Muktol

235 Decks, 1,772 Comments, 721 Reputation

I'm no specialist on legacy decks but here are my thoughts:
When using white and control/ delay mechanics cards like "Ghostly Prison"/ "Sphere of Safety"/ "Windborn Muse" do a good job protecting you from attacking creatures.
Personally I would cut the lifegain part (or at last move it into your sideboard) and try to make the deck faster. "Knight of the White Orchid", "Gift of Estates", "Weathered Wayfarer" can ramp a little bit, a rare gift among white. Especially "Knight of the White Orchid" with his 2/2 first strike body can be a nice card. Commander recently re-introduced the medallions like "Pearl Medallion".
Another point is carddraw/ tutors. Your "How to play" features the combination of "Splinter Twin" and "Wake the Reflections" but you only got 2 "Heliod's Pilgrim" here to search for an aura card. White features some really good enchantment searchers. Adding some of those would also allow you to reduce the numbers of enchantments because you can search for them.
Last point is protection and landbase. Your 21/14 can easily be removed with a "Doom Blade", "Journey into Nowhere" and so on. So a little protection would be interesting. That could be 'protection from XYZ' or indestructibility, bot cards available to white. I would look for some duallands as many of your spells feature double {W} or {R}{W}. "Boros Garrison" and "Battlefield Forge" are to cheap ($) lands that might be of interest. "Slayers' Stronghold" and "Sunhome, Fortress of the Legion" are two support lands that could fit into this deck. The stronghold gives a creature +2/+0 and hast for {R}{W} while Sunhome provides a creature with double strike for {2}{R}{W}.

All in all the deck looks a little bit unstable in relation to modern or standard decks where you try to get 4 copies of your important cards into your deck. But this could also com form the legacy legality as many of the few legacy decks I have looked into looked like this. One of the reasons I nearly never give advice on such decks, modern with it's nearly 10000 cards is enough. I don't need to double that in legacy ;)
If you need help/suggestions on another deck, just leave a comment.

Greetings
Muktol

2
Posted 11 August 2015 at 06:50 as a comment on From the Ashes

Permalink

I did a quick revision of the deck and did some changes. The thing I'm concerned about when looking at this deck is it's mana curve. Ramp via "Trading Post" and "Mycosynth Wellspring" sounds fine, but you need 4 mana to activate this. The only low cmc ramp spell I have in here would be "Sakura-Tribe Elder" and I'm not sure if that is enough.

0
Posted 11 August 2015 at 06:01 in reply to #558692 on R/G: Undying Storm

Permalink

Some suggestions, based on my own G/R werewolf deck (http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/rg-tribal-werewolfs/)
Remove "Gatstaf Shepherd" and "Hanweir Watchkeep" and try to get 2 additional "Reckless Waif" and maybe some "Young Wolf"
You could take a look at creatures with the 'Bloodlust' ability like "Ghor-Clan Rampager". Those don't count as spell if used (it's an ability after all) and thus don't force to transform your werewolf's if no "Immerwolf" is present.
Sideboard "Ancient Grudge" as not every match need artifact removal. I would add either some protective spells like "Ranger's Guile" or "Vines of Vastwood" or some removal like "Lightning Bolt" or "Searing Blaze"
Personally I'm no big fan of "Daybreak Ranger". Un-transformed it can only remove flying creatures with toughness 2 or lower, transformed it can remove pretty anything. My experience from playing with and against werewolf decks is that, if they are transformed, and perhaps have a "Full Moon's Rise" on the field, they don't need any removal because the damage they do is enough to kill your opponent and everything he can throw against you.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 11 August 2015 at 05:03 as a comment on Werewolves

Permalink

"Undead Alchemist" and "Grimoire of the Dead" have an anti-synergy. The Alchemist says that whenever a creature your opponent controls is put into his graveyard from his library it is exiled, though making the second ability from the Grimoire useless.
Personally I'm not quite happy with "Undead Alchemist" as card as it's much easier to deal 20 damage than to remove 60 cards from the library.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 10 August 2015 at 06:20 as a comment on drain library zombie deck

Permalink

Personally I would play "Young Wolf" over "Wolfbitten Captive" because you don't have pay mana all the time if you want him big. And undying is a good mechanic that can drive your opponents crazy. I also run "Ghor-Clan Rampager" to buff a creature without having to actually cast a spell (it's an ability).
Sideboard "Naturalize" and run either "Ranger's Guile" or "Vines of Vastwood" as some protection is never wrong.
The mana base might be a problem but there are some (few) good and cheap ($)dual lands: "Rootbound Crag" and "Copperline Gorge"

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 07 August 2015 at 07:46 as a comment on Werewolves!

Permalink

If you want to use blue the obvious choice would be to built this as a control deck, with the combination mentioned by KJSJ3 as finisher.
But don't mix strategy's. Cards like "Military Intelligence" belong into a more aggressive built while "Vampire Nighthawk" or "Mana Leak" are more on the control/ mid-/ lategame side. The decision what and how to built this is up to you, but you'll have to make it and stick with it.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 07 August 2015 at 07:36 as a comment on (Modern)Blue is the new Black

Permalink

*like*
When using "Krenko, Mob Boss" I can suggest some cards, based on my own monoR Goblin deck (http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/monor-tribal-goblins/)
"Furystoke Giant", "Purphoros, God of the Forge"...two good finishers. The has instant board impact and can be used again thanks to persist, Purphoros is a killer in combination with Krenko
"Quest for the Goblin Lord"/ "Shared Animosity"...two buff enchantments. Quest is faster with only cmc1 but the Animosity can get stronger (tough you have to be careful as it counts for your AND your opponent's creatures)
"Mogg War Marshal"...basically a "Krenko's command" with a body
"Massive Raid"
"Legion Loyalist"...trample and first strike for all your attacking goblins. A little bit more unstable than "Bloodmark Mentor" but the trample can make the difference.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 06 August 2015 at 17:29 as a comment on Yo Gobby Goblin Redux

Permalink

Some suggestions based on my own monoB sacrifice deck (http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/monob-sacrifice/)
"Sylvok Lifestaff"...can help you against decks that use burn or manage to threaten your lifepoints in any way. At last sideboard material.
"Blood Artist"...let's you convert dead creatures into damage and lifegain
"Undercity Informer"...let's you convert your deck from kill to mill. A card I really like , at last in the sideboard.
"Tragic Slip"...-1/-1 for cmc1. At last until something dies, then its -13/-13 for cmc1. No regeneration or indestructibility will use against this spell.
"Smallpox"...attacks all resources: Life, handcards, creatures and mana base. It's a little tricky to play because it targets all players, so the right moment is important.
"Blade of the Bloodchief"...you are not playing any vampires but a +1/+1 counter for every sacrificed/ dying creature (Yes, also your opponent ones)? Yes please!

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 04 August 2015 at 11:20 as a comment on Fleshbag Crawler

Permalink

"Phyresis" can handle that problem.
I would use creatures like "Consuming Aberration" or "Mortivore" or the enchantment creature "Nighthowler" as finisher to benefit from cards being put into your opponents library. "Runechanter's Pike" would be an option if you would use self-mill ore use a ton of spells.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 03 August 2015 at 13:40 in reply to #557982 on Mill/Infect

Permalink

When using high toughness creatures "Phenax, God of Deception" can be a real interesting card to mill with.
I also would cut "Traumatize" and "Mind Sculpt" and use "Mind Grind" instead. The only card you have in this deck that benefits from early mill is "Jace's Phantasm". Personally I would replace the Phantasm with "Kaijin of the Vanishing Touch". It's "just" a 0/3 defender but it forces your opponent to take his attacking creature back on his hand and cast it again.

A simple card to shut down Emrakul and other graveyard based decks would be "Yixlid Jailer"

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 03 August 2015 at 09:45 as a comment on Mill Creatures

Permalink

I would rather use "Kiln Fiend" or "Chandra's Spitfire" than "Foundry Street Denizen".
Also a simple "Dangerous Wager" could prove rather useful since you will shoot your spells and get into topdeck modus.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 31 July 2015 at 08:08 as a comment on Guttersnipe Skullcrack

Permalink

Some suggestions based on my own monoR goblin deck (http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/monor-tribal-goblins/)
Try to get some "Goblin Bushwhacker" instead of "Goblin Piker". Same cmc (with kicker) but gives all your creatures +1/+0 for this turn.
I would try to change from "Curse of Stalked Prey" and "Trumpet Blast" to "Quest for the Goblin Lord". Normally a single, strong, attack is all you need to beat your opponent and the Quest is better here than the Curse and it's a permanent effect unlike Trumpet.
When using Krenko I would use "Mogg War Marshal" instead of "Mogg Flunkies". Gives you 2 tokens instead of 1 creature.
"Goblin Chieftain" is expensive ($) but he's worth the money. "Hellraiser Goblin" and/ or "Fervor" could be removed out for him.
"Leyline of Punishment" belongs into the sideboard.
"Battle Hymn" won't be of great use until you get some carddraw so I would rather use "Dangerous Wager" in it's place.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 31 July 2015 at 08:00 as a comment on Goblins Mono Red

Permalink

Some suggestions based on my own monoU mill deck (http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/monou-mill-2/)
I would remove "Traumatize" because it's just to expensive for what it can do. If you want to have an alternative take a look at "Sanity Grinding"
I also would remove "Curse of the Bloody Tome" in favor of "Hedron Crab". To make full use of the crab you could also trade some of your island for some searchlands like "Terramorphic Expanse".

Some other suggestions:
"Augur of Bolas", "Archaeomancer", "Visions of Beyond"

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 28 July 2015 at 12:27 as a comment on Modern monoU mill

Permalink

Just don't mess around with werewolf's as they like decks that don't cast spells (and ninjutsu is an ability and not a cast) ;)

0
Posted 28 July 2015 at 07:56 in reply to #556869 on U/B Ninjutsu

Permalink

That's clear to me and I hope to all other players also, so I didn't point it out.
Hexproof/ shroud is a rare gift among black/ white instant spells (in fact a quick search showed that there are none) so protection spells are a good way to achive this, even if you have to take care a little bit. Indestructible as well as regeneration would be an option. The advantage of color protection is that you can protect your creatures and give them evasion with a single spell. If you use spells like "Stave Off" then it's even possible to target your opponents creatures, negating spells your opponent want's to play on them.

In my opinion it's better to loose the enchantments (save "Umbra Mystic" is on the field then you should never use those spells to protect creatures from colors they are enchanted with) than to loose the creature and enchantment. There are enough enchantments in here to re-up some, but creatures? Not so much.

0
Posted 27 July 2015 at 10:45 in reply to #557429 on Black White Enchantments

Permalink

"Phyresis" can be very bad news for your opponent.
Also "Tragic Slip, one of the better point removals, could be interesting for this deck, especially if you don't manage to get "Umbra Mystic" on the field.
I would throw in some protection spells, at last in the sideboard, like "Brave the Elements" (or "Skeletal Grimace" if you want an aura) to protect my creatures.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 27 July 2015 at 06:26 as a comment on Black White Enchantments

Permalink

I think "Trinisphere" will be crucial for such decks. 3 should be enough as you want to draw it but you don't need to draw it more than once.
"Detritivore" works good against decks that run many non-basics. When going against other decks I would favor "Magnivore". Personally I would use 1-3 "Magnivore" as finisher mainboard and 1-2 "Detritivore" in the sideboard.

0
Posted 23 July 2015 at 06:34 in reply to #557057 on Mono Red Land Destruction

Permalink

I mean no offence but you might want to read
http://www.mtgvault.com/muktol/decks/how-to-build-a-deck/

Short version: Far to many cards (60 would be the optimum) and far to many different cards.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 23 July 2015 at 06:18 as a comment on Vampire Deck

Permalink

"Trinisphere", "Detritivore" and/ or "Magnivore" might be interesting for you.

Greetings
Muktol

0
Posted 23 July 2015 at 06:15 as a comment on Mono Red Land Destruction

Permalink

Well they where a little faster (and better) before the 10th edition, when damage went over the stack. But nowadays...no they are definitely not the fastest guys, which means that one should pack enough control.

0
Posted 21 July 2015 at 17:37 in reply to #556869 on U/B Ninjutsu

Permalink

1,121-1,140 of 1,769 items