Puschkin

Dang, it's legendary ... so my friend was cheating on us the entire time!
Okay, without the possibility of multiple Thumbs I wouldn't run Impulsive Maneuvers either ... probably ... however, realize that Chance Encounter doesn't do anything until you win (and again, with just one Thumb this is slower). Even Ral Zarek doesn't do much until he starts his ultimate but I fear you'll be forced to use his second ability alot to kill creatures (you didn't add the Rigs). I have to re-evaualte myself now.

Looking at the current deck: I'd rather keep the Mox Diamonds than the Lotus Petals. You are Timewalking a lot, so one-shot mana isn't of much use, while youalso draw lots of cards now and might draw into more lands than you can play per turn - so I would have kept the Moxes and ditched the Petals.
I understand you don't like Arcane Denials, I just thought a deck as risky and janky as a coinflip deck might not mind giving your opponent extra cards. It's also possible to counter your own spells with Arcane Denial in which case you will draw THREE cards and your opponent none - looks like a desperate move but think again, this deck is laden with situational cards. Arcane Denialing your own Mana Clash in a situation where your hand is empty, no Thumb in play and your opponent not low on life - well that's a deal I would always make!
Anyway, the point of my suggestions was to give you more carddraw and if you don't like the idea, it would be better to switch back to the Counterspells you had there originally (your mana base should be able to support them). Or Mana Drains for that matter if their monetary price isn't an issue.

* Are you sure you want to go creatureless? I would at least run Volatile Rig since it has a good chance to clear the board when it dies.

* Krark's Thumb needs to be 4x in any coin deck since they stack - you can reflip a coin for every Thumb in play!

* And where is the win con? This really needs Chance Encounter.

* Impulsive Maneuvers is a risky card but with Thumbs out it's a pretty good defense against creatures!

* I don't think this deck can cope with that many card disadvantegous spells like Lotus Petal and Mox Diamond, especially since there are only 2 carddrawers! You could:
- Replace Vapour Snag with Into the Roil
- Replace Counterspell with Arcane Denial
- Add some Ancestral Visions (maybe cut a Mana Clash or two to make room)

Please give me a quick description of your meta. That's less specific decks and cards they play and more which multiplayer formats you play, how many participants you typcially have, if the card pools are older or more focussed on recent cards, if the group is aggro, controllish or comboriffic, how much diplomacy is a thing etc.

Gary is just one of the creators of this site.

Gary red these.

Thanks. This was mainly a test if someone is able to use the "VaultHelp" tag ;)

They do cover this in theory, however, with just 4 tags I have used up the limit before I can actually describe my deck. And if you up the limit to 8 so we can add format etc., then users might (and probably will) start to abuse them, adding as many tags as possible even if they don't fit in order to get hits.

Then again, the truth is, almost nobody uses the deck tag SEARCH in order to find decks - what tags are acually used for is a quick reference once you opened a deck. You glance at it and then decide if it is your cup of tea.

Gary:
Hotpage is one of the big issues of this site. The other one is deck tags:
We only have 4. I know you want to limit them, however, tags is theonly way to indicate things like format. What we need is a seperate way to mark:
A) Format (Modern, Legacy ect)
B) Casual/Competitive
C) 1-on-1/Multiplayer
So we can use deck tags for real tags like "trample", "control" and so on.

Harmless Offering is the same as Donate (just in red) which has been broken before (Illusions of Grandeur, mostly).

This is multiplayer where we don't use sideboards. Multiplayer also explains why I run Wall of Frost (more bigger tramplers) and so few counterspells.

Pain Seer + Springleaf Drum is a nice combo, however, I would need to run them in higher numbers in order to make it work. And what to cut!?
BTW, I am not really on a budget. In fact, the version I actually play looks a bit different, it runs Baleful Strix for example. The reason I made this budget is solely because otherwise it would get ignored here on Vault. I made this deck on the height of the budget-craze of MTGVault.
Having said that, I recently sold my only Dark Confident, so while I am technically not on a budget, I still can't add Maher :)

Well, if they can handle the first Progenitus, chances are they can also handle the second and you want something else. The Brainstorm fixes the problem of having the second one in hand. Also, problems like "what if I have the second Progenitus in hand after they killed the first one" happen in, say, 5% of all games, I don't know if you need to prepare for that. I think having a broader selection of fatties instead, that can handle more kinds of situations, would be more beneficial.

Are you set on Modern? Because this would love to run Deadapult and Strongarm Tactics.

If not, a strong engine with Squees and Amalgams would be Zombie Infestation and Gravecrawlers. With Zombie infestation as a discard outlet you can reduce the number of cards like Ideas Unbound (ESPECIALLY Ideas Unbound, which is troublesome because of the double-blue-requirement. Would maybe turn your deck upside down but it WOULD be stronger, I guess. Still vulnerable to graveyard hate, but hey, you can't have it all.

That's the thing, though, I had green in the initial draft (including Allosaurus) but at some point it became obvious that I had to cut at least one colour entirely. The requirements to run Draco and at the same time as many Scrylands as possible is already challenging enough.
Starting a greener version is a good idea, though! Cut the black and white parts alltogether for the green goodies. Don't forget Durkwood Baloth :)

Coming late to the party ... anyway, here are two suggestions that would revolutionize this deck:

* You don't really need Thaumaturge + Blast/Gridlock ... all you need is Unnatural Selection! Or Opposition for that matter ...

* Add some paragraphs to your ten foot Wall of Text that is your "How to Play" section :)

And how am I supposed to cast Allosaurus Rider when I don't have any other green cards!?

The new Emrakul might fit in technically but the casting cost reduction would never be big enough. I don't run fecthlands, have zero planeswalkers and a combined total of 5 artifacts and enchantments. In most situations he would still cost me about 10 mana.

All my überexpensive spells already have an alternative casting cost build in!

It never was a shit card to begin with. It was always meant to abuse the fact it costs 8 but can actually be cast for 3. Remember, it was in Scourge, the set that focussed on exactly that, big converted mana costs. There are many cards that look for high casting costs, even from the time before Scourge. Here is a deck I made 2 years agot around that concept: http://www.mtgvault.com/puschkin/decks/pyromania/

But of course, the latest set greatly helps Scournful Egotist, especially the EMERGE mechanic. I am just saying, Scounrful Egotist had his uses before.

About the deck:
* Have a look at Skyshroud Cutter as an alternative/supplement to Egotist. It may be only 4 mana, however, you don't need any mana to deploy him.

* Also have a look at Metamorphosis which is a cheaper albeit one-shot Food Chain.

* Since you will "tutor" into your big creatures, you don't need them at 2 copies each.

* Consider cards like Scroll Rack or Brainstorm. They not only help you setting up, they can also put any fatty back to your library in the case you drew them but want them in the lib for Evolution.

* Whats the purpose of Den Protector in this? You only really need the Regrowth part of it and if that's the case, you'd be better off using Eternal Witness instead.

* Your manabase is ... suboptimal. You need almost exclusively green mana plus some blue and red. White and blue mana are never used since you'll cast your Iona, Progenitus and so on via your various tricks. Even in the rare case you are forced to hard-cast them, you'd be better off with a mana-base that supports your main colours, read: Every dualland should have green in it and all your fetchies should be able to fetch forests. That way you can always fetch/BoP 3 white mana or whatever you need. So, no place here for something like Tundra, Plateu or the like - it should be 4 Tropical Island, 4 Taiga, 1 Savannah, 1 Bayou, some rainbowlands like City of Brass and an assortment of fetchies that are able to fetch forests.

* Displacement Wave is probably way too slow to achieve anything. Note that you cannot use Food Chain mana to power it. Consider Wash Out insead (if bounce is what you want for defense).

I started a little something:
http://www.mtgvault.com/puschkin/decks/mtgvault-the-gathering/

If you want to revive the site, take action and join!

I started a little something:
http://www.mtgvault.com/puschkin/decks/mtgvault-the-gathering/

If you want to revive the site, take action and join!

It would be better to have a "deck" for each format and then, instead of decks, it lists PLAYERS that are active in this format. I did that already on a private level here and it worked (for a while at least).