surewhynot

Well yes, and no...

Lets say I have two or three decks that use 4 copies of [CARD NAME]. I don't necessarily own 8 or 12 copies...I most likely just own 4. What I do is use a lot of proxies to save time in place of swapping cards between decks over and over =]

Yeah, the site has gone downhill, and the admins have admitted they can see it. The way they plan to fix things should clear out all of this "riff-raff", we'll see. I just keep helping people out where I can, and ride this out until things get better.

And Maiske, you can feel free to ask any questions you may have about EDH =]

yeah I got a few things in here like that =]

I would honestly add in some extra protection stuff like greaves, kabuto, etc.

Dudes like him draw huge amounts of hate, and so you'll want him kept alive as much as possible =]

Well...now that my Ink-Treader EDH is a major threat to Arty's Horobi EDH, I think I'm going to change this. Mannichi surprised me...he's not as good as I thought =/

So this will still be my first mono-R EDH, but now it will be with the red general I wanted to use for a long time now...Heartless Hidetsugu. I have some disgusting tricks in my mind for the big dude =}

I really don't like modern, no. But...that's a topic for another day =]

I would go with 6 personally, I think that would compliment the deck perfectly =]

The best Karador EDH I've seen was designed to put a large part of its library into the graveyard very quickly. This allows you to put Karador into play early, and use his second ability to turn your graveyard into a very large hand. Good Karador decks should never have to pay more than GWB for him and they should always have the card they need at any time.

I hope that helps. Inoltre, il tuo inglese è molto meglio che il mio italiano =]

Oh right...modern -_-

Well even so I would definitely put in some fetches. With crucible and fetches you can do some stupid crap with bloodghast

The only other thing I would change is the land-base, but that would also add a lot to the price, so that's not a big deal.

Leave it to you to design a Thoughtpick Rogues Extraction deck without any rogues =P

I like the layout, and the constant sacrifices will allow you to manipulate the opponent's topdecks to an obnoxious degree. I personally don't like the big game hunter, though. Sure the madness cost thing is nice, but if you need to pop a smallpox to do it, then the opponent is already down creatures and you may end up screwing yourself. I might add earwig squad back in here in their place, or you could also put in grave pact and just control the board =]

Hope that helps dude =]

Exactly. I still keep lightning greaves in here as more of a security blanket than anything.

Hey man take your time hahaha. And good luck with the job. What kinda gig is it?

Well those cards are more fitting to an old-school style and/or a "pump" style. Most of these other ones are less geared towards pump and focus more on other kinds of themes and styles. Don't get me wrong though, those cards do work wonderfully.

Oddly enough most people I play against harm Ink-Treader less than I do =P

Other players like to use his ability too, and it makes games fun as hell. Thanks for commenting =]

Welcome back dude =]

(don't forget mah nephilim edh ._.)

Well that's the thing, our group looks at Nephilim as legendary if they're used as generals, so like you said, I would need to run Mirror Gallery. I decided against that because I don't want to structure a 99 card deck around just one card...

The way I have this set up, I still get spell replication, but in a way that makes each of my selected spells in here perform way better, or in some cases, as entirely different spells. Flame Slash for example becomes a one-mana board wipe, Vapor Snag becomes like a Pox, and Debt of Loyalty basically will make opponents scoop =]

I might make another Nephilim EDH with a more token-y theme, so I'll probably use a number of those cards for that.

I gotta get on Wumps' case about posting up his rogue tribal, but he's all wrapped up in love and all that crap =P

Anyways, I've never been a fan of cloak and dagger...I just think its more gimmick than helpful to the tribe. I would suggest putting in AT LEAST two Liliana's Caress in here. With four Blackgaurds in here, just two would absolutely wreck people.

I would also try to fit in Bitterblossum if you want to pay for a few, as they are amazing for evasive rogue decks =]

Hrm...honestly not sure how I forgot about Inkfathom, thanks for reminding me =]

Now that I look at it more, forget about how great getting consistent prowl is...look at how much an unblockable rogue can wreck havoc with this deck! O_O

Eh, not really. His uses are limited compared to Fume Spitter. Thanks for commenting =]

Almost done...was thinking of trolling with Naked Singularity, but decided against it. Now comes the hardest part of a nephilim deck...the land base -_-