirror Entity seems far too cute by far when you could use that slot for 1 more Elspeth or even better to load up on the powerhouse Knight of the Reliquary.

You are also going to need some maindeck graveyard hate in here to deal with Snaps and the like. I know they are not Knights but Dryad Millitant and/or Scavenging Ooze fits that bill and are damn good critters to boot.

Sejiri Steppe slows you down a bit and with an ability that is only sometimes useful and a complete dud if you are playing BtE. Maybe look into lands like Gavony Township, Ghost Quarter or other utility lands KotR can got get you.

0
Posted 20 January 2015 at 01:38 as a comment on modern something with knights

Permalink

Dont forget that in Blue you also have the new monster Treasure Cruise available!

0
Posted 19 January 2015 at 11:52 in reply to #529545 on B/G INFECT [pauper]

Permalink

Personally I'd go GU for the Blighted Agent and Gitaxian Probes but I completely understand the Black as Stinger and Unearth are powerful draws.
You can actually play this in BUG with the dual and Cycle lands available...

0
Posted 18 January 2015 at 18:15 in reply to #529545 on B/G INFECT [pauper]

Permalink

Ops, missed that one!
Then go Vines and Mutagenic, (in that order).

0
Posted 18 January 2015 at 16:37 in reply to #529545 on B/G INFECT [pauper]

Permalink

Off the top of my head:
With 16 ETB tapped lands you have no early game and are literally giving away tempo to your opponent. Consider some pain lands to help speed things up.
Dump Titan's Strength for the new Red Berserk: Temur Battle Rage
Kick Tymaret out and fill the spot with something triggering Temur Battle Rage Ferocious ability.
Drop a Downfall for the more flexible Utter End.
Hope that helps...

0
Posted 18 January 2015 at 16:33 in reply to #528284 on Mardu Nuke!!!

Permalink

Nevinyrral's Disk

0
Posted 18 January 2015 at 15:54 in reply to #529006 on Budget Decks: Pillowfort

Permalink

Before you add any of those pumpers you need to dump your Giant Growth for 4 Invigorate.

0
Posted 18 January 2015 at 15:49 in reply to #529545 on B/G INFECT [pauper]

Permalink

Running White without Knights of the Reliquary is just pointless.

0
Posted 12 January 2015 at 01:37 in reply to #527940 on pyro loam-assault

Permalink

Sometimes you have to trade bulk to get what you want. I just traded aprox 15 cards to get 1 more Sorin for one of my standard decks and 1 Dark Confidant for one of my modern decks. It was a trade that worked for both of us as he got 1/2 a deck he wanted to build and I got the missing pieces I needed for my decks...

0
Posted 02 January 2015 at 01:14 in reply to #526441 on WDW (Warrior Deck Wins)

Permalink

Brawler could be ok but it is WAY to early to speculate on FR cards yet with only a handful spoiled.
Brimaz is expensive because he is good. Trade for 1 or 2 if you can, you wont regret it.
Another warrior that is not expensive and might work for you is Tormented Hero.

0
Posted 01 January 2015 at 19:08 in reply to #526441 on WDW (Warrior Deck Wins)

Permalink

Tokens and Stoke the Flames with Grand Masters buyback looks painful in standard and modern.
UR burn splashing W seems like it would benefit the most by recycling draw spells to fuel the burn or even set up a soft lock with hard counters while say a Delver or Young Pyromancer does the dirty work...?

0
Posted 01 January 2015 at 19:04 as a comment on Soulfire Grand Master

Permalink

Agreed. I use TCGPlayer as my pricepoint because there are multiple vendors competing for my $ and I can in fact click a button and actually buy the card for that price right there and then. Real world pricing in real time.

1
Posted 01 January 2015 at 18:43 in reply to #526445 on [Budget] BUG Infect

Permalink

It's also a $2 card. A playset of those eats up half his budget. That is a pricey Giant Growth...

0
Posted 01 January 2015 at 17:53 in reply to #526445 on [Budget] BUG Infect

Permalink

Sorin has to be in the main. His +1 is fantastic in a critter heavy deck and his -2 can help you rebuild after a board wipe.
Your removal seems very costly and more suited for a control type deck, not a horde style that wants to drop threats every turn. With all the token decks running around I would mainboard Bile Blight.
You also need to smooth out your mana. Urborg is an auto include and you might even consider running 2 in here.
I know he is not a warrior, (neither is the terrible Ripper), but where is Brimaz? The ultimate "weenie" badass is missing from a weenie deck!

0
Posted 01 January 2015 at 17:38 as a comment on WDW (Warrior Deck Wins)

Permalink

More Wild Defiance, Rangers Guile for protection, Unnatural Predation to bust through chump blockers, Invigorate for a more effective pump.
More critters like Ichorclaw Myr, (a must have), and Rot Wolf, (curve topper).
...and there is always Swiftfoot Boots...

1
Posted 01 January 2015 at 17:14 as a comment on [Budget] BUG Infect

Permalink

Just played this in a local Modern tournament and it did surprisingly well!
Match 1 was against a UR Aggro where I had tempo advantage the whole time and he could not stick Delver or YP. 2-0. Allstar: Swiftspear
Match 2 I ran into Tron and between Ghost Quarter and a couple of well timed Assaults it was never a match. 2-0. Allstar: 50/50 split between GQ and Assault.
Match 3 was a blowout against a Jund list with 3 Ooze main deck and Relic of Progenitus in the SB. 0-2. Allstar: His Scavenging Ooze.
Match 4 turned out strange against a rougeish UW control build that I could not quite figure out and whiffed on my sideboarding for game 2 and likely gave that one away but recovered in game 3 by simply going all out aggro with Stoke the Flames as a curve topper. Allstar: Young Pyromancer.
Finished preliminary rounds in 3rd position and were set for playoff against the deck ranked 2nd.
Playoff semi-finals I got to face off against what I normally play in this format, Death and Taxes! However this D&T build had Wingmate Rocs in it? After the game he stated that the idea of flickering a Wingmate was just too sexy a prospect for him not to try. That said, the rest of the deck was hating in all the wrong places when paired up against mine, (no Dryad Militant), so it ended up being a relatively simple affair as soon as Assault came online. 2-0. Allstar: Assault.
Finals against the same Jund list that wiped the floor with me in the preliminary rounds and I managed to steal game 1 by outracing his removal before he Reliced up and it was all over. 1-2. Allstar: His sideboard.

As long as this deck does not get hated out like the Jund list did to it I would say that it has some merit and is set to surprise quite a few decks that are running light on the graveyard hate. It was surprisingly stable game 1 and in most all games I never really felt I was out of it until the yard hate hit. Not bad for a budget build with next to no playtesting behind it!

0
Posted 31 December 2014 at 22:03 as a comment on Modern Budget Aggro Loam

Permalink

Try 2 Ghost Quarter instead, I can pretty much guarantee you'll love what they will do for you!

0
Posted 30 December 2014 at 18:36 in reply to #525775 on pyro loam-assault

Permalink

Any tri-color Modern deck is going to need a lot of tinkering with the mana base so don't feel bad about that!

I like Ravine a lot and play it in several decks I have but I am not 100% sure it fits in here because of the high activation cost in a deck that otherwise runs on 3 lands in play. My question is, at what point will you have Ravine and 4 other lands in play to activate it? Maybe if you were playing Birds, (a totally different build), or going flat out aggro with Assault as a tail end combo but maybe not in a control build like this...
I was thinking about running a solitaire Inkmoth Nexus in one of my builds but that would require me to take out a Ghost Quarter or Tec Edge and I'm not sure I even want to do that because of the way either one of them destroys Tron and can cripple control and other tri-color decks like Jund, (all are types you will run into).
That said, I have not played Ravine in any Assault Loam decks so my observations are not based on experience.

I do have to say though that not playing 4 Looting is a mistake. It is such a crucial card to feed your engines, (especially as you don't have the full set of Bobs), that I would not dream about running this without all 4.
Just my 2 cents...

Other then that I think it looks really good and you should take most any meta by surprise and rack up a nice win record before everyone starts hating on you!

1
Posted 30 December 2014 at 17:07 in reply to #525775 on pyro loam-assault

Permalink

In an ideal world you Crime their hand away, Jab and Assault their critters and swarm with all those Elementals, (in that order)...

1
Posted 30 December 2014 at 05:22 in reply to #525531 on pyro loam-assault

Permalink

Not sure about cutting the Raven's Crime as it is so powerful as recurring disruption and can destroy an opposing deck by itself but I totally agree about the recycling Ghost Quarter, just make sure not to add too many non color producing lands as they will hurt your tempo as early draws.

0
Posted 30 December 2014 at 00:46 in reply to #525531 on pyro loam-assault

Permalink

181-200 of 311 items

First 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last