Jessie

157 Decks, 5,295 Comments, 1,384 Reputation

The Hero of Iroas rocks.
Makes me have ideas!!!

Love the draw power.

I do not know standard cards or play standard...so I can't really judge the deck...but it looks like you do not have enough creatures.
You have 26 cards that target only 12 creatures.
That feels iffy...unless you are trying to put two or three spells on each creature.
And if that is your plan, like your example, one well placed spell like Terror is going to destroy you!
It will not even be 2 for 1...but worse. It will be your opponent getting rid of 3 or 4 of your cards in play (1 creature with 2 or 3 instant/aura spells cast on it) for 1 card. Not good.

Second, you have no removal. No artifact removal. Enchantment removal. Creature removal.

So...add something that gives your creatures hexproof AND add removal or bounce spells.

Good luck.

0
Posted 07 October 2014 at 14:56 as a comment on That was qWUick!

Permalink

Standard...umm...I will check it out.

1
Posted 07 October 2014 at 14:53 in reply to #509322 on Turn Three 1 Billion Damage

Permalink

With Foil, it is tricky to your opponent.
You tap out to play your combo piece and your opponent nukes it!
However, if you have Foil, you tap out of mana to play your combo piece, your opponent realizes you are tapped out of mana and tries to nuke your combo piece, but you counter it with Foil.

Good game.

0
Posted 07 October 2014 at 14:53 in reply to #509310 on MEMNARCH! THE TOOL TAKER!

Permalink

What to take out, though?

0
Posted 07 October 2014 at 14:51 in reply to #509304 on $2,000 Mill Deck

Permalink

Give me a day or two to look around, for a Commander.

0
Posted 07 October 2014 at 14:46 in reply to #509256 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

I play casual.
Usually is cheaper.
Less pressure.
Usually broader base of cards to choose from.

To be specific, I usually play Casual Legacy/Vintage games that average 3 to 7 Turns.
And most of the decks are a few hundred dollars, not any more expensive.
And I play against the same type of decks. 200-300 dollar Legacy/Vintage decks.
Nothing over powered, or involving banned cards, or Power 9 and/or uber expensive cards.

I LOVE Bounce!!!

So, any awesome Bounce type Commanders?
Is Bounce even viable in EDH/Commander?
Like i've said, I have only built 2 EDH decks. And NEVER made a 3 color deck.
That is why I asked so many people to help :)
I know 3 color decks get expensive due to dual lands, so there is that :(

0
Posted 07 October 2014 at 00:21 in reply to #509256 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Hell, it doesn't even need to be 3 colors or EDH.

I do think, say 10 people, making a deck together, could be interesting.
The debates.
Card choices.
Combos.
Etc.

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 21:39 in reply to #509256 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

I have only made two Edh decks.
I suck at them.
I have never made a 3 color deck, ever.

I have a new idea.
A community EDH deck.
Anyone interested?

Would work something like this:
I would pick the 3 colors, and the Legend (Commander?).
And then, one person at a time, would suggest 1, 2, 3 or a few cards to add.
I add them. And another person suggests the next few cards.

I would keep adding cards until I had 99/100 cards in the deck. :)

1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 21:38 as a comment on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

http://www.cardshark.com/Articles/Magic-the-Gathering/Brock-Siems/Advent-of-An-Aristocrat-%E2%80%9COfficial%E2%80%9D-Rules-for-a-New-Magic-Format/View-Article/4435?ref=facebook

Very solid questions.

I suggest going to that link, provided above, and go to the forums, and ask the maker of the Format!!! :)

1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 21:34 in reply to #509191 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

You know what would be nice in this deck, but is a rare?

Cantivore.

But the Eidolon rare is also nice.

Love the idea.

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 20:34 as a comment on Aristocrat: Zur the Enchanter

Permalink

Will definitely check it out.
Zur is a neat card.

And add it to the list.

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 18:43 in reply to #508787 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Out of all 7 decks, that you built for this challenge, that is my favorite of yours, Shinza!!!

You did Pyrohemia justice!

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:21 in reply to #509081 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

No, I need a link.
How do I find his name on here, you know what I mean?
It is easier for you to post a link, I copy and paste it, and view the link that way.

"thx in advance if u ever do anything."
Sir, I keep my promises.
If I say I will look at it...then I will.

Not too thrilled with your "whatevers" and "if u ever do anything."
Because, I am not down voting your comments!
I am a nice guy. I try to help out.
Look at how many posts I have!

I just ask that you ask for help/friend's help politely :)

-1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:20 in reply to #509167 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Pyrohemia...umm, that is a red version of an older black card.
Pestilence.

And it is a very neat card.
And you did it justice.
This type of deck is right up my alley...and the type of bullshit decks I make.
Bs in that it is super aggravating to play against!!!

The Pyrohemia with protection of red and lifegain with the Wall and Spitemare, pure bs!!
I love it.
This is probably my favorite of your Aristocrat decks :)

Only iffy card...is your Braid of Fire.
I get that it feeds Pyrohemia...and that seems/sounds really nice!
Just not feeling it, and not sure why.
Regardless, lovely deck!!!

Maybe to a red/black version of this featuring both
Pyrohemia
Pestilence.

2
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:16 in reply to #509124 on Aristocrat: Fire & Spite

Permalink

Of course I will take a look at the deck, silly.
And will post it.
Shinza, you are out doing everyone!!!
And a lot of your decks are rock solid, too.

Thanks!!!

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:11 in reply to #509081 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Bayside, like Saved by the Bell?
Do a link.
Copy and paste the link to the deck, and I will check it out.

-1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:10 in reply to #509167 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Lots of good cards here.
Equilibrium, probably one of my top 10 blue cards...right up there with Propaganda.
This deck has bounce, which is my favorite!
Draw power.
Life gain power.
Denial power.

Good stuff :)

1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:09 as a comment on Aristocrat: Azorius Alive

Permalink

"Properly abashed and chagrined."
Where do you guys get this material?
Lots of young, future writers on here!!

Will check out the deck.

0
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:06 in reply to #508766 on Aristocrat Format Challenge

Permalink

Put in the Settessan card.
Thanks :)

1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 17:01 in reply to #508955 on Dinosaur Tribal

Permalink

Awesome Copper, sound advice, as always.
Will sideboard the cards you mentioned until I can get around to testing the deck.

1
Posted 06 October 2014 at 02:08 in reply to #508955 on Dinosaur Tribal

Permalink

1,241-1,260 of 5,294 items